mirror of
https://github.com/nhammer514/textfiles-politics.git
synced 2024-12-18 12:14:33 -05:00
71 lines
4.2 KiB
Plaintext
71 lines
4.2 KiB
Plaintext
Police and Prisons
|
|
|
|
by A.M. Rosenthal, _New York Times_ Op-Ed, 1/28/94
|
|
|
|
More and more billions for prisons to lock up more and more Americans who
|
|
never had a decent chance at life. Are we mad? Why not use those billions to
|
|
build more schools to give more young people living in poverty the education
|
|
to climb out of it? It costs as much to keep a convict in prison as to send
|
|
him to Yale, for Heaven's sake.
|
|
And despite all the other billions the U.S. spends on the drug war,
|
|
narcotics still flood the country, users are still being put into prison,
|
|
crowding out violent criminals. Why not legalize drugs and use the anti-drug
|
|
money on therapy for addicts and to improve the neighborhoods that create
|
|
them?
|
|
And why those long sentences for convicts? Every year behind bars makes
|
|
them more bitter. They return to the same hard streets. Save money by cutting
|
|
sentences. Spend the savings to give released convicts training for decent
|
|
jobs.
|
|
Those three paragraphs sum up an important belief in American liberal
|
|
intellectual life -- the belief that war against crime and drugs is largely
|
|
aimed at and hurts the poor and wastes huge amounts of money that could be
|
|
used to fight the poverty, discrimination and educational deprivation that are
|
|
the root causes of crime.
|
|
The argument is false factually. Worse, it is damaging to people it is
|
|
supposed to benefit -- Americans, all skin shades, who live in the streets of
|
|
poverty and killing.
|
|
Economically, the struggle against crime is the biggest bargain the
|
|
taxpayer gets. A criminal on the loose costs society twice as much as a
|
|
criminal in jail -- in stolen good, smashed property and of course the medical
|
|
care for the victims.
|
|
The drug war has not yet been won. But it has saved hundreds or thousands
|
|
of Americans from lives of addiction that would have cost the country scores
|
|
of billions. Nobody knows exactly how much because drug abuse is the cause of
|
|
so many other crimes like family violence, robberies and muggings.
|
|
Most of the crime takes place in poor neighborhoods. Drug addicts gobble up
|
|
hospital space and time that would have gone to the people of those
|
|
neighborhoods. Fighting crime and drugs is one tax expenditure that benefits
|
|
the poor most of all.
|
|
All those crowded jails are not filled with pot smokers caught by cops on
|
|
patrol. Prof. John J. DiIulio Jr. of Princeton and Brookins reports that 93
|
|
percent of convicts in state prisons are violent criminals, many of them
|
|
repeat offenders.
|
|
Yes, a lot of Americans are in jail. A lot more should be. If your house
|
|
is burgled, there is a 1 in 80 chance the criminal will serve time.
|
|
The trouble with long sentences is that they turn out not to be all that
|
|
long. Convicts serve about one-third of their sentences. A rapist can expect
|
|
to be out in 5 years, a convicted murderer in 10.
|
|
President Clinton now recognizes the dreadful importance of crime in
|
|
American life. But if he is to lead, as he should, he ought to make sure his
|
|
top officers are following on close.
|
|
About mandatory sentences, his Attorney General is known to law officers as
|
|
Waffle General. His Surgeon General boosts another study of the much-studied
|
|
legalization of drugs. Then after he properly says "nothing doing," she boosts
|
|
it again. Either she does not believe what the President says or just does not
|
|
care very much.
|
|
Most of all, he should tell us the hardest truth of all -- how deeply
|
|
criminals have hurt the already wounded of America, the poor.
|
|
The President should tell us that criminals who have stayed out of jail and
|
|
criminals who got out too early have turned large parts of the inner city into
|
|
war zones. "Build schools, not prisons" -- that's not a choice now, it is a
|
|
hoax.
|
|
In war zones the money and energy of government and the people go to
|
|
surviving, fighting and winning. Sometimes a little extra money and energy are
|
|
spent to keep up spirits. But was there ever a case where in a war zone under
|
|
attack there was enough money to make life decent and build for the future?
|
|
The criminals have deprived other citizens of the greatest civil liberty --
|
|
the right to live in peace. They have also deprived citizens of the treasure
|
|
to build for the future.
|
|
That is what the President should tell the country, for it is the plain
|
|
truth and will be so until the winning starts.
|