Add experimental configuration option to allow disabling legacy Prometheus metric names. (#13540)

Co-authored-by: David Robertson <davidr@element.io>

changelog.d/13540.misc

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Add experimental configuration option to allow disabling legacy Prometheus metric names.

synapse/app/_base.py

@@ -266,15 +266,48 @@ def register_start(
     reactor.callWhenRunning(lambda: defer.ensureDeferred(wrapper()))
 
 
-def listen_metrics(bind_addresses: Iterable[str], port: int) -> None:
+def listen_metrics(
+    bind_addresses: Iterable[str], port: int, enable_legacy_metric_names: bool
+) -> None:
     """
     Start Prometheus metrics server.
     """
-    from synapse.metrics import RegistryProxy, start_http_server
+    from prometheus_client import start_http_server as start_http_server_prometheus
+
+    from synapse.metrics import (
+        RegistryProxy,
+        start_http_server as start_http_server_legacy,
+    )
 
     for host in bind_addresses:
         logger.info("Starting metrics listener on %s:%d", host, port)
-        start_http_server(port, addr=host, registry=RegistryProxy)
+        if enable_legacy_metric_names:
+            start_http_server_legacy(port, addr=host, registry=RegistryProxy)
+        else:
+            _set_prometheus_client_use_created_metrics(False)
+            start_http_server_prometheus(port, addr=host, registry=RegistryProxy)
+
+
+def _set_prometheus_client_use_created_metrics(new_value: bool) -> None:
+    """
+    Sets whether prometheus_client should expose `_created`-suffixed metrics for
+    all gauges, histograms and summaries.
+    There is no programmatic way to disable this without poking at internals;
+    the proper way is to use an environment variable which prometheus_client
+    loads at import time.
+
+    The motivation for disabling these `_created` metrics is that they're
+    a waste of space as they're not useful but they take up space in Prometheus.
+    """
+
+    import prometheus_client.metrics
+
+    if hasattr(prometheus_client.metrics, "_use_created"):
+        prometheus_client.metrics._use_created = new_value
+    else:
+        logger.error(
+            "Can't disable `_created` metrics in prometheus_client (brittle hack broken?)"
+        )
 
 
 def listen_manhole(

synapse/app/generic_worker.py

@@ -412,7 +412,11 @@ class GenericWorkerServer(HomeServer):
                         "enable_metrics is not True!"
                     )
                 else:
-                    _base.listen_metrics(listener.bind_addresses, listener.port)
+                    _base.listen_metrics(
+                        listener.bind_addresses,
+                        listener.port,
+                        enable_legacy_metric_names=self.config.metrics.enable_legacy_metrics,
+                    )
             else:
                 logger.warning("Unsupported listener type: %s", listener.type)
 

synapse/app/homeserver.py

@@ -307,7 +307,11 @@ class SynapseHomeServer(HomeServer):
                         "enable_metrics is not True!"
                     )
                 else:
-                    _base.listen_metrics(listener.bind_addresses, listener.port)
+                    _base.listen_metrics(
+                        listener.bind_addresses,
+                        listener.port,
+                        enable_legacy_metric_names=self.config.metrics.enable_legacy_metrics,
+                    )
             else:
                 # this shouldn't happen, as the listener type should have been checked
                 # during parsing

synapse/config/metrics.py

@@ -42,6 +42,35 @@ class MetricsConfig(Config):
 
     def read_config(self, config: JsonDict, **kwargs: Any) -> None:
         self.enable_metrics = config.get("enable_metrics", False)
+
+        """
+        ### `enable_legacy_metrics` (experimental)
+
+        **Experimental: this option may be removed or have its behaviour
+        changed at any time, with no notice.**
+
+        Set to `true` to publish both legacy and non-legacy Prometheus metric names,
+        or to `false` to only publish non-legacy Prometheus metric names.
+        Defaults to `true`. Has no effect if `enable_metrics` is `false`.
+
+        Legacy metric names include:
+        - metrics containing colons in the name, such as `synapse_util_caches_response_cache:hits`, because colons are supposed to be reserved for user-defined recording rules;
+        - counters that don't end with the `_total` suffix, such as `synapse_federation_client_sent_edus`, therefore not adhering to the OpenMetrics standard.
+
+        These legacy metric names are unconventional and not compliant with OpenMetrics standards.
+        They are included for backwards compatibility.
+
+        Example configuration:
+        ```yaml
+        enable_legacy_metrics: false
+        ```
+
+        See https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/11106 for context.
+
+        *Since v1.67.0.*
+        """
+        self.enable_legacy_metrics = config.get("enable_legacy_metrics", True)
+
         self.report_stats = config.get("report_stats", None)
         self.report_stats_endpoint = config.get(
             "report_stats_endpoint", "https://matrix.org/report-usage-stats/push"

synapse/metrics/__init__.py

@@ -46,12 +46,12 @@ from twisted.python.threadpool import ThreadPool
 
 # This module is imported for its side effects; flake8 needn't warn that it's unused.
 import synapse.metrics._reactor_metrics  # noqa: F401
-from synapse.metrics._exposition import (
+from synapse.metrics._gc import MIN_TIME_BETWEEN_GCS, install_gc_manager
+from synapse.metrics._legacy_exposition import (
     MetricsResource,
     generate_latest,
     start_http_server,
 )
-from synapse.metrics._gc import MIN_TIME_BETWEEN_GCS, install_gc_manager
 from synapse.metrics._types import Collector
 from synapse.util import SYNAPSE_VERSION
 

synapse/metrics/_legacy_exposition.py

@@ -80,7 +80,27 @@ def sample_line(line: Sample, name: str) -> str:
     return "{}{} {}{}\n".format(name, labelstr, floatToGoString(line.value), timestamp)
 
 
+# Mapping from new metric names to legacy metric names.
+# We translate these back to their old names when exposing them through our
+# legacy vendored exporter.
+# Only this legacy exposition module applies these name changes.
+LEGACY_METRIC_NAMES = {
+    "synapse_util_caches_cache_hits": "synapse_util_caches_cache:hits",
+    "synapse_util_caches_cache_size": "synapse_util_caches_cache:size",
+    "synapse_util_caches_cache_evicted_size": "synapse_util_caches_cache:evicted_size",
+    "synapse_util_caches_cache_total": "synapse_util_caches_cache:total",
+    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache_size": "synapse_util_caches_response_cache:size",
+    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache_hits": "synapse_util_caches_response_cache:hits",
+    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache_evicted_size": "synapse_util_caches_response_cache:evicted_size",
+    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache_total": "synapse_util_caches_response_cache:total",
+}
+
+
 def generate_latest(registry: CollectorRegistry, emit_help: bool = False) -> bytes:
+    """
+    Generate metrics in legacy format. Modern metrics are generated directly
+    by prometheus-client.
+    """
 
     # Trigger the cache metrics to be rescraped, which updates the common
     # metrics but do not produce metrics themselves
@@ -94,7 +114,8 @@ def generate_latest(registry: CollectorRegistry, emit_help: bool = False) -> byt
             # No samples, don't bother.
             continue
 
-        mname = metric.name
+        # Translate to legacy metric name if it has one.
+        mname = LEGACY_METRIC_NAMES.get(metric.name, metric.name)
         mnewname = metric.name
         mtype = metric.type
 
@@ -124,7 +145,7 @@ def generate_latest(registry: CollectorRegistry, emit_help: bool = False) -> byt
         om_samples: Dict[str, List[str]] = {}
         for s in metric.samples:
             for suffix in ["_created", "_gsum", "_gcount"]:
-                if s.name == metric.name + suffix:
+                if s.name == mname + suffix:
                     # OpenMetrics specific sample, put in a gauge at the end.
                     # (these come from gaugehistograms which don't get renamed,
                     # so no need to faff with mnewname)
@@ -140,12 +161,12 @@ def generate_latest(registry: CollectorRegistry, emit_help: bool = False) -> byt
             if emit_help:
                 output.append(
                     "# HELP {}{} {}\n".format(
-                        metric.name,
+                        mname,
                         suffix,
                         metric.documentation.replace("\\", r"\\").replace("\n", r"\n"),
                     )
                 )
-            output.append(f"# TYPE {metric.name}{suffix} gauge\n")
+            output.append(f"# TYPE {mname}{suffix} gauge\n")
             output.extend(lines)
 
         # Get rid of the weird colon things while we're at it
@@ -170,11 +191,12 @@ def generate_latest(registry: CollectorRegistry, emit_help: bool = False) -> byt
             # Get rid of the OpenMetrics specific samples (we should already have
             # dealt with them above anyway.)
             for suffix in ["_created", "_gsum", "_gcount"]:
-                if s.name == metric.name + suffix:
+                if s.name == mname + suffix:
                     break
             else:
+                sample_name = LEGACY_METRIC_NAMES.get(s.name, s.name)
                 output.append(
-                    sample_line(s, s.name.replace(":total", "").replace(":", "_"))
+                    sample_line(s, sample_name.replace(":total", "").replace(":", "_"))
                 )
 
     return "".join(output).encode("utf-8")

synapse/util/caches/__init__.py

@@ -34,10 +34,10 @@ TRACK_MEMORY_USAGE = False
 caches_by_name: Dict[str, Sized] = {}
 collectors_by_name: Dict[str, "CacheMetric"] = {}
 
-cache_size = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache:size", "", ["name"])
+cache_size = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache_size", "", ["name"])
-cache_hits = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache:hits", "", ["name"])
+cache_hits = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache_hits", "", ["name"])
-cache_evicted = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache:evicted_size", "", ["name", "reason"])
+cache_evicted = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache_evicted_size", "", ["name", "reason"])
-cache_total = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache:total", "", ["name"])
+cache_total = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache_total", "", ["name"])
 cache_max_size = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_cache_max_size", "", ["name"])
 cache_memory_usage = Gauge(
     "synapse_util_caches_cache_size_bytes",
@@ -45,12 +45,12 @@ cache_memory_usage = Gauge(
     ["name"],
 )
 
-response_cache_size = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache:size", "", ["name"])
+response_cache_size = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache_size", "", ["name"])
-response_cache_hits = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache:hits", "", ["name"])
+response_cache_hits = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache_hits", "", ["name"])
 response_cache_evicted = Gauge(
-    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache:evicted_size", "", ["name", "reason"]
+    "synapse_util_caches_response_cache_evicted_size", "", ["name", "reason"]
 )
-response_cache_total = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache:total", "", ["name"])
+response_cache_total = Gauge("synapse_util_caches_response_cache_total", "", ["name"])
 
 
 class EvictionReason(Enum):

tests/test_metrics.py

@@ -12,7 +12,16 @@
 # WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
 # See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
 # limitations under the License.
+try:
+    from importlib import metadata
+except ImportError:
+    import importlib_metadata as metadata  # type: ignore[no-redef]
 
+from unittest.mock import patch
+
+from pkg_resources import parse_version
+
+from synapse.app._base import _set_prometheus_client_use_created_metrics
 from synapse.metrics import REGISTRY, InFlightGauge, generate_latest
 from synapse.util.caches.deferred_cache import DeferredCache
 
@@ -162,3 +171,30 @@ class CacheMetricsTests(unittest.HomeserverTestCase):
 
         self.assertEqual(items["synapse_util_caches_cache_size"], "1.0")
         self.assertEqual(items["synapse_util_caches_cache_max_size"], "777.0")
+
+
+class PrometheusMetricsHackTestCase(unittest.HomeserverTestCase):
+    if parse_version(metadata.version("prometheus_client")) < parse_version("0.14.0"):
+        skip = "prometheus-client too old"
+
+    def test_created_metrics_disabled(self) -> None:
+        """
+        Tests that a brittle hack, to disable `_created` metrics, works.
+        This involves poking at the internals of prometheus-client.
+        It's not the end of the world if this doesn't work.
+
+        This test gives us a way to notice if prometheus-client changes
+        their internals.
+        """
+        import prometheus_client.metrics
+
+        PRIVATE_FLAG_NAME = "_use_created"
+
+        # By default, the pesky `_created` metrics are enabled.
+        # Check this assumption is still valid.
+        self.assertTrue(getattr(prometheus_client.metrics, PRIVATE_FLAG_NAME))
+
+        with patch("prometheus_client.metrics") as mock:
+            setattr(mock, PRIVATE_FLAG_NAME, True)
+            _set_prometheus_client_use_created_metrics(False)
+            self.assertFalse(getattr(mock, PRIVATE_FLAG_NAME, False))