constellation/bootstrapper/internal/kubernetes/kubernetes_test.go
Daniel Weiße ba4471a228 AB#2316 Configurable enforced PCRs (#361)
* Add warnings for non enforced, untrusted PCRs

* Fix global state in Config PCR map

Signed-off-by: Daniel Weiße <dw@edgeless.systems>
2022-08-12 15:59:45 +02:00

668 lines
23 KiB
Go

package kubernetes
import (
"context"
"errors"
"net"
"regexp"
"testing"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/bootstrapper/internal/kubernetes/k8sapi"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/bootstrapper/internal/kubernetes/k8sapi/resources"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/bootstrapper/role"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/internal/cloud/metadata"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/internal/logger"
"github.com/edgelesssys/constellation/internal/versions"
"github.com/stretchr/testify/assert"
"github.com/stretchr/testify/require"
"go.uber.org/goleak"
corev1 "k8s.io/api/core/v1"
kubeadm "k8s.io/kubernetes/cmd/kubeadm/app/apis/kubeadm/v1beta3"
)
func TestMain(m *testing.M) {
goleak.VerifyTestMain(m)
}
func TestInitCluster(t *testing.T) {
someErr := errors.New("failed")
serviceAccountURI := "some-service-account-uri"
masterSecret := []byte("some-master-secret")
autoscalingNodeGroups := []string{"0,10,autoscaling_group_0"}
nodeName := "node-name"
providerID := "provider-id"
privateIP := "192.0.2.1"
publicIP := "192.0.2.2"
loadbalancerIP := "192.0.2.3"
aliasIPRange := "192.0.2.0/24"
testCases := map[string]struct {
clusterUtil stubClusterUtil
kubectl stubKubectl
providerMetadata ProviderMetadata
CloudControllerManager CloudControllerManager
CloudNodeManager CloudNodeManager
ClusterAutoscaler ClusterAutoscaler
kubeconfigReader configReader
wantConfig k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML
wantErr bool
k8sVersion versions.ValidK8sVersion
}{
"kubeadm init works without metadata": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{SupportedResp: false},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{SupportedResp: false},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantConfig: k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML{
InitConfiguration: kubeadm.InitConfiguration{
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{
"node-ip": "",
"provider-id": "",
},
Name: privateIP,
},
},
ClusterConfiguration: kubeadm.ClusterConfiguration{},
},
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init works with metadata and loadbalancer": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SupportedResp: true,
SelfResp: metadata.InstanceMetadata{
Name: nodeName,
ProviderID: providerID,
VPCIP: privateIP,
PublicIP: publicIP,
AliasIPRanges: []string{aliasIPRange},
},
GetLoadBalancerIPResp: loadbalancerIP,
SupportsLoadBalancerResp: true,
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{SupportedResp: false},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantConfig: k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML{
InitConfiguration: kubeadm.InitConfiguration{
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{
"node-ip": privateIP,
"provider-id": providerID,
},
Name: nodeName,
},
},
ClusterConfiguration: kubeadm.ClusterConfiguration{
ControlPlaneEndpoint: loadbalancerIP,
APIServer: kubeadm.APIServer{
CertSANs: []string{publicIP, privateIP},
},
},
},
wantErr: false,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when retrieving metadata self": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SelfErr: someErr,
SupportedResp: true,
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when retrieving metadata subnetwork cidr": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
GetSubnetworkCIDRErr: someErr,
SupportedResp: true,
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when retrieving metadata loadbalancer ip": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
GetLoadBalancerIPErr: someErr,
SupportsLoadBalancerResp: true,
SupportedResp: true,
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when applying the init config": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{initClusterErr: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when deploying helm charts": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupHelmDeploymentsErr: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting up the join service": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupJoinServiceError: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{SupportedResp: true},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting the cloud contoller manager": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupCloudControllerManagerError: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{SupportedResp: true},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting the cloud node manager": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupCloudNodeManagerError: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{SupportedResp: true},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting the cluster autoscaler": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupAutoscalingError: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{SupportedResp: true},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when reading kubeconfig": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
ReadErr: someErr,
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting up the kms": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupKMSError: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{SupportedResp: false},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{SupportedResp: false},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"kubeadm init fails when setting up verification service": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{setupVerificationServiceErr: someErr},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{SupportedResp: false},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{SupportedResp: false},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
wantErr: true,
k8sVersion: versions.Latest,
},
"unsupported k8sVersion fails cluster creation": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
kubeconfigReader: &stubKubeconfigReader{
Kubeconfig: []byte("someKubeconfig"),
},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
CloudNodeManager: &stubCloudNodeManager{},
ClusterAutoscaler: &stubClusterAutoscaler{},
k8sVersion: "1.19",
wantErr: true,
},
}
for name, tc := range testCases {
t.Run(name, func(t *testing.T) {
assert := assert.New(t)
require := require.New(t)
kube := KubeWrapper{
clusterUtil: &tc.clusterUtil,
providerMetadata: tc.providerMetadata,
cloudControllerManager: tc.CloudControllerManager,
cloudNodeManager: tc.CloudNodeManager,
clusterAutoscaler: tc.ClusterAutoscaler,
configProvider: &stubConfigProvider{InitConfig: k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML{}},
client: &tc.kubectl,
kubeconfigReader: tc.kubeconfigReader,
getIPAddr: func() (string, error) { return privateIP, nil },
}
_, err := kube.InitCluster(
context.Background(), autoscalingNodeGroups, serviceAccountURI, string(tc.k8sVersion),
nil, nil, resources.KMSConfig{MasterSecret: masterSecret}, nil, nil, logger.NewTest(t),
)
if tc.wantErr {
assert.Error(err)
return
}
require.NoError(err)
var kubeadmConfig k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML
require.NoError(resources.UnmarshalK8SResources(tc.clusterUtil.initConfigs[0], &kubeadmConfig))
require.Equal(tc.wantConfig.ClusterConfiguration, kubeadmConfig.ClusterConfiguration)
require.Equal(tc.wantConfig.InitConfiguration, kubeadmConfig.InitConfiguration)
})
}
}
func TestJoinCluster(t *testing.T) {
someErr := errors.New("failed")
joinCommand := &kubeadm.BootstrapTokenDiscovery{
APIServerEndpoint: "192.0.2.0:6443",
Token: "kube-fake-token",
CACertHashes: []string{"sha256:a60ebe9b0879090edd83b40a4df4bebb20506bac1e51d518ff8f4505a721930f"},
}
privateIP := "192.0.2.1"
k8sVersion := versions.Latest
testCases := map[string]struct {
clusterUtil stubClusterUtil
providerMetadata ProviderMetadata
CloudControllerManager CloudControllerManager
wantConfig kubeadm.JoinConfiguration
role role.Role
wantErr bool
}{
"kubeadm join worker works without metadata": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
role: role.Worker,
wantConfig: kubeadm.JoinConfiguration{
Discovery: kubeadm.Discovery{
BootstrapToken: joinCommand,
},
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
Name: privateIP,
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{"node-ip": privateIP},
},
},
},
"kubeadm join worker works with metadata": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SupportedResp: true,
SelfResp: metadata.InstanceMetadata{
ProviderID: "provider-id",
Name: "metadata-name",
VPCIP: "192.0.2.1",
},
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
role: role.Worker,
wantConfig: kubeadm.JoinConfiguration{
Discovery: kubeadm.Discovery{
BootstrapToken: joinCommand,
},
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
Name: "metadata-name",
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{"node-ip": "192.0.2.1"},
},
},
},
"kubeadm join worker works with metadata and cloud controller manager": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SupportedResp: true,
SelfResp: metadata.InstanceMetadata{
ProviderID: "provider-id",
Name: "metadata-name",
VPCIP: "192.0.2.1",
},
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{
SupportedResp: true,
},
role: role.Worker,
wantConfig: kubeadm.JoinConfiguration{
Discovery: kubeadm.Discovery{
BootstrapToken: joinCommand,
},
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
Name: "metadata-name",
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{"node-ip": "192.0.2.1"},
},
},
},
"kubeadm join control-plane node works with metadata": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SupportedResp: true,
SelfResp: metadata.InstanceMetadata{
ProviderID: "provider-id",
Name: "metadata-name",
VPCIP: "192.0.2.1",
},
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
role: role.ControlPlane,
wantConfig: kubeadm.JoinConfiguration{
Discovery: kubeadm.Discovery{
BootstrapToken: joinCommand,
},
NodeRegistration: kubeadm.NodeRegistrationOptions{
Name: "metadata-name",
KubeletExtraArgs: map[string]string{"node-ip": "192.0.2.1"},
},
ControlPlane: &kubeadm.JoinControlPlane{
LocalAPIEndpoint: kubeadm.APIEndpoint{
AdvertiseAddress: "192.0.2.1",
BindPort: 6443,
},
},
SkipPhases: []string{"control-plane-prepare/download-certs"},
},
},
"kubeadm join worker fails when retrieving self metadata": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{
SupportedResp: true,
SelfErr: someErr,
},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
role: role.Worker,
wantErr: true,
},
"kubeadm join worker fails when applying the join config": {
clusterUtil: stubClusterUtil{joinClusterErr: someErr},
providerMetadata: &stubProviderMetadata{},
CloudControllerManager: &stubCloudControllerManager{},
role: role.Worker,
wantErr: true,
},
}
for name, tc := range testCases {
t.Run(name, func(t *testing.T) {
assert := assert.New(t)
require := require.New(t)
kube := KubeWrapper{
clusterUtil: &tc.clusterUtil,
providerMetadata: tc.providerMetadata,
cloudControllerManager: tc.CloudControllerManager,
configProvider: &stubConfigProvider{},
getIPAddr: func() (string, error) { return privateIP, nil },
}
err := kube.JoinCluster(context.Background(), joinCommand, tc.role, string(k8sVersion), logger.NewTest(t))
if tc.wantErr {
assert.Error(err)
return
}
require.NoError(err)
var joinYaml k8sapi.KubeadmJoinYAML
joinYaml, err = joinYaml.Unmarshal(tc.clusterUtil.joinConfigs[0])
require.NoError(err)
assert.Equal(tc.wantConfig, joinYaml.JoinConfiguration)
})
}
}
func TestK8sCompliantHostname(t *testing.T) {
compliantHostname := regexp.MustCompile(`^[a-z0-9]([-a-z0-9]*[a-z0-9])?(\.[a-z0-9]([-a-z0-9]*[a-z0-9])?)*$`)
testCases := map[string]struct {
hostname string
wantHostname string
}{
"azure scale set names work": {
hostname: "constellation-scale-set-bootstrappers-name_0",
wantHostname: "constellation-scale-set-bootstrappers-name-0",
},
"compliant hostname is not modified": {
hostname: "abcd-123",
wantHostname: "abcd-123",
},
"uppercase hostnames are lowercased": {
hostname: "ABCD",
wantHostname: "abcd",
},
}
for name, tc := range testCases {
t.Run(name, func(t *testing.T) {
assert := assert.New(t)
hostname := k8sCompliantHostname(tc.hostname)
assert.Equal(tc.wantHostname, hostname)
assert.Regexp(compliantHostname, hostname)
})
}
}
type stubClusterUtil struct {
installComponentsErr error
initClusterErr error
setupHelmDeploymentsErr error
setupAutoscalingError error
setupJoinServiceError error
setupCloudControllerManagerError error
setupCloudNodeManagerError error
setupKMSError error
setupAccessManagerError error
setupVerificationServiceErr error
setupGCPGuestAgentErr error
setupOLMErr error
setupNMOErr error
setupNodeOperatorErr error
joinClusterErr error
startKubeletErr error
restartKubeletErr error
initConfigs [][]byte
joinConfigs [][]byte
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) InstallComponents(ctx context.Context, version versions.ValidK8sVersion) error {
return s.installComponentsErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) InitCluster(ctx context.Context, initConfig []byte, nodeName string, ips []net.IP, log *logger.Logger) error {
s.initConfigs = append(s.initConfigs, initConfig)
return s.initClusterErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupHelmDeployments(context.Context, k8sapi.Client, []byte, k8sapi.SetupPodNetworkInput, *logger.Logger) error {
return s.setupHelmDeploymentsErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupAutoscaling(kubectl k8sapi.Client, clusterAutoscalerConfiguration resources.Marshaler, secrets resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupAutoscalingError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupJoinService(kubectl k8sapi.Client, joinServiceConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupJoinServiceError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupGCPGuestAgent(kubectl k8sapi.Client, gcpGuestAgentConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupGCPGuestAgentErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupCloudControllerManager(kubectl k8sapi.Client, cloudControllerManagerConfiguration resources.Marshaler, configMaps resources.Marshaler, secrets resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupCloudControllerManagerError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupKMS(kubectl k8sapi.Client, kmsDeployment resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupKMSError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupAccessManager(kubectl k8sapi.Client, accessManagerConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupAccessManagerError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupCloudNodeManager(kubectl k8sapi.Client, cloudNodeManagerConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupCloudNodeManagerError
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupVerificationService(kubectl k8sapi.Client, verificationServiceConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupVerificationServiceErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupOperatorLifecycleManager(ctx context.Context, kubectl k8sapi.Client, olmCRDs, olmConfiguration resources.Marshaler, crdNames []string) error {
return s.setupOLMErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupNodeMaintenanceOperator(kubectl k8sapi.Client, nodeMaintenanceOperatorConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupNMOErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) SetupNodeOperator(ctx context.Context, kubectl k8sapi.Client, nodeOperatorConfiguration resources.Marshaler) error {
return s.setupNodeOperatorErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) JoinCluster(ctx context.Context, joinConfig []byte, log *logger.Logger) error {
s.joinConfigs = append(s.joinConfigs, joinConfig)
return s.joinClusterErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) StartKubelet() error {
return s.startKubeletErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) RestartKubelet() error {
return s.restartKubeletErr
}
func (s *stubClusterUtil) FixCilium(nodeName string, log *logger.Logger) {
}
type stubConfigProvider struct {
InitConfig k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML
JoinConfig k8sapi.KubeadmJoinYAML
}
func (s *stubConfigProvider) InitConfiguration(_ bool, _ versions.ValidK8sVersion) k8sapi.KubeadmInitYAML {
return s.InitConfig
}
func (s *stubConfigProvider) JoinConfiguration(_ bool) k8sapi.KubeadmJoinYAML {
s.JoinConfig = k8sapi.KubeadmJoinYAML{
JoinConfiguration: kubeadm.JoinConfiguration{
Discovery: kubeadm.Discovery{
BootstrapToken: &kubeadm.BootstrapTokenDiscovery{},
},
},
}
return s.JoinConfig
}
type stubKubectl struct {
ApplyErr error
createConfigMapErr error
AddTolerationsToDeploymentErr error
AddTNodeSelectorsToDeploymentErr error
waitForCRDsErr error
resources []resources.Marshaler
kubeconfigs [][]byte
}
func (s *stubKubectl) Apply(resources resources.Marshaler, forceConflicts bool) error {
s.resources = append(s.resources, resources)
return s.ApplyErr
}
func (s *stubKubectl) SetKubeconfig(kubeconfig []byte) {
s.kubeconfigs = append(s.kubeconfigs, kubeconfig)
}
func (s *stubKubectl) CreateConfigMap(ctx context.Context, configMap corev1.ConfigMap) error {
return s.createConfigMapErr
}
func (s *stubKubectl) AddTolerationsToDeployment(ctx context.Context, tolerations []corev1.Toleration, name string, namespace string) error {
return s.AddTolerationsToDeploymentErr
}
func (s *stubKubectl) AddNodeSelectorsToDeployment(ctx context.Context, selectors map[string]string, name string, namespace string) error {
return s.AddTNodeSelectorsToDeploymentErr
}
func (s *stubKubectl) WaitForCRDs(ctx context.Context, crds []string) error {
return s.waitForCRDsErr
}
type stubKubeconfigReader struct {
Kubeconfig []byte
ReadErr error
}
func (s *stubKubeconfigReader) ReadKubeconfig() ([]byte, error) {
return s.Kubeconfig, s.ReadErr
}