This does introduce the ability of expressing incorrect combinations
of the enums `SwapFailed` and `Reason`, but these are just internal
to this function and it's terser that way.
This helps distinguish between the case where the refund timelock is
reached before the bitcoin is locked and the case where the refund
timelock is reached after the bitcoin is locked and before Alice sends
over the transfer proof for locking up the monero. In the first case
we can abort without doing anything, but in the second case we must
instruct the caller to refund the bitcoin.
Add a binary crate `swap` that implements two nodes (Alice and Bob). With this
applied we can start up a node for each role and do:
- Bob: Requests current amounts using BTC is input
- Alice: Responds with amounts
- Bob: (mock) get user input to Ok the amounts
... continue with swap (TODO)
By having two modules that declare and use the `harness` module we ran
into a situation where not all parts of the `harness` module were
being used by both of these other test modules. This was producing
annoying warnings.
For now this can be solved by marking the `harness` module declaration
as public. This has no real effect since modules under `/tests` cannot
be depended on elsewhere, but it satisfies the compiler. It does mean
that we will not hear about unused functions, but this change should
be temporary and it's a very minor problem given that it's just test
code.
Instead of checking once to see if Monero's `TxLock` has been
published, the new trait should keep looking until the transaction has
been found.
The new trait also allows the caller to set an expected number of
confirmations on the transaction.
The implementation of the trait is currently part of test code, but it
should be similar to what we will eventually do for an application.
Mimics what @thomaseizinger did here [1] and here [2].
This has the advantage that the consumer has more freedom to execute
`Action`s without having to implement particular traits. The error
handling required inside this protocol-executing function is also
reduced.
As discussed with Thomas, for this approach to work well, the
trait functions such as `receive_transfer_proof` should be infallible,
and the implementer should be forced to hide IO errors behind a retry
mechanism.
All of these asynchronous calls need to be "raced" against
the abort condition (determined by the `refund_timelock`), which is
missing in the current state of the implementation.
The initial handshake of the protocol has not been included here,
because it may not be easy to integrate this approach with libp2p, but
a couple of messages still need to exchanged. I need @tcharding to
tell me if it's feasible/good to do it like this.
[1]
https://github.com/comit-network/comit-rs/blob/move-nectar-swap-to-comit/nectar/src/swap/comit/herc20_hbit.rs#L57-L184.
[2] e584d2b14f/nectar/src/swap.rs (L716-L751).
There are no guarantees that send_message and receive_massage do not block
the flow of execution. Therefore they must be paired between Alice/Bob, one
send to one receive in the correct order.
Define Alice to call `receive_message` first, with Bob sending the message. Do
this because we are expecting Alice to be have a well known address, there is no
currently such assumption for Bob.
Previously there was a delay making a get raw transaction call to
give some time for a transaction to be confirmed on the blockchain.
This has been replaced with a loop that waits until the call is
succesful.
Previously we were testing the protocol by manually driving Alice and
Bob's state machines. This logic has now be moved to an async state
transition function that can take any possible state as input. The
state transition function is called in a loop until it returns the
desired state. This allows use to interrupt midway through the protocol
and perform refund and punish tests. This design was chosen over a
generator based implementation because the the generator based
implementation results in a impure state transition function that is
difficult to reason about and prone to bugs.
Test related code was extracted into the tests folder.
The 2b and 4b states were renamed to be consistent with the rest.
Macros were used to reduce code duplication when converting
child states to their parent states and vice versa.
Todos were added were neccessary.
There is some sort of timing issue when spinning up the monero containers on
github CI. I do not know exactly what is the cause but we have a configurable
'additional sleep time' already available for `testcontainers` that can resolve
this issue.
Use the environment variable MONERO_ADDITIONAL_SLEEP_PERIOD to tell
`testcontainers` to wait an additional 60 while bringing up the monero
container.
Update the readme inline with review suggestions by doing:
- Copy 'long story short' text from blog post
- Correct the erroneous description of watching blockchains
- Fix gramar
