decentralized-id.github.io/_posts/government/europe/2020-01-11-europe.md

title	layout	description	excerpt	permalink	canonical_url	categories	tags	header	last_modified_at
European Digital Identity and SSI	single	A digital identity available to all Europeans, enabling access to digital services across the EU and control over which information is shared with third parties	By using the European Digital Identity, the user only has to select the necessary documents that are stored locally on his digital wallet to reply to the bank’s request. Then, verifiable digital documents are created and sent securely for verification to the bank, who can then continue with the application process.	/government/europe/	https://decentralized-id.com/government/europe/	Region	Ethereum uPort Europe EU Zug Finland Spain Netherlands Germany Catalonia ESSIFlab eIDAS EBSI Verifiable Credentials W3C IDUnion Aries Indy	image caption teaser /images/european_union-header.webp [image source](https://www.fidh.org/en/international-advocacy/european-union/eu-budget-joint-call-by-civil-society-to-reverse-cuts-to-the-ndici) /images/europe_teaser.webp	2023-06-15

General

• @EIC2022 Centralized & Decentralized Identity converging 2022-05-18 Martin Kuppinger

  For me, the most relevant new topic and trend was to finally see the convergence of decentralized identities (DID) and traditional approaches on IAM starting. DID, also referred to as SSI (Self Sovereign Identity) or verifiable credentials, is a concept where the user has a wallet that holds proofs of identities and attributes.

• State of SSI in Europe and Necessity for Network-of-Networks (convened by Sovrin) 2021-05-06 Andre Kudra

  3. Hyperledger Indy and Aries technology stack
  4. ‘Network of networks’ which has been a key concept at the Sovrin Foundation
  5. The topic is meant to be a conversation as an outline based on material information which can be shared publicly
  6. EBSI is one of the funded projects from the EU
  7. ESSIF is one of the projects in this portfolio - have issued a request for proposal for consulting (not in the network of networks topic but other areas)
  8. Findy (Finland) - yet to go live. Has public and private partners.
  9. Projects underway at Spain and other member nations in EU
  10. Substantial funding behind Indy based technology stack deployments are being seen
  11. Germany has 3 major streams active in the identity space

EU

• The European Digital Identity Regulation 2023-04-08

  The Regulation amends Regulation (EU) 910/2014 on electronic identification and trust services for electronic transactions in the internal market (‘the eIDAS Regulation’). This amendment is required, as digitalisation of all functions of society has increased dramatically. The provision of both public and private services is increasingly becoming digital after the COVID-19 pandemic.

• Commission puts forward declaration on digital rights and principles for everyone in the EU 2022-01-26 EU Commission

  The draft declaration covers key rights and principles for the digital transformation, such as placing people and their rights at its centre, supporting solidarity and inclusion, ensuring the freedom of choice online, fostering participation in the digital public space, increasing safety, security and empowerment of individuals, and promoting the sustainability of the digital future.

  These rights and principles should accompany people in the EU in their everyday life: affordable and high-speed digital connectivity everywhere and for everybody, well-equipped classrooms and digitally skilled teachers, seamless access to public services, a safe digital environment for children, disconnecting after working hours, obtaining easy-to-understand information on the environmental impact of our digital products, controlling how their personal data are used and with whom they are shared.

• Global state of SSI and how to build on it: EU report 2022-01-24

  The European Union’s cybersecurity agency has been busy typing up its research. The latest report is an overview of Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) technologies, standards, providers and regulation from around the world with a view to their relevance applicability to the EU project for digital identity for individuals and businesses.

  • Digital Identity: Leveraging the SSI Concept to Build Trust

    It critically assesses the current literature and reports on the current technological landscape of SSI and existing eID solutions, as well as the standards, communities, and pilot projects that are presently developing in support of these solutions. This study takes a wide view of decentralised electronic identity, considers possible architectural elements and mechanisms of governance, and identifies security risks and opportunities presented by SSI in view of cross-border interoperability, mutual recognition, and technology neutrality as required by eIDAS.

• Joining forces towards European digital credentials 2021-11-30 European Commission

  The European BlockchainPartnership is a group of 29 countries and the EC. We help public administrations accelerate the creation of trustworthy cross border digital services.9Having this opportunity in mind, the EBSI (European BlockchainServices Infrastructure) has been developed.

  Our vision is to accelerate the creation of cross-border services and put blockchainat the service of public administrations for the purpose of verifying information, making the services trustworthy.

  EBSI is the first EU-wide blockchaininfrastructure, driven by the public sector, in full respect of European values and regulations. EBSI is supported by 29 countries (All EU Member States, Norway and Lichtenstein) and the EC forming the European BlockchainPartnership (EBP).

• The “Secure Platform” Concept for Europe - a Trusted and Secure Foundation for a Human-Centric Digital World. 2021-06-04 MyData

  The following article discusses the technical requirements needed to protect our personal data and to ensure a safer digital world. It presents solutions for creating an open and secure IT infrastructure where data privacy can always be guaranteed. The article has been written by esatus, founding member and lead of the “Secure Platform” working group, a thematic group within the IT Security Association Germany (TeleTrusT).

• TechCrunch Europe wants to go its own way on digital identity 2021-06-03

  Alongside today’s regulatory proposal they’ve put out a recommendation, inviting member states to “establish a common toolbox by September 2022 and to start the necessary preparatory work immediately” — with a goal of publishing the agreed toolbox in October 2022 and starting pilot projects (based on the agreed technical framework) sometime thereafter.

  “This toolbox should include the technical architecture, standards and guidelines for best practices,” the commission adds, eliding the large cans of worms being firmly cracked open.

• Digital Identity for all Europeans 2021-06

The European Digital Identity will be available to EU citizens, residents, and businesses who want to identify themselves or provide confirmation of certain personal information. It can be used for both online and offline public and private services across the EU.

Every EU citizen and resident in the Union will be able to use a personal digital wallet.

• Overview of Member States' eID strategies 2021-04-07

  With this in mind, the following report provides an overview of the national approaches to electronic identification, describing how the 27 Member States are rolling out eID solutions to ensure that digital services can be securely accessed both at national and at European level. The report focusses on the approaches towards eID outlined in national strategy documents, together with other supporting documentation and web resources, with the aim of offering a thorough understanding of the eID state of play across Europe. This understanding of national strategies can feed into discussions on future EU-level action on eID.

• A trusted and secure European e-ID - Regulation 2021-05-28

  By offering a European Digital Identity framework based on the revision of the current one, at least 80% of citizens should be able to use a digital ID solution to access key public services by 2030. [...] The legal instrument aims to provide, for cross-border use: – access to highly secure and trustworthy electronic identity solutions, – that public and private services can rely on trusted and secure digital identity solutions, – that natural and legal persons are empowered to use digital identity solutions, – that these solutions are linked to a variety of attributes and allow for the targeted sharing of identity data limited to the needs of the specific service requested, – acceptance of qualified trust services in the EU and equal conditions for their provision.

• End-To-End Encryption is Too Important to Be Proprietary 2022-05-02 Cory Doctorow

  The EU’s Digital Markets Act (DMA) is set to become law; it will require the biggest tech companies in the world (Apple, Google and Facebook, and maybe a few others) to open up their instant messaging services (iMessage, Facebook Messenger, Whatsapp, and maybe a few others) so that smaller messaging services can plug into them. These smaller services might be run by startups, nonprofits, co-ops, or even individual tinkerers.

See [EBSI]({% link _posts/government/europe/2023-06-08-ebsi.md %}), [eIDAS]({% link _posts/government/europe/2020-01-06-eIDAS.md %}), and [eSSIF-Lab]({% link _posts/history/2023-06-08-essif-lab.md%})

Regional

Findynet - Finland

• Finnish tech co-op receives government grant to develop a self-sovereign identity network 2022-09-02 TheNews

  The Finnish Government has awarded a €3m (£2.6m) grant to Findynet Cooperative for a pilot project aiming to build a self-sovereign identity network.

• The Findynet Cooperative receives a government grant to develop a trusted way to share information in electronic interactions 2022-08-31 Findy.fi

  The aim of this public-private cooperation is to strengthen Finland’s leading position in digitalization and support the emergence of investments in new digital services.

• The Missing Network Layer Model 2022-03-05 Findy Epic Post

  You might think that I have lost my mind. We have just reported that our Indy SDK based DID agency is AIP 1.0 compatible, and everything is wonderful. What’s going on?

Spain

• Verifiable Credentials for Digital Identity Projects 2021-08-26

  The Spanish Association for Standardization (UNE) has recently published the UNE 71307-1 Digital Enabling Technologies Standard. This is the first global standard on decentralized identity management, based on Blockchain and Distributed Ledger Technologies (DLT).

Netherlands

• Deployment of a Blockchain-Based Self-Sovereign Identity - Delft 2019-06-07

  This solution for making identities Self-Sovereign, builds on a generic provable claim model for which attestations of truth from third parties need to be collected. The claim model is then shown to be both blockchain structure and proof method agnostic. Four different implementations in support of these two claim model properties are shown to offer sub-second performance for claim creation and claim verification. Through the properties of Self-Sovereign Identity, legally valid status and acceptable performance, our solution is considered to be fit for adoption by the general public

• TU Delft helps develop digital ID for use on your phone 2018-06-07

  In addition to your passport and driving licence, a phone application that enables you to prove your identity quickly and securely and also offers even more privacy options could soon be possible. As part of the Dutch Blockchain Coalition, Delft University of Technology (TU Delft, The Netherlands) has joined forces with the Netherlands Identity Data Agency (RvIG), a division of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Kingdom Relations (BZK), IDEMIA (the current manufacturer of Dutch passports) and law firm CMS, in developing an initial prototype for a digital stamp that could fulfil this purpose in the future. This digital identity is based on TU Delft’s innovative blockchain technology, known as Trustchain. The prototype was demonstrated at a BZK event held on 7 June. After the summer, a consumer trial of this technology will be launched in two Dutch municipalities.

• TrustChain: A Sybil-resistant scalable blockchain - Presentation 2018-03-22

  Source: Future Generation Computer Systems, Article in Press, Sep. 2017

• Dutch Blockchain Coalition
  • Action Agenda 2017-06-15

    The Dutch Blockchain Action Agenda has been jointly developed by industry, government and knowledge institutions. Together they have assumed a leading role and joint responsibility for the success of the Action Agenda of the Dutch Blockchain Coalition. The coalition is permanently open for experts and stakeholders who want to make a contribution so that the coalition realises the maximum result. In this process, it will be continuously considered where the best match lies between the expertise offered and the interest of the programme, which should be viewed as a rolling agenda. The collaboration is for a period of several years, can assume different working practices, and in mutual consultation will be harmonised with the possibilities and needs of the partners involved.

• Self-Sovereign Identity Framework and Blockchain 2017-06-29

  Seven participants of the project (Accenture, APG, Brightlands, Chamber of Commerce, De Volksbank, Rabobank, and TNO) are developing a self-sovereign identity framework (SSIF) for the creation, validation and revocation of such identities that can be used in conjunction with blockchain technologies and the (disruptive) applications that are enabled by such technologies. The goal is to specify, validate and ultimately build a trustworthy, open digital infrastructure for self-sovereign identities that is secure, decentralized, open source, supports privacy (e.g., GDPR compliance) in multiple roles, and lacks a single point of failure or large information honey-pot. We aim to follow well-established requirements for user-centric identity systems

Germany

• Reinventing Government with Technology - Sebastian Manhart 2021-12-01 KuppingerCole

  Raj Hegde is joined by Sebastian Manhart - Technical Advisor on Digital Identity for the German Chancellery to explore governmental reform and understand stakeholder expectations behind the rollout of digital identity projects in the post-COVID era.

• "Irresponsible and Dangerous" 2021-12-10 Spigel

  The ID wallet for the digital driving license had a digital accident: A week before the federal elections, it was presented to the public by Transport Minister Andreas Scheuer (CSU), just under a week later it had disappeared from the Apple and Google app stores .

• ID Wallet: The German government had long known about IT security vulnerabilities 2021-10-30 Market Research Telecast

  The BSI expresses the problem as follows: “The authentication of the user required to carry out a hotel check-in on the basis of the factors possession (” link secret “) and knowledge (” PIN “) takes place exclusively on the basis of key material that is stored in the Wallet app is saved. ” No specially secured electronic storage and processing medium such as a “secure element” integrated in smartphones is used.

• Digital identities: German-Finnish cooperation agreed 2021-09-22 Bundesregierung

  The content of the joint declaration is close bilateral cooperation in the development of a cross-border ecosystem of digital identities based on the principles of Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI).

Secure Digital Identities

• ID-Ideal as an integrated solution 2021-11-17 Jolocom The idea behind ID-Ideal is to create a basis for existing and future identity services. To achieve this, interoperability between the individual ecosystems is necessary. For this reason, the project mainly focuses on key aspects:

  A) Trust Framework: harmonize various ID services and create standards for secure digital identities

  B) High relevance to everyday life and very good usability to increase the incentive

  C) Establishing a TrustNest initiative: an open community that promotes certification, exchange, and further development

• IDunion Introduction and AMA (there will be another one tomorrow!) 2021-05-06 Andre Kudra, IDunion

  IDunion enables self-determined identities based on Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) technologies Hyperledger Indy and Hyperledger Aries. The aim of the IDunion organisation is to create an open ecosystem for decentralised identity management, which can be used  worldwide and is based on European values and regulations.

  IDunion is also a project co-funded by the German Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs (BMWi) as part of the Showcases Secure Digital Identities program

• Showcase programme “Secure Digital Identities” 2020-06 Digitale Technoligen DE

  With this innovation competition, the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action (BMWK) is directly contributing to Germany’s digital sovereignty and data security on the Internet. The measure aims to strengthen the confidence of citizens and companies in digital transformation. The envisaged proposals should also be aligned with the needs and opportunities of small and medium-sized enterprises and enable them to implement and use Secure Digital Identities.

Catalonia

• Catalan digital ID program using Blockchain wins government approval 2019-09-26

  The newly announced Catalan digital ID initiative will use blockchain technology to empower citizen service in the northeastern corner of Spain. The regional government of Catalan reportedly has “launched a new project to create decentralized and self-sovereign digital identity based on distributed ledger technology.”

• Catalan government announces self-sovereign identity project 2019-09-09

  The government of Catalonia announced its plans for self-sovereign identities (SSIs) for citizens based on blockchain technology. The project, named IdentiCAT, was revealed by the President of Catalonia Quim Torra and will allow citizens to be the “owner, manager and exclusive custod[ian] of his identity and data”.

• Catalonia Announces Decentralized ID System the Govt Won’t Control 2019-09-09

  President Quim Torra and Minister of Digital Policies and Administration Jordi Puigneró announced the project on Sept. 7, local media outlet VilaWeb reported. Notably, the government says it will not have access to citizens' data.

Spain

• Alastria

  a non-profit consortium building a national blockchain ecosystem for Spain. The security and veracity of information will be ensured through the identification of natural and legal persons, while at the same time allowing citizens to have control over their personal information in a transparent way following the guidelines set by the European Union.

• alastria/alastria-identity

  At this moment, this solution has been developed and tested for Quorum (Geth) on the Alastria Red-T network. More information about its nodes and the network can be found in the alastria-node repository. In the future, the objetive is that this works with other Alastria networks such as Besu Red-B or Hyperledger Fabric Red-H.

Interop

• Validated ID is set to complete the S4EDI20 interoperability tests 2022-09-18 ValidatedID

  This represents the last phase of the AS4EDI20 project to implement the CEF eDelivery AS4 profile in Europe. This project is co-financed by the European Commission through the CEF Telecom program and managed by HaDEA, with action number 2020-EU-IA-0024.

• A pilot project for interoperable decentralised identity between Aigües de Barcelona, CaixaBank and Validated ID 2022-08-09 Validated ID

  The lines of action of the laboratory are framed in six blocks: resilient water resources, the impact of global change; efficient infrastructure management; the environment and health; water and energy; and water demand management. The projects developed contribute to the achievement of one or more Sustainable Development Goals, putting the citizen at the center of digital transformation and advocating a perspective on technological humanism.

• Building interoperable self-sovereign identity for Europe TNO Oskar van Deventer

  ways to build an SSI ecosystem and architecture together that is interoperable and technologically mature fit for society and funding opportunities for SSI projects through grants.

• Adopting eID in Europe and Beyond State of Identity

  Digital identity is now recognized as a key building block in digitizing public administration; however, it requires interoperability with private sector use cases to drive value for its citizens.

• Three Governments enabling digital identity interoperability Heather Vescent

  On September 15, 2021, I moderated a panel with representatives from the United States Government, the Canadian Government, and the European Commission. Below is an edited excerpt from the panel

Organization

• European Union Digital Identity Wallet Consortium EUDI Wallet Consortium

  The EU Digital Wallet Consortium (EWC) is a joint effort to successfully leverage the benefits of the proposed EU digital identity in the form of Digital Travel Credentials across the Member States. The EWC intends to build on the Reference Wallet Application to enable a use case focused on Digital Travel Credentials.

• Self-Sovereign Identity Working Group European Blockchain Association in collaboration with the European Commission

  The European Blockchain Association e. V. identified the potential for better communication, coordination and guidance in the European SSI community. Right now, many enterprises and organisations are building their own SSI solutions by implementing the existing standards and protocols. Since all these parties do similar work and have to face similar problems, it is critical for the community to share these learnings and experiences openly. To facilitate this process, the European Blockchain Association e. V. has founded an SSI Working Group which is open to participation from organisations, enterprises and individuals.

Background

• Control over data still a long way off according to research into Self-Sovereign Identity 2021-10-20 iBestuur

  In their final recommendations, the researchers from INNOPAY and TNO argue that in view of the social value of digital data exchange, the government would do well to play a driving role in the further consolidation of the SSI playing field. That starts with creating clarity about the relationship between the Digital Government Act and the EU Digital Identity Wallet.

• Blockchain-enabled Self-Sovereign Identity 2021-09-06

  Martin Schäffner, the initiator of the EuSSI Working Group of the European Blockchain Association and expert in Self-Sovereign Identity, explains the concept of Self-Sovereign Identity and how it differentiates from conventional digital identities.

• The Roles of Government & The Private Sector in a Digital ID Program with Sebastian Manhart 2021-08-13 Northern Block

  we dive into what’s happening within the Digital ID landscape within Europe. Sebastian Manhart is very well positioned between policy and technology in the European Union. In this episode of SSI Orbit, he shares his experiences and future projections.

• Data Sovereignty and Trusted Online Identity 2021-07-28 IEEE Beyond Standards

  The panel discussed the creation of self-sovereign identification from three viewpoints – the government, the private sector, and the citizens.

  1. The government could lead the way, with a centralized public key infrastructure. The EU EIDAS regulation, adopted in 2014, established electronic identification based on such an infrastructure. Uptake has been a challenge with this approach, however. Some countries have seen high adoption rates, such as Estonia, but other countries, such as Germany, still see a low adoption rate.
  2. In a second scenario, the private sector could potentially lead the effort — there are already companies that provide us with secure ID. Some people, however, would be concerned about data privacy.
  3. A third path could involve handing back some control to citizens. One example of such an approach is the European Self Sovereign Identity Framework developed by the EU Commission. Here the control lies neither with a centralized government service nor with private companies, but is given to the citizens.

• The European Single Identity System “Back to the Future” 2020-12-19 EEMA

  Chair: Steve Pannifer, COO, Consult Hyperion Steve Purser, Head of Core Operations, ENISA Tolis Apladas, Program Manager of eIdentity and eSigning Services, EU Commission Detlef Hühnlein, Director, go.eIDAS e.V

• EU report signposts route to blockchain ID verification 2019-05-30

  “There are persistent – and increasingly serious – problems with the way digital identity works,” says the report, ‘Blockchain and Digital Identity’. “For individuals, but also for businesses and governments, the status quo is becoming less and less tenable.”

  But the report maps out a path to improving the current digital ID landscape, in which citizens typically use a huge range of systems to access public and private services. “It is now possible to build new identity frameworks based on the concept of decentralised identities,” its authors write, setting out six recommendations for public sector business owners and digital professionals.

• EU Report Considers Blockchain-Based Digital Identities, Tokenized National Currencies 2018-12-07
  • EU Blockchain Forum - BLOCKCHAIN FOR GOVERNMENT AND PUBLIC SERVICES
• EU BLOCKCHAIN OBSERVATORY AND FORUM—Workshop Report e-Identity 2018-11-07
• Government services and digital identity 2018-08-01 EUBlockchainForum

  The theme of this paper is the use of blockchain and distributed ledger technology for government services, and digital identity in relation to those. The scope for the state-of-the-art is global, but conclusions and recommendations focus on the significance and barriers in the European context. We assume general familiarity with blockchain and smart contract technology. For the purposes of this document, the essential features are that a blockchain has no central data controller or storage, and that it is an append-only immutable record store with reliable timestamping. More specific details, such as consensus mechanism, which vary from one blockchain network to another, are omitted.

Bundlesblok Position Paper

• A position paper on blockchain enabled identity and the road ahead 2018-10 Identity Working Group of the German Blockchain Association [article]

  Appendix VII – Pilot Projects and Proof of Concepts

  • TrustNet (Finland)

    TrustNet is a heavily industry-networked research project that focuses on developing a blockchain-based distributed environment for personal data management following the MyData principles.

  • Alastria (Spain)

    The security and veracity of information will be ensured through the identification of natural and legal persons, while at the same time allowing citizens to have control over their personal information in a transparent way following the guidelines set by the European Union.

  • Blockchain on the Move (Antwerp, Belgium)

    As a cooperation project between the city of Antwerp, the Flemish Information Agency, Digipolis and the Flemish ICT organization (V-ICT-OR), the project Blockchain on the Move is a pilot project on SSI and its application on the municipal level. It explores the potential of SSI for e-Government use cases and State-issued credentials for private sector B2B and B2C use cases.

  • City of Zug (UPort and ti&m)

    With the SSI implemented in Zug, users can now pay their parking fees, register for elections or perform online sign on for e-government services33. The benefits range for the city of Zug are low infrastructure requirements, decreased security risks, cost effectiveness, GDPR compliance and scalability.

  • Danube Tech (Austria)

    In a SSI proof-of-concept during the first half of 2018, 3 banks, an insurance company, the Austrian Post, and an institution representing notaries has cooperated to implement a range of use cases based on DIDs, Verifiable Credentials, Sovrin, and the XDI protocol. The use cases included:

    • digital ID onboarding for existing clients,
    • SSO for new clients,KYC
    • sharing of KYC data between organizations,
    • dynamic data verification (change-of-address),
    • secure communication (e-mail with ID confirmation),
    • change of identity service providers,
    • personal ID verification in a peer-to-peer marketplace