Implemented config option sso.update_profile_information to keep user's display name in sync with the SSO displayname.
Signed-off-by: Johannes Kanefendt <johannes.kanefendt@krzn.de>
We were repeatedly looking up a config option in a loop (using the
unclassed config style), which is expensive enough that it can cause
large CPU usage.
An accidental mis-ordering of operations during #6739 technically allowed an incoming knock event over federation in before checking it against any configured Third Party Access Rules modules.
This PR corrects that by performing the TPAR check *before* persisting the event.
This could cause a minor data leak if someone defined a non-restricted join rule
with an allow key or used a restricted join rule in an older room version, but this is
unlikely.
Additionally this starts adding unit tests to the spaces summary handler.
This PR adds a common configuration section for all modules (see docs). These modules are then loaded at startup by the homeserver. Modules register their hooks and web resources using the new `register_[...]_callbacks` and `register_web_resource` methods of the module API.
Fixes https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10030.
We were expecting milliseconds where we should have provided a value in seconds.
The impact of this bug isn't too bad. The code is intended to count the number of remote servers that the homeserver can see and report that as a metric. This metric is supposed to run initially 1 second after server startup, and every 60s as well. Instead, it ran 1,000 seconds after server startup, and every 60s after startup.
This fix allows for the correct metrics to be collected immediately, as well as preventing a random collection 1,000s in the future after startup.
Dangerous actions means deactivating an account, modifying an account
password, or adding a 3PID.
Other actions (deleting devices, uploading keys) can re-use the same UI
auth session if ui_auth.session_timeout is configured.
* Trace event persistence
When we persist a batch of events, set the parent opentracing span to the that
from the request, so that we can trace all the way in.
* changelog
* When we force tracing, set a baggage item
... so that we can check again later.
* Link in both directions between persist_events spans
* Room version 7 for knocking.
* Stable prefixes and endpoints (both client and federation) for knocking.
* Removes the experimental configuration flag.
Add 'federation_ip_range_whitelist'. This allows backwards-compatibility, If 'federation_ip_range_blacklist' is set. Otherwise 'ip_range_whitelist' will be used for federation servers.
Signed-off-by: Michael Kutzner 1mikure@gmail.com
This is the first of two PRs which seek to address #8518. This first PR lays the groundwork by extending ResponseCache; a second PR (#10158) will update the SyncHandler to actually use it, and fix the bug.
The idea here is that we allow the callback given to ResponseCache.wrap to decide whether its result should be cached or not. We do that by (optionally) passing a ResponseCacheContext into it, which it can modify.
==============================
Bugfixes
--------
- Fix a bug which caused presence updates to stop working some time after a restart, when using a presence writer worker. Broke in v1.33.0. ([\#10149](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10149))
- Fix a bug when using federation sender worker where it would send out more presence updates than necessary, leading to high resource usage. Broke in v1.33.0. ([\#10163](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10163))
- Fix a bug where Synapse could send the same presence update to a remote twice. ([\#10165](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10165))
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
iQFEBAABCgAuFiEEBTGR3/RnAzBGUif3pULk7RsPrAkFAmDDdrcQHGVyaWtAbWF0
cml4Lm9yZwAKCRClQuTtGw+sCTzfB/4qaTqW2mBiwjf52SmOu6HNyd8uQd6nLIAZ
mJC218Wakh2tT0W4iVkKwUgpuHFbtcy0rSNTlXtW4kG8XzhpTvT56RH9qls99aD3
SGKqYpOv6NkWZibN6NdVvLDW85ixficDTXco3BljRCIMlORhY0swy+LWLwksdjWj
6kQ+Gi/QAtKP3Pt5epYs0Ix5o1T94DfZOWE//mqBhG5cMDAw/K/G/c8tRfEjclt9
wACBjmt2fw/Lbn9j3b0feNVp+xnFcFNuAK2bSEd8Y3yph1mhjdsIszULnM7IFNsR
Q8zg+i7PJKNq8pQjei8j8T/aKscPTPH5XGqOSLlizj15snsiwlkz
=C6lV
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Merge tag 'v1.36.0rc2' into develop
Synapse 1.36.0rc2 (2021-06-11)
==============================
Bugfixes
--------
- Fix a bug which caused presence updates to stop working some time after a restart, when using a presence writer worker. Broke in v1.33.0. ([\#10149](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10149))
- Fix a bug when using federation sender worker where it would send out more presence updates than necessary, leading to high resource usage. Broke in v1.33.0. ([\#10163](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10163))
- Fix a bug where Synapse could send the same presence update to a remote twice. ([\#10165](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10165))
This is essentially an implementation of the proposal made at https://hackmd.io/@richvdh/BJYXQMQHO, though the details have ended up looking slightly different.
Spawned from missing messages we were seeing on `matrix.org` from a
federated Gtiter bridged room, https://gitlab.com/gitterHQ/webapp/-/issues/2770.
The underlying issue in Synapse is tracked by https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10066
where the message and join event race and the message is `soft_failed` before the
`join` event reaches the remote federated server.
Less soft_failed events = better and usually this should only trigger for events
where people are doing bad things and trying to fuzz and fake everything.
Fixes#1834.
`get_new_events_for_appservice` internally calls `get_events_as_list`, which will filter out any rejected events. If all returned events are filtered out, `_notify_interested_services` will return without updating the last handled stream position. If there are 100 consecutive such events, processing will halt altogether.
Breaking the loop is now done by checking whether we're up-to-date with `current_max` in the loop condition, instead of relying on an empty `events` list.
Signed-off-by: Willem Mulder <14mRh4X0r@gmail.com>
If backfilling is slow then the client may time out and retry, causing
Synapse to start a new `/backfill` before the existing backfill has
finished, duplicating work.
This adds quite a lot of OpenTracing decoration for database activity. Specifically it adds tracing at four different levels:
* emit a span for each "interaction" - ie, the top level database function that we tend to call "transaction", but isn't really, because it can end up as multiple transactions.
* emit a span while we hold a database connection open
* emit a span for each database transaction - actual actual transaction.
* emit a span for each database query.
I'm aware this might be quite a lot of overhead, but even just running it on a local Synapse it looks really interesting, and I hope the overhead can be offset just by turning down the sampling frequency and finding other ways of tracing requests of interest (eg, the `force_tracing_for_users` setting).
The existing tracing reports an error each time there is a timeout, which isn't
really representative.
Additionally, we log things about the way `wait_for_events` works
(eg, the result of the callback) to the *parent* span, which is confusing.
Empirically, this helped my server considerably when handling gaps in Matrix HQ. The problem was that we would repeatedly call have_seen_events for the same set of (50K or so) auth_events, each of which would take many minutes to complete, even though it's only an index scan.
==============================
Bugfixes
--------
- Fix a bug introduced in v1.35.0rc1 when calling the spaces summary API via a GET request. ([\#10079](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10079))
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
iQFEBAABCgAuFiEEBTGR3/RnAzBGUif3pULk7RsPrAkFAmCvpZMQHGVyaWtAbWF0
cml4Lm9yZwAKCRClQuTtGw+sCdPwCACQIlIWd6eIoXLUc+wDcrd+k5xL376EdYah
x7ABswiYSm+9C4xr58gJD3xc6eiD2PCIWdZN0rsQDLIOfSXW6x1lyKD+Ds0HySok
MaVpsoxbb9o/Zf9qtXF2bLSArZUQwfoNaA45NLgNzfUIijf1e+bd2wNEgHlRSoMz
m10GggOFU0Ds/CCYZpxZw/eXDbLWL7eaHR30vw/jQ1cEsV+S4ucnUmLHFCF7YCyI
Np80pnywH5cYKerecldFWenL4YZJswVbx+AW9e3lBzq5jOrRZkmLkaHg10mCR2f6
CV03ie65Ce+7x5UU6v6nHA0DYUTQGIjlJBtyCN3tFglUduQ8Gpu0
=Mfsf
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Merge tag 'v1.35.0rc2' into develop
Synapse 1.35.0rc2 (2021-05-27)
==============================
Bugfixes
--------
- Fix a bug introduced in v1.35.0rc1 when calling the spaces summary API via a GET request. ([\#10079](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/10079))
* Make `invalidate` and `invalidate_many` do the same thing
... so that we can do either over the invalidation replication stream, and also
because they always confused me a bit.
* Kill off `invalidate_many`
* changelog
`keylen` seems to be a thing that is frequently incorrectly set, and we don't really need it.
The only time it was used was to figure out if we had removed a subtree in `del_multi`, which we can do better by changing `TreeCache.pop` to return a different type (`TreeCacheNode`).
Commits should be independently reviewable.
* Fix /upload 500'ing when presented a very large image
Catch DecompressionBombError and re-raise as ThumbnailErrors
* Set PIL's MAX_IMAGE_PIXELS to match homeserver.yaml
to get it to bomb out quicker, to load less into memory
in the case of super large images
* Add changelog entry for 10029
Fixes: https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/9962
This is a fix for above problem.
I fixed it by swaping the order of insertion of new records and deletion of old ones. This ensures that we don't delete fresh database records as we do deletes before inserts.
Signed-off-by: Marek Matys <themarcq@gmail.com>
Also add support for giving a callback to generate the JSON object to
verify. This should reduce memory usage, as we no longer have the event
in memory in dict form (which has a large memory footprint) for extend
periods of time.
Instead of parsing the full response to `/send_join` into Python objects (which can be huge for large rooms) and *then* parsing that into events, we instead use ijson to stream parse the response directly into `EventBase` objects.
To be more consistent with similar code. The check now automatically
raises an AuthError instead of passing back a boolean. It also absorbs
some shared logic between callers.
- use a tuple rather than a list for the iterable that is passed into the
wrapped function, for performance
- test that we can pass an iterable and that keys are correctly deduped.
It's not obvious that instances of SQLBaseStore each need their own
instances of random.SystemRandom(); let's just use random directly.
Introduced by 52839886d6
Signed-off-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
We can get away with just catching UnicodeError here.
⋮
+-- ValueError
| +-- UnicodeError
| +-- UnicodeDecodeError
| +-- UnicodeEncodeError
| +-- UnicodeTranslateError
⋮
https://docs.python.org/3/library/exceptions.html#exception-hierarchy
Signed-off-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
Functionally identical, but more obviously cryptographically secure.
...Explicit is better than implicit?
Avoids needing to know that SystemRandom() implies a CSPRNG, and
complies with the big scary red box on the documentation for random:
> Warning:
> The pseudo-random generators of this module should not be used for
> security purposes. For security or cryptographic uses, see the
> secrets module.
https://docs.python.org/3/library/random.html
Signed-off-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
This should help ensure that equivalent results are achieved between
homeservers querying for the summary of a space.
This implements modified MSC1772 rules, according to MSC2946.
The different is that the origin_server_ts of the m.room.create event
is not used as a tie-breaker since this might not be known if the
homeserver is not part of the room.
Per changes in MSC2946, the C-S and S-S APIs for spaces summary
should use GET requests.
Until this is stable, the POST endpoints still exist.
This does not switch federation requests to use the GET version yet
since it is newly added and already deployed servers might not support
it. When switching to the stable endpoint we should switch to GET
requests.
MSC1772 specifies the m.room.create event should be sent as part
of the invite_state. This was done optionally behind an experimental
flag, but is now done by default due to MSC1772 being approved.
Now that cross signing exists there is much less of a need for other people to look at devices and verify them individually. This PR adds a config option to allow you to prevent device display names from being shared with other servers.
Signed-off-by: Aaron Raimist <aaron@raim.ist>
* tests for push rule pattern matching
* tests for acl pattern matching
* factor out common `re.escape`
* Factor out common re.compile
* Factor out common anchoring code
* add word_boundary support to `glob_to_regex`
* Use `glob_to_regex` in push rule evaluator
NB that this drops support for character classes. I don't think anyone ever
used them.
* Improve efficiency of globs with multiple wildcards
The idea here is that we compress multiple `*` globs into a single `.*`. We
also need to consider `?`, since `*?*` is as hard to implement efficiently as
`**`.
* add assertion on regex pattern
* Fix mypy
* Simplify glob_to_regex
* Inline the glob_to_regex helper function
Signed-off-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
* Moar comments
Signed-off-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
Co-authored-by: Dan Callahan <danc@element.io>
We were pulling the full auth chain for the room out of the DB each time
we backfilled, which can be *huge* for large rooms and is totally
unnecessary.
The hope here is that by moving all the schema files into synapse/storage/schema, it gets a bit easier for newcomers to navigate.
It certainly got easier for me to write a helpful README. There's more to do on that front, but I'll follow up with other PRs for that.
This is an update based on changes to MSC2946. The origin_server_ts
of the m.room.create event is copied into the creation_ts field for each
room returned from the spaces summary.
Synapse can be quite memory intensive, and unless care is taken to tune
the GC thresholds it can end up thrashing, causing noticable performance
problems for large servers. We fix this by limiting how often we GC a
given generation, regardless of current counts/thresholds.
This does not help with the reverse problem where the thresholds are set
too high, but that should only happen in situations where they've been
manually configured.
Adds a `gc_min_seconds_between` config option to override the defaults.
Fixes#9890.
This leaves out all optional keys from /sync. This should be fine for all clients tested against conduit already, but it may break some clients, as such we should check, that at least most of them don't break horribly and maybe back out some of the individual changes. (We can probably always leave out groups for example, while the others may cause more issues.)
Signed-off-by: Nicolas Werner <nicolas.werner@hotmail.de>
Support the delete of a room through DELETE request and mark
previous request as deprecated through documentation.
Signed-off-by: Thibault Ferrante <thibault.ferrante@pm.me>
This fixes a regression where the logging context for runWithConnection
was reported as runWithConnection instead of the connection name,
e.g. "POST-XYZ".
I went through and removed a bunch of cruft that was lying around for compatibility with old Python versions. This PR also will now prevent Synapse from starting unless you're running Python 3.6+.
This ensures that something like an auth error (403) will be
returned to the requester instead of attempting to try more
servers, which will likely result in the same error, and then
passing back a generic 400 error.
Applied a (slightly modified) patch from https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/9574.
As far as I understand this would allow the cookie set during the OIDC flow to work on deployments using public baseurls that do not sit at the URL path root.
When receiving a /send_join request for a room with join rules set to 'restricted',
check if the user is a member of the spaces defined in the 'allow' key of the join rules.
This only applies to an experimental room version, as defined in MSC3083.
As far as I can tell our logging contexts are meant to log the request ID, or sometimes the request ID followed by a suffix (this is generally stored in the name field of LoggingContext). There's also code to log the name@memory location, but I'm not sure this is ever used.
This simplifies the code paths to require every logging context to have a name and use that in logging. For sub-contexts (created via nested_logging_contexts, defer_to_threadpool, Measure) we use the current context's str (which becomes their name or the string "sentinel") and then potentially modify that (e.g. add a suffix).
This attempts to be a direct port of https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse-dinsic/pull/74 to mainline. There was some fiddling required to deal with the changes that have been made to mainline since (mainly dealing with the split of `RegistrationWorkerStore` from `RegistrationStore`, and the changes made to `self.make_request` in test code).
When receiving a /send_join request for a room with join rules set to 'restricted',
check if the user is a member of the spaces defined in the 'allow' key of the join
rules.
This only applies to an experimental room version, as defined in MSC3083.
This basically speeds up federation by "squeezing" each individual dual database call (to destinations and destination_rooms), which previously happened per every event, into one call for an entire batch (100 max).
Signed-off-by: Jonathan de Jong <jonathan@automatia.nl>
Part of #9744
Removes all redundant `# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-` lines from files, as python 3 automatically reads source code as utf-8 now.
`Signed-off-by: Jonathan de Jong <jonathan@automatia.nl>`
This change ensures that the appservice registration behaviour follows the spec. We decided to do this for Dendrite, so it made sense to also make a PR for synapse to correct the behaviour.
Related: #8334
Deprecated in: #9429 - Synapse 1.28.0 (2021-02-25)
`GET /_synapse/admin/v1/users/<user_id>` has no
- unit tests
- documentation
API in v2 is available (#5925 - 12/2019, v1.7.0).
API is misleading. It expects `user_id` and returns a list of all users.
Signed-off-by: Dirk Klimpel dirk@klimpel.org
We pull all destinations requiring catchup from the DB in batches.
However, if all those destinations get filtered out (due to the
federation sender being sharded), then the `last_processed` destination
doesn't get updated, and we keep requesting the same set repeatedly.
When joining a room with join rules set to 'restricted', check if the
user is a member of the spaces defined in the 'allow' key of the join rules.
This only applies to an experimental room version, as defined in MSC3083.
This PR modifies `GaugeBucketCollector` to only report data once it has been updated, rather than initially reporting a value of 0. Fixes zero values being reported for some metrics on startup until a background job to update the metric's value runs later.
At the moment, if you'd like to share presence between local or remote users, those users must be sharing a room together. This isn't always the most convenient or useful situation though.
This PR adds a module to Synapse that will allow deployments to set up extra logic on where presence updates should be routed. The module must implement two methods, `get_users_for_states` and `get_interested_users`. These methods are given presence updates or user IDs and must return information that Synapse will use to grant passing presence updates around.
A method is additionally added to `ModuleApi` which allows triggering a set of users to receive the current, online presence information for all users they are considered interested in. This is the equivalent of that user receiving presence information during an initial sync.
The goal of this module is to be fairly generic and useful for a variety of applications, with hard requirements being:
* Sending state for a specific set or all known users to a defined set of local and remote users.
* The ability to trigger an initial sync for specific users, so they receive all current state.
The `remote_media_cache_thumbnails_media_origin_media_id_thumbna_key`
constraint is superceded by
`remote_media_repository_thumbn_media_origin_id_width_height_met` (which adds
`thumbnail_method` to the unique key).
PR #7124 made an attempt to remove the old constraint, but got the name wrong,
so it didn't work. Here we update the bg update and rerun it.
Fixes#8649.
The regex should be terminated so that subdomain matches of another
domain are not accepted. Just ensuring that someone doesn't shoot
themselves in the foot by copying our example.
Signed-off-by: Denis Kasak <dkasak@termina.org.uk>
`room_invite_state_types` was inconvenient as a configuration setting, because
anyone that ever set it would not receive any new types that were added to the
defaults. Here, we deprecate the old setting, and replace it with a couple of
new settings under `room_prejoin_state`.
This should fix a class of bug where we forget to check if e.g. the appservice shouldn't be ratelimited.
We also check the `ratelimit_override` table to check if the user has ratelimiting disabled. That table is really only meant to override the event sender ratelimiting, so we don't use any values from it (as they might not make sense for different rate limits), but we do infer that if ratelimiting is disabled for the user we should disabled all ratelimits.
Fixes#9663
I've reiterated the advice about using `oidc` to migrate, since I've seen a few
people caught by this.
I've also removed a couple of the examples as they are duplicating the OIDC
documentation, and I think they might be leading people astray.
If you have the wrong version of `cryptography` installed, synapse suggests:
```
To install run:
pip install --upgrade --force 'cryptography>=3.4.7;python_version>='3.6''
```
However, the use of ' inside '...' doesn't work, so when you run this, you get
an error.
Running `dmypy run` will do a `mypy` check while spinning up a daemon
that makes rerunning `dmypy run` a lot faster.
`dmypy` doesn't support `follow_imports = silent` and has
`local_partial_types` enabled, so this PR enables those options and
fixes the issues that were newly raised. Note that `local_partial_types`
will be enabled by default in upcoming mypy releases.
Split off from https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/pull/9491
Adds a storage method for getting the current presence of all local users, optionally excluding those that are offline. This will be used by the code in #9491 when a PresenceRouter module informs Synapse that a given user should have `"ALL"` user presence updates routed to them. Specifically, it is used here: b588f16e39/synapse/handlers/presence.py (L1131-L1133)
Note that there is a `get_all_presence_updates` function just above. That function is intended to walk up the table through stream IDs, and is primarily used by the presence replication stream. I could possibly make use of it in the PresenceRouter-related code, but it would be a bit of a bodge.
Builds on the work done in #9643 to add a federation API for space summaries.
There's a bit of refactoring of the existing client-server code first, to avoid too much duplication.
Currently federation catchup will send the last *local* event that we
failed to send to the remote. This can cause issues for large rooms
where lots of servers have sent events while the remote server was down,
as when it comes back up again it'll be flooded with events from various
points in the DAG.
Instead, let's make it so that all the servers send the most recent
events, even if its not theirs. The remote should deduplicate the
events, so there shouldn't be much overhead in doing this.
Alternatively, the servers could only send local events if they were
also extremities and hope that the other server will send the event
over, but that is a bit risky.
This bug was discovered by DINUM. We were modifying `serialized_event["content"]`, which - if you've got `USE_FROZEN_DICTS` turned on or are [using a third party rules module](17cd48fe51/synapse/events/third_party_rules.py (L73-L76)) - will raise a 500 if you try to a edit a reply to a message.
`serialized_event["content"]` could be set to the edit event's content, instead of a copy of it, which is bad as we attempt to modify it. Instead, we also end up modifying the original event's content. DINUM uses a third party rules module, which meant the event's content got frozen and thus an exception was raised.
To be clear, the problem is not that the event's content was frozen. In fact doing so helped us uncover the fact we weren't copying event content correctly.
We had two functions named `get_forward_extremities_for_room` and
`get_forward_extremeties_for_room` that took different paramters. We
rename one of them to avoid confusion.
* Populate `internal_metadata.outlier` based on `events` table
Rather than relying on `outlier` being in the `internal_metadata` column,
populate it based on the `events.outlier` column.
* Move `outlier` out of InternalMetadata._dict
Ultimately, this will allow us to stop writing it to the database. For now, we
have to grandfather it back in so as to maintain compatibility with older
versions of Synapse.
Instead of if the user does not have a password hash. This allows a SSO
user to add a password to their account, but only if the local password
database is configured.
Fixes https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/9572
When a SSO user logs in for the first time, we create a local Matrix user for them. This goes through the register_user flow, which ends up triggering the spam checker. Spam checker modules don't currently have any way to differentiate between a user trying to sign up initially, versus an SSO user (whom has presumably already been approved elsewhere) trying to log in for the first time.
This PR passes `auth_provider_id` as an argument to the `check_registration_for_spam` function. This argument will contain an ID of an SSO provider (`"saml"`, `"cas"`, etc.) if one was used, else `None`.
Federation catch up mode is very inefficient if the number of events
that the remote server has missed is small, since handling gaps can be
very expensive, c.f. #9492.
Instead of going into catch up mode whenever we see an error, we instead
do so only if we've backed off from trying the remote for more than an
hour (the assumption being that in such a case it is more than a
transient failure).
Background: When we receive incoming federation traffic, and notice that we are missing prev_events from
the incoming traffic, first we do a `/get_missing_events` request, and then if we still have missing prev_events,
we set up new backwards-extremities. To do that, we need to make a `/state_ids` request to ask the remote
server for the state at those prev_events, and then we may need to then ask the remote server for any events
in that state which we don't already have, as well as the auth events for those missing state events, so that we
can auth them.
This PR attempts to optimise the processing of that state request. The `state_ids` API returns a list of the state
events, as well as a list of all the auth events for *all* of those state events. The optimisation comes from the
observation that we are currently loading all of those auth events into memory at the start of the operation, but
we almost certainly aren't going to need *all* of the auth events. Rather, we can check that we have them, and
leave the actual load into memory for later. (Ideally the federation API would tell us which auth events we're
actually going to need, but it doesn't.)
The effect of this is to reduce the number of events that I need to load for an event in Matrix HQ from about
60000 to about 22000, which means it can stay in my in-memory cache, whereas previously the sheer number
of events meant that all 60K events had to be loaded from db for each request, due to the amount of cache
churn. (NB I've already tripled the size of the cache from its default of 10K).
Unfortunately I've ended up basically C&Ping `_get_state_for_room` and `_get_events_from_store_or_dest` into
a new method, because `_get_state_for_room` is also called during backfill, which expects the auth events to be
returned, so the same tricks don't work. That said, I don't really know why that codepath is completely different
(ultimately we're doing the same thing in setting up a new backwards extremity) so I've left a TODO suggesting
that we clean it up.
