mirror of
https://github.com/nhammer514/textfiles-politics.git
synced 2024-12-27 00:09:39 -05:00
1496 lines
79 KiB
Plaintext
1496 lines
79 KiB
Plaintext
24 page printout, pages 89 to 111 of 322
|
||
CHAPTER III
|
||
|
||
CHRISTIAN "SCRIPTITRE" FORGERIES
|
||
|
||
"Nothing stands in need of Lying but a LIE."
|
||
|
||
To such an extent are the origins of the Christian Religion
|
||
wrapped in obscurity, due to the labyrinthine confusions and
|
||
contradictions and forgeries of its early records, that it is quite
|
||
impossible to extricate, with any degree of confidence, a thread of
|
||
historic truth from the tangle.
|
||
|
||
The 27 New Testament booklets, attributed to eight individual
|
||
"Apostolic" writers, and culled from some 200 admitted forgeries
|
||
called Gospels, Acts, and Epistles, constitute the presient
|
||
"Canonical" or acceptedly inspired compendium of the primitive
|
||
history of Christianity. The only available method to extract from
|
||
them approximately just judgments as to the risie and progress of
|
||
the new system of beliefs, must be by a series of tentative
|
||
assumptions of reletive truth of sundry details of the narratives.
|
||
By relative truth of any tentatively assumed "fact," I mean such
|
||
"fact" with relation always to its contradictory, -- one or the
|
||
other must necessarily be false -- while both may be -- and
|
||
probably are. For, as virtually every alleged "fact" recorded in
|
||
Gospels, Acts and Epistles is off-set by a contradictory recital,
|
||
rendering one or the other untrue, neather can be assumed with
|
||
assurance; the actuality of either, and of all, is thus made
|
||
doubtful, and is subject to total rejection as our study of the
|
||
booklets develops.
|
||
|
||
On such provisional assumption that sundry of the things
|
||
recorded possibly may have happened as in one manner or the other
|
||
related, we are able to reach several obvious conclusions as to the
|
||
order and approximate times of those dubiously-assumed happenings.
|
||
In view, however, of what we have seen, and shall soon more
|
||
abundantly see, of the shifty and fraudulent methods of
|
||
ecclesiatitical "history"-writing and propaganda, we may be
|
||
prepared for some rude upsettings of our inherited traditions of
|
||
Christian fact and faith.
|
||
|
||
The central character of the Christian faith, Jesus, to assume
|
||
him as a historical personage, was a Jew, as were, by tradition,
|
||
his disciples and entourage. As is, of course, well known:
|
||
"Christianity took its rise in Judaism; its Founder and His
|
||
disciples were orthodox Jews, and the latter maintained their
|
||
Jewish practices, at least for a time, after the day of Pentecost.
|
||
The Jews themselves looked upon the followers of Christ as a mere
|
||
Israelitish sect, ... 'the sect of the Nazarenes' (Acts xxiv, 15),"
|
||
-- the believers in the Promised Messiah. (CE. iii, 713.) In this
|
||
they were grievously deceived and disappointed, as, too the world
|
||
knows; "Christ's humble and obscure life, ending in the ignominious
|
||
death on the cross, was the very opposite of what the Jews expected
|
||
of their Christ." (CE. i, 620.)
|
||
|
||
Jesus was a native of Galilee, "his own country" (Mt. ii, 23;
|
||
xiii, 54-55), or of Judaea, "his own country" (.John iv, 43-44). He
|
||
was born "in the days of Herod the King" (Mt. ii, 1), about 6 B.C.,
|
||
or "when Cyrenius was governor of Syria" (Luke ii, 1-7), about 7
|
||
A.D., or some 13 years later. (CE. viii, 377; EB. i, 307-8.) The
|
||
destructive contradictions as to his lineage and parentage, and
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
89
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
other essential particulars, are reserved for opportune notice.
|
||
Jesus became a Jewish sectarian religious teacher of the zealot
|
||
reformer type; so zealous that his own family thought him insane
|
||
and sent out to apprehend him (Mark iii, 31); many of the people
|
||
said of him, "He hath a devil, and is mad" (John x, 20); his own
|
||
disciples, seeing his raid into the Temple after the money-
|
||
changers, shook their heads and muttered the proverb: "The zeal of
|
||
thine house hath eaten me up" (John ii, 17).
|
||
|
||
His ministry, of about one year, according to the first three
|
||
Gospels, of some three yeurs according to the fourth, was, by his
|
||
own repeated assertion, limited exclusively to his own Jewish
|
||
people: "I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of
|
||
Israel" (Mt. xv, 24; ef. Acts iii, 25-26; xiii, 46; Rom. xv, 8);
|
||
and he straitly enjoined on his Twelve Aposties: "Go not into the
|
||
way of the Gentiles, and into any city of the Samaritans enter ye
|
||
not: But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel" (Mt.
|
||
X, 5-6); to the woman of Canaan who pleaded with him to have mercy
|
||
on her daughter, "grievously vexed with a devil," he retorted: "It
|
||
is not meet to take the children's bread, and cast it to dogs" (Mt.
|
||
xv, 22-28; vii, 6). His own announcement, and his command to the
|
||
Twelve, was "Preach, saying, The Kingdom of Heaven is at hand" (Mt.
|
||
x, 7), -- the exclusively Hebraic Kingdom of the Baptist (Mt. iii,
|
||
2), as of the Jewish Messianic apocrypha which we have noticed.
|
||
Jesus lived at the height of the "age of apocryphal literature,"
|
||
and in due time got into it, voluminously.
|
||
|
||
Before his death, time and again he made and repeated the
|
||
assurance -- the most positive and iterated of all the sayings
|
||
attributed to him -- of the immediate end of the world, and of his
|
||
quick triumphant return to establish the Kingdom of God in the new
|
||
earth and reign on the reestablished throne of David forever. Time
|
||
and again he said and repeated: "Verily I say unto you, There be
|
||
some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see
|
||
the Son of man coming in his Kingdom" (Mt. xvi, 28; Mk. ix, I; Lk.
|
||
ix, 27); "This generation shall not pass, till all these things be
|
||
done" Mk. xiii, 30). -- So quickly would this "second coming" be,
|
||
that when the Twelve were sent out on their first preaching tour in
|
||
little Palestine, their Master assured them: "Ye shall not have
|
||
gone over the cities of Israel till the Son of man be come" (Mt. x,
|
||
23). Caiaphag, the high priert before whom Jesus was led after his
|
||
capture in the Garden, solemnly conjured him "By the living God"
|
||
for the truth; and Jesus replied: "Nevertheless I say unto you,
|
||
Hereafter shall ye see the Son of man ... coming in the clouds of
|
||
heaven." (Mt. xxvi, 63, 64; Mk. xiv, 61, 62.) Some people are
|
||
expecting him yet. Of course, there were, could be, none but Jews
|
||
in heaven, or in this new Kingdom of Heaven on the new earth:
|
||
"Salvation is of the Jews." (John iv, 22.) It was 144,000 Jews, the
|
||
"scaled" saints, who alone constituted the original Jewish "Kingdom
|
||
of God" (Rev. vii).
|
||
|
||
With these explicit data we arrive at the first obvious and
|
||
positive conclusion: With the expectation of a quick and sudden end
|
||
of the world and of all things human, no books were written on the
|
||
subject in that generation or, for a little leeway, the next or so,
|
||
after the death of the expected returning King. The scant, number
|
||
of credulous Jews who accepted this preachment as "Gospel truth"
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
90
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
and lived in this expectation, were nourished with neighborhood
|
||
gossip and oral traditions of the "good news," and needed and had
|
||
no written books of inspired record of these things. Thus many
|
||
years passed. Only as the dread consummation was delayed, and the
|
||
hope deferred sickened the hearts of the expectant Jews and they
|
||
waned in faith, and as aecused by Paul and Barnabas, "put it from
|
||
you," did the defeated propagandists of the "Faith that failed at
|
||
the Cross," give the shoulder to the Jews and "turn to the
|
||
Gentiles" (Acts xiii, 46), and begin to expand the failing new
|
||
Jewish faith among the superstitious Pagans of the countries round
|
||
about. But this was still by the spoken word; on all the
|
||
supposititious "missionary tours" the Word was spread by word of
|
||
mouth written gospel books were not yet. When at last, the "coming"
|
||
being still unrealized -- these books began to be written, we can
|
||
accurately determine something of the order of their writing, and
|
||
finally, though negatively, the approximate times when they were
|
||
written, by ascertaining when they were not yet written.
|
||
|
||
We have seen that for a century and more the only "Scriptures"
|
||
used by the Jewish propagandists of the Christ were the Greek
|
||
Septuagint translations of the old hebrew sacred writings, "the Law
|
||
and the Prophets" (CE. v, 702; i, 635); supplemented by sundry
|
||
Jewish apocrypha and the Pagan Sibylline Oracles; these were the
|
||
only "authorities" appealed to by the early "Fathers" for the
|
||
propaganda of the new faith. Indubitably, if the wonderful
|
||
"histories" of their Christ and the inspired pretended writings of
|
||
his first, Apostles, forming noew the New Testament, had then
|
||
existed, even in scraps of writing, they would have been the most
|
||
precious and potent documents of propaganda, would have been
|
||
snatched at and quoted and appealed to with infinate zeal and
|
||
ardor, as they have been through the centuries since. But, for some
|
||
150 years, as we shall see, little or nothing besides Old Testament
|
||
and Pagan Oracles were known or quoted. As said by the great
|
||
critic, Solomon Reinach, "With the exception of Papias, who speaks
|
||
of a narrative by Mark, and a collection of sayings of Jesus, no
|
||
Christian writer of the first half of the second century (i.e., up
|
||
to 150 A.D.) quotes the Gospels or their reputed authors."
|
||
(Reinach, Orpheus, p. 218.) So, patently, as yet no "Gospels" and
|
||
but few if any "Epistles" of our "canon" had as yet been written.
|
||
Again, we read the 23 booklets from and including Acts to
|
||
Revelation: there is not a solitary referance to a word of
|
||
quotation from, any of our four Gospels; scarce a trace of the
|
||
wonderful career and miracles of Jesus the Christ; not a word of
|
||
his "gospel" or teachings mentioned or quoted. These Epistles,
|
||
indeed, "preach Christ Crucified" (from oral tradition), as the
|
||
basis of the propagandists' own "gospel." But the written "Gospel
|
||
of Jesus Christ" (his life and words and deeds), was unknown:
|
||
indeed, jealous of the so-called Petrine preaching which "perverts
|
||
the gospel of Christ" as preached by him, the soi-disant Apostle
|
||
Paul fulminates: "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach
|
||
any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached, let,
|
||
him be accursed" (Gal. i, 7, 8); -- so early did priestly
|
||
intolerance and priestly curses on opponents come into holy vogue.
|
||
Therefore the conclusion is inevitable that when those 23 Acts and
|
||
Epistles were written, none of the four "Gospel" biographies of
|
||
Jesus the Christ had yet seen the light. "Written Gospels are
|
||
neither mentioned nor implied in the NT epistles, nor in that, of
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
91
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Clemens Romanus, nor, probably, in that of Barnabas, nor in the
|
||
Didache. luke (i, 1-4) implies that 'many gospels' were current"
|
||
(EB. ii, 1809), at the time that Gospel was written.
|
||
|
||
The Acts and Epistles, therefore, with Revelation, were
|
||
written before any of the Gospel biographies. If these Christ-
|
||
histories had existed, how eagerly would they have been seized upon
|
||
to garnish and glorify the preachment of the early propagandists of
|
||
the Faith that failed at the Cross, -- and would have perished
|
||
wholly but. for the allbelieving Pagan Gentiles, who, when they
|
||
heard it, "were glad, and glorified the word of the lord" (Acts
|
||
xiii, 48), as orally delivered.
|
||
|
||
"THE AGE OF APOCRYPHAL LITERATURE"
|
||
|
||
As the long years passed and one generation of disappointed
|
||
"Messiah" Jews was gathered unto its fathers and was followed by
|
||
another, the believers in the promised "second coming" for the
|
||
establishment of the Jewish Kingdom grew restles, and made
|
||
pertinent complaint, "Saying, Where is the promise of his coming?
|
||
for since the fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they were
|
||
from the beginning of the creation" (2 Peter ii, 4), -- and as they
|
||
yet continue. Dubbing these reasonable but disturbing inquirers
|
||
"scoffers," the crafty Peter tried in typical priestly form to
|
||
squirm out of the embarrassing situation created by the positive
|
||
promises of the Christ and the inspired preachments of himself and
|
||
his apostolic confreres, by the shifty rejoinder: "But, beloved
|
||
["scoffers"], be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is
|
||
with the Lord as a thousand yearn, and a thousand years as one day"
|
||
(2 Peter ii, 8) -- which doesn't mean anything for an honest
|
||
answer; and time and again they cajole the impatient eredtilous:
|
||
"Ye have need of patience; ... for yet a little while, and he that
|
||
shall come, will come." (Heb. x, 36, 37; cf. 1 Thess. iv, l6-18; 2
|
||
Thess. iii, 5; James v, 7, 8; et passim.) But he isn't come yet,
|
||
these 2000 years.
|
||
|
||
It was at this critical juncture, to revive and stimulate the
|
||
jaded hope of the Jewish believers and to spread the propaganda
|
||
amongst the all-believing Pagaiis, that the written Christ-tales
|
||
began to be worked up by the Christian propagandists. Before their
|
||
admiring eyes they had for models the "whole literature" of Jewish
|
||
apocryphal or forged writings, plus the Pagan Oracles: with immense
|
||
zeal and industry they set about to imitate the example before
|
||
them, and to reforge these Jewish and heathen forgeries to more
|
||
definite Chriiitian uses, and to forge anew another whole
|
||
literature of distinctively Christian forgeries and fabulous
|
||
histories of the Christ. "In this form of propaganda the Christians
|
||
proved themselves to be apt pupils of the Jews. So common, indeed,
|
||
had become in early Christian times, the invention of such oracles
|
||
that Celsus terms Christians Sibyllistai, believers in sibyls, or
|
||
sibyl-mongerrs" (EB. i, 246), that is, peddlers of Christian
|
||
forgeries in Pagan form (Ib. p. 261). How great was this pious
|
||
fabrication we can only judge from the two hundred, more or less,
|
||
of false histories, gospels, epistles and revelations which have
|
||
survived, entire or fragmentary, or by title only, through the long
|
||
intervening centuries of faith, and of which 27 are yet cherished
|
||
as of Divine inspiration.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
92
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
"THE IDEA OF INSPIRATION"
|
||
|
||
Before sketching the welter of these lying works of Christian
|
||
hands and childish minds, we may define, by high priestly
|
||
authority, the status of the problem of divine inspiration, and
|
||
just how the notion of "canonicity" or official inspiration, came
|
||
to be, now attributed to, now withdrawn from, this heterogeneous
|
||
mass or mess of pious scribblings, and finally clung to only 27 of
|
||
yet asserted sanctity. These admissions are very illuminating.
|
||
|
||
We have aeen that the Hebrew Old Testament itself "reveals no
|
||
formal notion of inspiration," though, we are assured, "the later
|
||
Jews must have possessed the idea" (CE. iii, 269); -- thus only an
|
||
idea or notion somehow acquired, but not through divine
|
||
illumination, for as we read, of all the mass of Jewish holy
|
||
forgeries "each of them has at one tune or another been treated as
|
||
canonical" or divinely inspired. (EB. i, 250.) Whether the
|
||
Christian notion or idea as to the divine inspiration of their own
|
||
new forgeries was of any better quality may now appear.
|
||
|
||
The New Testament and the inspired Apostles are silent on the
|
||
subject and left the matter to serious doubts and disputations for
|
||
many centuries: "There are no indications in the New Testament ...
|
||
of a definite new Canon bequeathed by the Apostles to the Church,
|
||
or of a strong self-witness to Divine inspiration," admits the CE,.
|
||
(iii, 274); that is, there is nothing in the 27 booklets which
|
||
would lead to the suspicion of their "inspiration" or truth. There
|
||
was then no Church for them to bequeath to, nor was the Canon
|
||
settled, as we shall see: "It was not until about the middle of the
|
||
second century -- [when we shall see the books were really written]
|
||
-- that under the rubric of Scripture the New Testament writings
|
||
were assimilated to the Old. ... But it should be remembered that
|
||
the inspired character of the New Testament in a Catholic dogma,
|
||
and must therefore in some way have been revealed to, and taught
|
||
by, Apostles"! (Ib. p. 275.) This is a strikingly queer bit of
|
||
clerical dialectic, and leaves the question of the "some way" of
|
||
revelation to the Apostles and of their transmission of the "dogma"
|
||
to posterity, in a nebulously unsatisfying state.
|
||
|
||
Further, the dubious and disputed status of the sacred
|
||
writings through centuries, and the ultimate settlement of the
|
||
controversies by the 'ipse dixit' of a numerical majority of the
|
||
Council of Trent, in 1546, -- after the Reformation had forced the
|
||
issue, is thus admitted: "The idea of a complete and clear-cut
|
||
canon of the New Testament existing from the beginning, that is,
|
||
from Apostolic times, has no foundation in history. The cannon of
|
||
the New Testament, like that of the Old, is the result of a
|
||
development, of a process at once stimulated by disputes with
|
||
doubters, both within and without the Church, and retarded by
|
||
certain obscurities and natural hesitations, and which did not
|
||
reach its final term until the dogmatic defination of the
|
||
Tridentine Council. ... And this want of a organized distribution,
|
||
secondarily to the absence of an early fixation of the Canonm, left
|
||
room for variations and doubts which lasted far into the
|
||
centuries." (CE., iii, 274.) The 'modus operandi' of the Holy
|
||
Council in ultimately "canonizing" Jerome's old Vulgate Version,
|
||
and its motive for doing so, are thus exposed by the keen pen of
|
||
the author of the Rise and Fall:
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
93
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
"When the Council of Trant resolved to pronounce sentence on
|
||
the Cannon of Scripture, the opinion which prevented, after some
|
||
debate, was to declare the Latin Vulgate authentic and 'almost'
|
||
infallible; and this sentence, which was guarded by formidable
|
||
anathemas, secured all the books of the Old and New Testament which
|
||
composed that ancient version. ... When the merit of that version
|
||
was discussed, the majority of the theologians urged, with
|
||
confidence and success, that it was absoutely necessary to receive
|
||
the Vulgate as authentic and inspired, unless they wished to
|
||
abandon the victory to the Lutherans, and the honors of the Church
|
||
to the Grammarians." (Gibbon, A Vindication, v, 2; Istoria del
|
||
consiglio Tridentino, L. ii, p. 147.) A number of these books were
|
||
bitterly disputed and their authenticity and inspiration denied by
|
||
the leading Reformers, Luther, Grotius, Calvin, etc., and excluded
|
||
from their official lists, until finally the Reformed Church
|
||
followed the example of the Church hopeless of reform and swallowed
|
||
the canon whole, as we have it today, -- minus, of course, the
|
||
'Tobit,' 'Judith,' and like inspired buffooneries of the True
|
||
Bible.
|
||
|
||
Such books and the vicissitudes of their authority are thus
|
||
described: "Like the Old Testament, the New has its deutero-
|
||
canonical [i.e. doubted] books and portions of books, their
|
||
canonicity having formally been a subject of some controversy in
|
||
the Church. These are, for entire books: the Epistle to the
|
||
Hebrews, that od James, the Second and Third of John, Jude, and
|
||
Apocalypse; giving seven in all as the number of the N.T. contested
|
||
books. The formerly disputed passages are three: the closing
|
||
section of St. Mark's Gospel, xvi, 9-20, about the apparitions of
|
||
Christ after the resurrection; the verses in Luke about the bloody
|
||
sweat of Jesus, xxii, 43, 44; the Pericope Adulterae, or narrative
|
||
of the woman taken in adultery, St. John, vii, 53 to viii, 11.
|
||
Since the Council of Trent it is not permitted for a Catholic to
|
||
question the inspiration of these passages." (CE. iii, 274.)
|
||
Besides the forgery of the above and other books as a whole, we
|
||
shall see many other instances of "interpolated" or forged passages
|
||
in the Christian books.
|
||
|
||
"THE LYING PEN OF THE SCRIBES"
|
||
|
||
Speaking of the doubtful historicity of the celebrated AEsop
|
||
of the famous Fables which go under his name, a critic well states
|
||
a valid test of historicity: "We may well doubt, however, whether
|
||
he (AEsop) ever existed; we have the most varied accounts of him,
|
||
many of which are on their face pure inventions; and the fables
|
||
which passed under his name were certainly not written until long
|
||
after the period in which he is supposed to have lived." (NIE. i,
|
||
191.) We may have occasion to apply this test to the personality of
|
||
Jesus of Nazareth and sundry apostolic personages; in any event it
|
||
is peculiarly applicable to the numerous Christian stories and
|
||
fables treating of them, which on their face are pure inventions,
|
||
and which were admittedly forged in the names of Jesut; himself and
|
||
of all of his Apostles and of many of the shining lights of the new
|
||
Christian faith, just as we have seen was done in the Jewish
|
||
forgerier; in the names of the Old Testament notables from Adam on
|
||
down the catalogue.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
94
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Leaving for the moment aside the 27 presently accepted
|
||
booklets of the N.T., and admitting the many Christian forgeries of
|
||
Christ-fables, CE. thus apologetically explains: "The genuine
|
||
Gospels are silent about long stretches of the life of our Lord,
|
||
the Blessed Virgin, and St. Joseph. This reserve of the Evangelists
|
||
did not satisfy the pardonable curiosity of many Christians eager
|
||
for details. ... Enterprising spirits responded to this natural
|
||
craving by pretended gospels full of romantic fables, and fantastic
|
||
and striking details; their fabrications were eagerly read and
|
||
accepted as true by common folk who were devoid of any critical
|
||
faculty and who were predisposed to believe what so luxuriously fed
|
||
their pious curiosity. Both Catholics and Gnostics were concerned
|
||
in writing these fictions. The former had no motive other than that
|
||
of a PIOUS FRAUD." (CE. i, 606.) The motive above admitted for
|
||
feeding with pious frauds the "natural craving" of the ignorant and
|
||
superstitiouts Christians for marvel-mongering by the Church, is
|
||
confirmed by a distinguished historign: "A vast and ever-increasing
|
||
crowd of converts from paganism, who had become such from worldly
|
||
considerations, and still hankered after wonders like those in
|
||
which their forefathers had from time immemorial believed, lent a
|
||
ready ear to assertions which, to more hesitating or better-
|
||
instructed minds, would have seemed to carry imposture on their
|
||
very face." (Draper, The Intellectaal Development of Europe, i,
|
||
309.)
|
||
|
||
This being thus frankly confessed, our clerical writer
|
||
describes the general character of these pious frauds: "The
|
||
Christian apocryphal writings in general imitate the books of the
|
||
N.T.) and therefore, with a few exceptions, fall under the
|
||
description of Gospels, Acts, Epistles, and Apocalypses." (CE. i,
|
||
606.) Further apologizing for these Christian forgeries, and giving
|
||
a smear of clerical whitewash to the forgers, it is speciously
|
||
pleaded, that "the term apocryphal in connection with special
|
||
gospels must be understood as bearing no more unfavorable an import
|
||
than uncanonical." They were forgeries pure and simple; and their
|
||
pious value is urged, that "the apocryphal Gospels help us to
|
||
understand the religious conditions of the second and third
|
||
centuries," -- as indeed they do, in a light very damaging to any
|
||
suspicion of truthfulness, common honesty, or anything above the
|
||
most mediocre intelligence of the pious Fathers and Faithful who
|
||
put these gross fabrications into circulation in the name and for
|
||
the sake of Christ. Their pious plea is: "Amor Christi est cui
|
||
satisfecimus." (Ib. p. 606.) Of these pious frauds it adds: "The
|
||
quasi-evangelistic compositions concerning Christ ... are all of
|
||
Orthodox origin." (Ib. p. 607.)
|
||
|
||
"CHRISTIAN EVIDENCES" -- FORGED
|
||
|
||
When the new Faith went forth to conquer the Pagan world for
|
||
Christ, the pious Greek Fathers and priests of the Propaganda soon
|
||
felt the need of something of more up-to-date effectiveness than
|
||
Old Testament text and Sibylline Oracles, they needed something
|
||
concrete out of the New Dispensation to "show" to the superstitious
|
||
Pagans to win them to the Christ and his Church: something
|
||
tangible, visible; compellingly authentic proofs. Like arms of
|
||
proof for the holy warfare, the invincible weapons of truth -- "the
|
||
whole armour of God" -- they forged outright for the conquest of
|
||
the unbeliever. What more convincing and compelling proofs of Jesus
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
95
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
the Christ, his holy Apostles, and their wondrous works of over a
|
||
century ago, than the following authentic and autograph documents
|
||
and records, held before doubting eyes:
|
||
|
||
A "GOSPEL" WRITTEN BY JESUS CHRIST'S OWN HAND;
|
||
|
||
LETTERS AND PORTRAITS OF JESUS CHRIST AND HIS PERSONAL
|
||
CORRESPONDENCE;
|
||
|
||
LETTERS WRITTEN BY HIS VIRGIN MOTHER;
|
||
|
||
PILATE'S OFFICIAL REPORT TO THE EMPEROR OF THE TRIAL AND
|
||
CRUCIFICTION OF JESUS, WITH PILATE'S CONFESSION OF FAITH;
|
||
|
||
THE REPLY OF TIBERIUS, AND THE TRIAL OF PILATE;
|
||
|
||
OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS OF THE ROMAN SENATE ABOUT JESUS,
|
||
|
||
GOSPELS, EPISTLES, ACTS, BY EVERY ONE OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES;
|
||
|
||
OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS; OF CHURCH LAW AND GOVERNMENT, WRITTEN IN
|
||
GREEK, BY THE APOSTLES;
|
||
|
||
RECORDS OF THE EARLIEST "POPES" AND "APOSTOLIC SUCCESSION;
|
||
|
||
SCORES OF OTHER PIOUS FORGED DOCUMENTS TO BE RELATED BELOW.
|
||
|
||
Armed with lying credentials and "proofs" of the fictitious
|
||
persons and performances for which credence must be won among the
|
||
credulous pagans, the priests and Vicars of God propagated their
|
||
stupendous "LIES to the glory of God" and the exaltation of the
|
||
Church. We shall catelogue these crude forgeries somewhat more
|
||
fully, and look into some of the more notorious.
|
||
|
||
FORGED GOSPELS, ACTS, EPISTLES
|
||
|
||
Half a hundred of false and forged Apostolic "Gospels of Jesus
|
||
Christ," together with more numerous orher "Scripture" forgeries,
|
||
was the output, so far as known now, of the lying pens of the pious
|
||
Christians of the first two centuries of the Christian "Age of
|
||
Apocryphal Literature"; all going to swell the "very large number
|
||
of apocryphal writings of distinctly Christian origin which were
|
||
produced from the second century onward, to satisfy an unhealthy
|
||
craving for the occult and marvelous or to embellish the stories of
|
||
the saints." (NIE., i, 746.) These N.T. apocryplia include
|
||
"numerous works purporting to have been written by apostles or
|
||
their associates, but not able to secure a general or permanent
|
||
recognition. These may be classified thus: (a) Gospels; (b) Acts of
|
||
Apostles; (c) Epistles; (d) Apocalypses; (e) Didactic Works; (f)
|
||
Hymns. (Ib. p. 748.) "The name Gospel," says CE. (vi, 656), "as
|
||
indicating a written account of Christ's words and deeds, has been,
|
||
and still is, applied to a large number of narratives of Christ's
|
||
life, which circulated both before and after the composition of our
|
||
Third Gospel (cf. Luke i, 1-4). The titles of some fifty such works
|
||
have come down to us. ... It is only, however, in connection with
|
||
some twenty of these 'Gospels' that some information has been
|
||
preserved. ... Most of them, as far as can be made out, are late
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
96
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
productions, the apocryphal character of which is generally
|
||
admitted by contemporary [i.e., present day] scholars." Naming
|
||
first as Nos. 1-4 "The Canonical Gospels," now falsely labelled
|
||
with the names of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, the twenty best
|
||
known ones are listed as follows; viz: The Gospels according to the
|
||
Hebrews; of Peter; According to the Egyptians; of Matthias; of
|
||
Philip; of Thomas; the Proto-Evangelium of James, Gospel of
|
||
Nicodemus (Acta Pilati); of the Twelve Apostles; of Basilides; of
|
||
Valentius; of Marcion; of Eve; of Judas; the Writing Genna Marias;
|
||
the Gospel Teleioseos. (CE. vi, 656.)
|
||
|
||
Individual Gospels were forged in the names of each of the
|
||
Twelve Apostles, severally, and a joint fabrication under the name
|
||
of "The Gospel of the Twelve," was put into the mouths of the
|
||
twelve Apostles, using the first person to give the ear-marks of
|
||
authenticity to their forged utterances; and separately, "Almost
|
||
every one of the Apostles had a Gospel fathered upon him by one
|
||
early sect or another." (EB. i, 259.) Several seem to have been
|
||
fathered upon Matthew besides the one that wrongly heads the list
|
||
of the "canonical Four," such as the Gospel of Matthias, Traditions
|
||
of Matthias, also a supposed and probably non-existent writing in
|
||
Hebrew hypothesized as the basic document of the Four; probably,
|
||
also the so-called Logia, a papyrus scrap of one sheet discovered
|
||
at Oxyrhynchus, Egypt, and containing alleged sayings of Jesus
|
||
which in part correspond with, in part radically differ from the
|
||
sayings attributed to him in the Four. He was also made responsible
|
||
for a so-called Gospel of St. Matthew, dating from the 4th or 5th
|
||
century, which "purports to have been written by Matthew and
|
||
translated by St. Jerome." (CE.. i, 608,)
|
||
|
||
This authority also lists the famous Protevangetium Jacobi, or
|
||
Infancy Gospel of James, the Arabic Gospel of the Infancy, that of
|
||
Gamaliel, the Gospel according to the Hebrews, also According to
|
||
the Egyptians; of the Nazarenes; Gospels of St. Peter, of St.
|
||
Philip, of St. Thomas, of St. Bartholomew, of St. Andrew, of
|
||
Barnabas, of Thaddeus, even notable forged Gospels of Judas
|
||
Iscariot, and of Mother Eve; also the Gospel by Jesus Christ. We
|
||
have the Gospel of Nicodemus, the History of Joseph the Carpenter,
|
||
the Descent into Hades, the Desicent of Mary, the Ascents of James,
|
||
the Prophecy of Hystaspes, the Didache or Teachings of the
|
||
Apostles; the Gospel of the Nativity of the Virgin Mary, the
|
||
Transitum Mariae or Evangelium Joannin. This last named pious
|
||
Christian work, as described by CE. (i, 607-8) is forged in the
|
||
name of St. John the Apostle, and is "prefaced with a spurious
|
||
Letter of the Bishop of Sardis, Melito"; it records how "the
|
||
Apostles are preternaturally transported from different quarters of
|
||
the globe to the Virgin's deathbed, those who have died being
|
||
resurrected for the purpose"; a Jew who dares touch the sacred body
|
||
instantly loses both hands, which are restored through the
|
||
mediation of the Apostles. Christ, accompanied by a band of angels,
|
||
comes down to receive his mother's soul, "the Apostles bear the
|
||
body to Gethsemane and deposit it in a tomb, whence it is taken up
|
||
alive to heaven"; this being an extraordinary miracle, for the body
|
||
was dead and the soul carried to heaven from her home and the dead
|
||
body laid in the grave, where it comes to life again for the
|
||
Heaven-trip. This clumsy fable, says CE., considerably "influenced
|
||
the Fathers" (Ib. i, 608), who were notoriously ehildish-minded. A
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
97
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
very noted and notorious forgery was the Gospel of Paul and Thecla,
|
||
of which Father Tertullian relates, that this story wag fabricated
|
||
by an Elder of Asia Minor, who, when convicted of the fraud --
|
||
[this being the only known instance of such action], -- confessed
|
||
that he had perpetrated it "for the love of St. Paul." (Reinach,
|
||
Orpheus, p. 235.) The Protevangelium Jacobi was "an Apocryphal work
|
||
by a fanciful fabulist, urhampered by knowledge of Jewish affairs,
|
||
contposed before the end of the second century with a view to
|
||
removing the glaring contradictions between Matthew and Mark,"
|
||
regarding the birth and life of Jesus CHrist. (EB. iii, 3343.) An
|
||
"Epistle on the Martyrdom of the Apostles Peter and Paul was at a
|
||
later period attributed to St. Linus. ... It is apoeryphal, and of
|
||
later date than the history of the Martyrdom of the two Apostles,
|
||
by some attributed to Marcellus, which is also apocryphal." (CE.
|
||
ix, 273; see Acta Apostolorum, Apoerypha, xiv.) Other noted
|
||
Fatherly fabrications were the celebrated Epistles I and II of
|
||
Clement to the Corinthians, and the Pseudo-Clementine Recognitions
|
||
and Homilies, purporting to be written by the very doubtful Bishop
|
||
of Rome of that name; very voluminous, and written about 140 A.D.,
|
||
not a line of New Testament "scriptures" do they quote, but they
|
||
quote freely from the O.T. and from various Jewish, Christian and
|
||
Pagan works. (EB. iii, 3486.)
|
||
|
||
Besides the above complete "Gospel" forgeries, there are
|
||
several more, and fragments of others, which purport to contain
|
||
"sayings" attributed to Jesus which are not contained in the Four
|
||
Gospels; and which are known as Agrapha, that is, things not
|
||
written. Among these are the Logia of Oxyrhynchus above mentioned;
|
||
the Fayum gospel-fragment, a papyrus purporting to give words of
|
||
Christ to Peter at the Last Supper, "in a form which diverges
|
||
largely by omissions from any in the canonical gospels." (EB. i,
|
||
258.) These Agrapha "do not embrace the lenghy sections ascribed to
|
||
Jesus in the 'Didiscalin' and the 'Pistis Sophia'; these works also
|
||
contain some brief quotations of alleged words of Jesus; ... nor
|
||
the Sayings contained in religious romances, such as we find in the
|
||
apocryphal Gospels, the apocryphal Acts, or the Letter of Christ to
|
||
Abgar. ... In patristic citations ... Justin Martyr, Clement of
|
||
Alexandria, Origen, make fslse quotations," -- citing instances.
|
||
(CE. i, 225, 226.) In the class of Agrapha are also "words in the
|
||
Gospels not regarded as genuine, as Mt. vi, 13b; xvii, 21; Mk. xvi,
|
||
9-20; John vii, 53; viii, 2; also alleged quotations from the Old
|
||
Testament in the New Testament not found in the Old Testament."
|
||
(NIE. 1, 240.)
|
||
|
||
Of apocryphal Acts of Apostles we are edified by the Acts, or
|
||
Travels, (Greek, Pereodui) of Peter, (and separately) of John, of
|
||
Thomas, of Andrew, and of Paul; another Acts of Philip, Acts of
|
||
Matthew, of Bartholomew, of John, of judas Thomas. There is a whole
|
||
collection of Martyrdoms of the several Apostles. Of apocryphal
|
||
Epistles, the most famous is the Correspondence between the Abgar
|
||
of Edessa, and Jesus; between the Roman Philosopher Seneca and
|
||
Paul; apocryphal Epistles of Paul, to the Laodiceans, to the
|
||
Alexandrians, the Third Epistle to the Corinthians. Forged
|
||
Apocalypses abound, of which that of Peter, the Vision of Hermas,
|
||
the Vision of Paul, the Apocalypge of Paul, the Apocalypse of the
|
||
Virgin Mary. The didactic Preaching of Peter, the Teaching of the
|
||
Apostles, or Didache, containing warnings against Judaism and
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
98
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
polytheism, and words of Jesus to the Apostles; another set
|
||
containing a lament of Peter for his denial of Jesus, and various
|
||
ethical maxims a Syriac Preaching of Simon Cephas; a collection of
|
||
Hymns or Odes of Solomon. As if these were not enough for Christian
|
||
edification, "many heretical or Gnostic works of the same
|
||
apocryphal kind were changed into orthodox by expurgation of
|
||
objectionable matter or by rewriting, using the same outlines; thus
|
||
a series of Catholic Acts was produced, written from an orthodox
|
||
standpoint." (NIE. i, 748.) A very celebrated forgery was the
|
||
Shepherd of Hermas, forged by Hermas,' supposed brother of Pius,
|
||
Bishop of Rome, about 150 A.D. See the vast catalogue (CE. i,
|
||
601-615).
|
||
|
||
A whole literature of Christian forgery grew up and had
|
||
immense vogue under the designation of Acts Pilati, or Acts of
|
||
Pilate. One of the most popular of these was called the Gospel of
|
||
Nicodemus, of which CE,. says: "The alleged Hebrew orignal is
|
||
attributed to Nicodemius; the title is of medieval origin. The
|
||
apocryphon gained wide credit in the Middle Ages. ... The 'Acta'
|
||
are of orthodox composition. The book aimed at gratifying the
|
||
desire for extra-evangelical details concerning oar Lord, and at
|
||
the same time, to strengthen faith in the Resurrection of Christ,
|
||
and at general edification." (i, 3.) The Descent into Hades is an
|
||
enlargement of the reputed official acts or repots of Pilate to the
|
||
Roman Emperor. Speaking of the Pilate Literature as a whole, the
|
||
Catholic Encyclopedia. in a paragraph which pointedly admits the
|
||
falsifying frauds of three luminous liars and forgers of the Faith,
|
||
Justin Martyr, the great Bishop Eusebius, and Father Tertullian,
|
||
explains that these Acta "dwell upon the part which a reresentative
|
||
[Pilate] of the Roman Empire played in the supreme events of our
|
||
Lord's life, and to shape the testimony of Pontius Pilate, even at
|
||
the cost of exaggeration and amplification -- [hear the soft-
|
||
pedaling note], into a weapon of apologetic defense, making the
|
||
official bear witness to the miracles, Crucifixion, and
|
||
Resurrection of Jesus Christ. ... It is characterized by
|
||
exaggerating Pilate's weak defense of Jesus into a strong dympathy
|
||
and practical belief in his Divinity." (CE. i, 609.) Father
|
||
Tertullian, in his Apologia (xxi), relates the Report of Pilate to
|
||
the Emperor, sketching the miracles and death of Jesus Christ, and
|
||
says, "All these things Pilate announced to Tiberius Caesar."
|
||
Bishop Eusebius thus relates the fable as taken from the Apologia
|
||
of Father Tertullian: "The fame of Our Lord's remarkable
|
||
resurrection and ascension being now spread abroad, ... Pontius
|
||
Pilate transmits to Tiberius an account of the circumstances
|
||
concerning the resurrection of our Lord from the dead. ... In this
|
||
account, he also intimated that he had ascertained other miracies
|
||
respecting him, and that having now risen from the dead, he was
|
||
believed to be a God by the great mass of the people. Tiberius
|
||
referred the matter to the Senate, ... being obviously pleased with
|
||
the doctrine; but the Senate, as they had not proposed the matter,
|
||
[rejected it]. But he continued in his opinion, threatening death
|
||
to the accusers of the Chriatians; a divine providence infusing
|
||
this into his mind, that the Gospel having freer scope in its
|
||
commencement, might spread everywhere over the world." (Eusebius,
|
||
HE. II, 2.) Father Justin Martyr, in his Apologia, "appeals
|
||
confidently as a proof of them to the 'Acta' or records of Pilate,
|
||
existing in the imperial archives." Eusebius, relates spurious
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
99
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
anti-Christian Acts of Pilate composed in the fourth century, the
|
||
Acta Pilati or Gospel of Nicodemus, Anphora Pilati, Paradoseis; a
|
||
still later fabrication is the Latin Epistola Pilati ad Tiberium,
|
||
Also the Letter of Herod to Pilate and Letter of Pilate to Herod;
|
||
the Narrative of Joseph of Arimathea. The pseudo-Correspondence of
|
||
Jesus with Abgar, King of Edessa, is found in Eusebius (Hist.
|
||
Eccles., I, xiii), "who vouches that he himself translated it from
|
||
the Syriac documunis in the archives of Edessa, the metropolis, of
|
||
Eastern Syria. ... 'This,' adds Eusebius, 'happened in the year 340
|
||
of the Seleucid era, corresponding to A.D. 28-29.'" (CE. i, 609,
|
||
610.) More monumental lies to the glory of God than those of the
|
||
distinguialied Church Fathers are not "A collection of apocryphal
|
||
Acts of the Apostles was formed in the Frankish Church in the sixth
|
||
century, probably by a monk." (Ib. p. 610.) There were also "the
|
||
works accredited to Dionysius the Areopagite, who was not the
|
||
author of the works bearing his name." (lb. p. 638.)
|
||
|
||
Of highest importance because "these Acts are the chief source
|
||
for details of the martyrdom of the two great Apostles," as admits
|
||
the CE., special notice is made of the "Catholic" Acts of Sts.
|
||
Peter and Paul, of which many MSS of "the legend" existed, the
|
||
material import of which is thus not quite honestly summarized:
|
||
"The Jews have been aroused by the news of Paul's intended visit
|
||
(to Rome), and induce Nero to forbid it. Nevertheless the Apostle
|
||
secretly enters Italy; his companion is mistaken for himself at
|
||
Puteoli and beheaded. In retribution that city is swallowed up by
|
||
the sea. Peter receives Paul at Rome with joy. The preaching of the
|
||
Apostles converts multitudes and even the Empress. Simon Magus
|
||
traduces the Christian teachers, and there is a test of strength in
|
||
miracles between that magician and the Apostles, which takes place
|
||
in the presence of Nero. Simon essays a flight to heaven but falls
|
||
in the Via Sacra and is dashed to pieces, Nevertheless, Nero is
|
||
bent on the destruction of Peter and, Paul. The latter is beheaded
|
||
on the Ostian Way, and Peter is cruciffed at his request head
|
||
downward. Before his death he relates to the people the 'Quo
|
||
Vadis?' story. Three men from the East carry off the Apostles'
|
||
bodies but are overtaken. St. Peter is buried at 'the place called
|
||
the Vatican,' and Paul on the Ostian Way. These Acts are the chief
|
||
source for details of the martyrdom of the two great Apostles. They
|
||
are also noteworthy as emphasizing the close concord between the
|
||
Apostolic founders of the Roman Church." (CE. i, 611-12.)
|
||
|
||
The reader is desired to bear well in mind the foregoing
|
||
paragraph, and particularly the last two sentences, the former of
|
||
immense significance when we come to review the falsified fiction
|
||
of the foundation of the Roman Church by Peter, -- the "chief
|
||
source" of which portentous claim is confessedly founded on the
|
||
crude and fantastic "legend"' of an admittedly forged document.
|
||
Another admission of forgery by the Fathers, before introducing
|
||
them formally, may be noted:, "Such known works as the Shepherd of
|
||
Hermas, the Epistle of Barnabas, the Didache or Teaching of the
|
||
Twelve Apostles, and the Apostolic Canons and Constitutions, though
|
||
formally apocryphal, really belong to patristic literature" (CE. i,
|
||
601), -- that is, they are forged writings of the Fathers.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
100
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
THE FORGFD "APOSTLES' CREED"
|
||
|
||
The "Apotitles' Creed," forged by the Fathers several
|
||
centuries after the Apostles, must be added to the Patristic list.
|
||
Of this famous Creed, which every Christian presumably knows by
|
||
rote and piously recites in numberless services, CE. again
|
||
confesses it spurious: "Throughout the Middle Ages it was generally
|
||
believed that the Apostles, on the day of Pentecost, while still
|
||
under the direct inspiration of the Holy Ghost, composed our
|
||
present Creed, each of the Apostles contributing one of the Twelve
|
||
articles. This legend dates back to the sixth century, and is
|
||
foreshadowed still earlier in a sermon attributed to St. Ambrose,
|
||
which takes notice that the Creed was 'pieced out by twelve
|
||
separate workmen.'" (CE. i, 629.) Indeed, "not a few works have
|
||
been falsely attributed to St. Ambrose." (CE. i, 387; cf. p. 406.)
|
||
|
||
We may smile at the peculiarly clerical way in which CE. would
|
||
"whitewash" the great Bishop of Milan, St. Ambrose (e. 340-397),
|
||
from the lie direct which admittedly he told in that Sermon, --
|
||
saying that the Bishop simply "takes notice that the creed was
|
||
pieced out," etc.; the truth being that Ambrose positively affirmed
|
||
the fable as truth, and may have invented it. His poisitive words
|
||
are; "that the Twelve Apostles, as skilled artificers, assembled
|
||
together, and made a key by their common advice, that is, the
|
||
Creed; by which the darkness of the devil is disclosed, that the
|
||
light of Christ may appear." (Ambrose, Opera, tom. iii., Sermon 38,
|
||
p. 265; quoted in The New Testament Apocrypha, New York, The Truth
|
||
Seeker Co.) -- a work which I feel impelled to commend to all who
|
||
wish to know at first hand the 25 remarkable Chureh "Gospel"
|
||
forgeries there collected.
|
||
|
||
THE FORGED ATHANASIAN CREED
|
||
|
||
In likewise the celebrated Athanasian Creed of the Church,
|
||
attributed to St. Athanasius and so held by the Church "until the
|
||
seventeenth century" (CE. ii, 34), with most evil resiilts, is now
|
||
an admitter forgery. In words of Gibbon: "St. Athanasius is not the
|
||
author of the creed; it does not appear to have existed within a
|
||
century after his death; it was composed in Latin, therefore in one
|
||
of the Western provinces. Gennadius, patriarch of Constitantinoble,
|
||
was so much amazed by this extraordinary composition, that he
|
||
frankly pronounced it to be the work of a drunken man." (Petav.
|
||
Dogmat. Theologica, tom. ii, 1, vii, c. 8, p. 687; Gibbon, p. 598.)
|
||
|
||
JESUS CHRIST'S FORGED LETTERS
|
||
|
||
We may look for a moment at several of the most notorious of
|
||
the forgeries perpetrated for the glory of God and for imposture
|
||
upon the superstitious Christians to enhance Pagan credtulity in
|
||
the tales of Christ. If the Gospel tales were true, why should God
|
||
need pious lies to give them credit? Lies and forgeries are only
|
||
needed to bolster up falsebood: "Nothing stands in need of lying
|
||
but a lie." But Jesus Christ must needs be propagated by lies; upon
|
||
lies, and what better proof of his actuality than to exhibit
|
||
letters written by him in his own handwriting? The "Little Liars of
|
||
the Lord" were equal to the forgery of the signature of their God,
|
||
-- false letters in his name, as above cited from that exhaustless
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
101
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
mine of clerical falsities, the Catholic Encyclopedia, which again
|
||
describes them, and proves that they 'Were forged by their great
|
||
Bisbop of Caesaria: "The historian Eusebius records [HE. I, xii],
|
||
a legend which he himself firmly believes concerning a
|
||
correspondence that took place between Our Lord and the local
|
||
potentate (Abgar) at Edessa. Three documents relate to this
|
||
correspondence: (1) the Letter of Abgar to Our Lord; (2) Our Lord's
|
||
answer; (3) a picture of Our Lord, painted from life. This legend
|
||
enjoyed a great popularity, both in the East, and in the West,
|
||
during the Middle Ages. Our Lord's Letter was copied on parchment,
|
||
marble, and metal, and used as a talisman or an amulet." (CE. i,
|
||
42.) But it is not true, as we have seen already confessed, that
|
||
Eusebius innocently believed that these forgeries were genuine --
|
||
for they were all shamelessly forged by Eusebius himself: "who
|
||
vouches that he himself translated it from the Syriac documents in
|
||
the archives of Edessa." (CE. i, 610.) Again it is said by CE.,
|
||
that these forged letters, with the portrait, were "accepted by
|
||
Eusebius without hesitation, and used by Addision in his work on
|
||
Christian Evidences as genuine" (Ib. vi, 217).
|
||
|
||
It should be mentioned, first, that Abgar was not a personal
|
||
name of a King of Edessa, but was a generic title of all the rulers
|
||
of that small state: "By this title all the toparchs of Edessa were
|
||
called, just as the Roman Emperors were called Caesars, the Kings
|
||
of Egypt Pharaohs or Ptolemies, the Kings of Syria Antiochi." (ANF.
|
||
viii, 651, note.) With this first check on the forging Bishop, here
|
||
is what he said in his Church history, Book I, chapter the
|
||
thirteenth. (p. 63 seq.) Note the false fervor of the holy Bishop
|
||
to sugar-coat his circumstantial and commodious lie and fraud:
|
||
"While the Godhead of our Saviour and Lord Jesut, Christ was
|
||
proclaimed among all men by reason of the astonishing mighty-works
|
||
which He wrought, and myriads, even from countries remote from the
|
||
land of Judaea, who were afflicted with sicknesses and diseases of
|
||
every kind, were coming to him in the hope of being healed, King
|
||
Abgar sent him a letter asking Him to come and heal him of his
|
||
disease. But our Saviour at the time he asked Him did not comply
|
||
with his request. Yet He deigned to give him a letter in reply. ...
|
||
Thou hast in writing the evidence of these things, which is taken
|
||
from the Book of Records which was at Edessa; for at that time the
|
||
Kingdom was still standing. In the documents, then, which were
|
||
there, in which was contained whatever was done by those of old
|
||
down to the time of Abgar, these things are also found preserved
|
||
down to the present hour. There is, however, nothing to prevent our
|
||
hearing the very letters themselves, which have been taken by us
|
||
from the archives, and are in words to this effect, translated from
|
||
Aramaic into Greek.
|
||
|
||
"'Copy of the letter which was written by King Abgar to Jesus,
|
||
and sent to him by the hand of Ananias -- [the Bishop was the
|
||
Ananias in this tale, and aptly named his letter-carrier], -- the
|
||
Tabularius, to Jerusalem:
|
||
|
||
'Abgar the Black, sovereign of the country, to Jesus, the good
|
||
Saviour, who has appeared in the country of Jerusalem: Peace. I
|
||
have heard about Thee, and about the healing which is wrought by
|
||
Thy hands without drugs and roots. For, as it is reported, Thou
|
||
makest the blind to see, and the lame to walk; and Thou cleansest
|
||
the lepers, and Thou castest out unclean spirits and demons, and
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
102
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Thou healest those who are tormented with lingering diseases, and
|
||
Thou raisest the dead. And when I heard all these things about
|
||
Thee, I settled in my mind one of two things: either that Thou art
|
||
God, who has come down from heaven, and doest these things; or that
|
||
Thou art the Son of God, and doest these things. On this account,
|
||
therefore, I have written to beg of Thee that Thou wouldest weary
|
||
Thyself to come to me, and heal this disease which I have. For I
|
||
have also heard that the Jews murmur against Thee, and wish to do
|
||
Thee harm. But I have a city, small and beautiful, which is
|
||
sufficient for two.'
|
||
|
||
"Copy of those things which were written by Jesus in reply by
|
||
the hand of Ananias, the Tabularius, to Abgar, sovereign of the
|
||
country: --
|
||
|
||
'Blessed is he that believeth in me, not having seen me. For
|
||
it is written concerning me, that those who see me will not believe
|
||
in me, and that those will believe who have not seen me, and will
|
||
be saved. But touching that which thou hast written to me, that I
|
||
should come to thee it is meet that I should finish here all that
|
||
for the sake of which I have been sent; and, after I have finished
|
||
it, then I shall be taken up to Him that sent me; and, when I have
|
||
been taken up, I will send to thee one of my disciples, that he may
|
||
heal thy disease, and give salvation to thee and to those who are
|
||
with thee.'
|
||
|
||
"To these letters moreover, is appended the following, also in
|
||
the Aramaic tongue", -- here following the official record of the
|
||
visit of one "Thaddaeus the apostle, one of the Seventy," and him
|
||
wonderful works in Edessa. "These things were done in the year 340.
|
||
In order, moreover that these things may not have been translated
|
||
to no purpose word for word from the Aramaic into Greek, they are
|
||
placed in their order of time here. Here endeth the first book."
|
||
(HE. i, 13; ANF. viii, 651-653.) Bishop Eusebius is thus seen to
|
||
have been a most circumstantial liar and a well-skilled forger for
|
||
God. From this episcopal lie sprouted like toadstools a whole
|
||
literature of "various books concerning Abgar the King and
|
||
Thaddaeus the Apostle," in which are preserved to posterity a
|
||
series of five letters -- very much in the style of modern patent-
|
||
medicine testimonials -- written by Abgar to Tiberius Caesar and to
|
||
neighboring potentates, endorsing Jesus and his healing powers;
|
||
with a reply from Tiberius declaring that "Pilate has officially
|
||
informed us of the miracles of Jesus.". With respect to the other
|
||
letters testimonial, it is recorded: "Abgar had not yet received
|
||
answers to these letters when he died, having reigned thirty-eight
|
||
years." (Ibid. pp. 657-741, 706.)
|
||
|
||
These crass episcopal forgeries were welcomed into the Church,
|
||
and for fifteen centuries have gone unrebuked by Pope or Church.
|
||
Even since the Reformation so strong was the belief in the Abgar-
|
||
Jesus forgeries, that notable prelates in England including
|
||
Archbishop Cave, have "strenuously contended for their admission
|
||
into the canon scripture. ... The Reverend Jeremiah Jones observes,
|
||
that common people in England have this Epistle in their houses, in
|
||
many places, fixed in a frame, with the picture of Christ before
|
||
it; and that they generally, with much honesty and devotion, regard
|
||
it as the word of God, and the genuine Epistle of Christ." (Quoted
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
103
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
in editorial note to the Epistles, in The Lost Books of the Bible,
|
||
p. 62.) To such state of superstitious credulity does the Church
|
||
with its pious impostures prostitute the minds of its ignorant and
|
||
credulous votaries. The portrait of Jesus, referred to above, is
|
||
said, in other versions of the Letter, to have been sent by Jesus
|
||
to the King; this portrait is now displayed at both Rome and Genoa.
|
||
(NIE. i, 38.)
|
||
|
||
OTHER FORGERIES FOR CHRIST'S SAKE
|
||
|
||
The pious fancy of the Fathers forged another official Letter,
|
||
in the name of what CE. calls "a fictitious person," one Lentulus,
|
||
pretended predecessor of Pilate as governor of Judaea, to the Roman
|
||
Senate, giving a description of the personal appearance of Jesus
|
||
Christ, and closing with the words, "He is the most beautiful of
|
||
the sons of men." This letter, says CE. "was certainly apocryphal";
|
||
it was first printed in the Life of Christ, by Ludolph the
|
||
Christian; though it is thought to be traceable to the time of
|
||
Diocletian. (CE. ix, 154.) This notion of the personal beauty of
|
||
Jesus is not shared by the "tradition" of the Fathers; for Jesus
|
||
Christ is declared by Cyril of Alexandria to have been "the ugliest
|
||
of the sons of men"; a tradition also declared by Fathers Justin
|
||
Martyr and Tertullian; to offset which evil notion there was forged
|
||
"a beautiful Letter, purporting to have been written by Lentulus to
|
||
the Roman Senate." (Ib. vi, 235.) But St. Augustine, says CE.,
|
||
"mentions that in his time there was no authentic portrait of
|
||
Christ, and that the type of features was still undetermined, so
|
||
that we have absolutely no knowledge of His appearance." (De
|
||
Trinitate, lib. vii, ch. 4,5; CE. vi, 211, n.)
|
||
|
||
This, however, is contrary to the venerated Church fable and
|
||
artistic forgery current under the title of "St. Veronica's Veil,"
|
||
based on the tale in Luke (xxvii, 27) of the woman of Jerusalem who
|
||
offered to Jesus a linen cloth to wipe his face as he was carrying
|
||
his cross towards Calvary. On wiping his sweating face, the
|
||
supposed authentic likeness of the features of the Christ was
|
||
miraculously impressed upon the cloth. The lucky lady "went to
|
||
Rome, bringing with her this image of Christ, which was long
|
||
exposed to public veneration. To her are likewise traced several
|
||
other relies of the Blessed Virgin venerated in several Churches of
|
||
the West. To distinguish at Rome the oldest and best known of these
|
||
images it was called vera icon (true image), which ordinary
|
||
language soon made veronica ... By degrees popular Imagination
|
||
mistook this word for the name of a person" (CE. xv, 362), -- and,
|
||
Lo! Saint Veronica emerges from the canonizing Saint-mill of Holy
|
||
Church. Here we plainly see myth-in-the-making; and may appreciate
|
||
the moral splendor as well as crafty thriftiness of the Church of
|
||
God which thus supplies its Faithful ready-made with one of the
|
||
most cherished female Saints of the Calendar, -- a confessed myth
|
||
and forgery. His Holiness especially displayed and vouched for this
|
||
fake on March 19, 1930, when he preached his crusade against
|
||
Russia. But the Church also, in the Roman Martyrology, credits this
|
||
holy icon to Milan, so as to fool many other Faithful. (Ib. p.
|
||
363.) This mythical female Saint "has also been confounded with a
|
||
pious woman who, according to [Bishop] Gregory of Tours, brought to
|
||
the neighboring town of Bazas some drops of the blood of John the
|
||
Baptist, at whose beheading she was present," and CE. doesn't even
|
||
wink. (Ib.)
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
104
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
JOSEPHUS FORGERY TESTIFIES OF JESUS
|
||
|
||
So many confessed Christian forgeries in Pagan and Christian
|
||
names having been wrought to testify to Jesus Christ, it was, "one
|
||
naturally expects," says CE., that a Jewish "writer so well
|
||
informed as Josephus" must know and tell about Jesus; "one
|
||
naturally expects, therefore, a notice about Jesus Christ in
|
||
Josephus." And with pride it pursues: "Antiquities, VIII, iii, 3,
|
||
seems to satisfy this expectation." It proceeds to quote the
|
||
passage, which differeth only as one translation naturally differs
|
||
from another, from that in the Whitson translation; so I follow CE.
|
||
In Chapter iii Josephus treats of "Sedition of the Jews against
|
||
Pontius Pilate"; in section 1. he relates the cause and the
|
||
suppression of the mutiny, the ensigns of the army displaying the
|
||
idolatrous Roman Eagle, brought into the Holy City; in section 2.
|
||
he tells of the action of Pilate in bringing "a current of water to
|
||
Jerusalem, and did it with the sacred money," thus again arousing
|
||
a clash with the fanatics; "there were great numbers of them slain
|
||
by this means." Passing for the moment the notorious section 3,
|
||
Josephus the Jew begins section 4: "About the same time, also,
|
||
another sad calamity put the Jews in disorder," which he proceeds
|
||
to relate, ending the long chapter. Note that these section numbers
|
||
were not put in by Josephus, but are modern editor's devices to
|
||
facilitate citation, like the chapters and verses in the Bible. And
|
||
now for the much-debated section, sandwiched, in a whole chapter on
|
||
"Seditions of the Jews," between the accounts of two massacres of
|
||
his countrymen and "another sad calamity"; and thus we read -- note
|
||
the parentheses of CE. (viii, 376): --
|
||
|
||
"About this time," quotes CE., "appeared Jesus, a wise man (if
|
||
indeed it is right to call Him a man; for He was a worker of
|
||
astonishing deeds, a teacher of such men an receive the truth with
|
||
joy), and He drew to Himself many Jews (and many also of the
|
||
Greeks. This was the Christ). And when Pilate, at the denunciation
|
||
of those that are foremost among us, had condemned Him to the
|
||
cross, those who had first loved Him did not abandon Him. (For He
|
||
appeared to them alive on the third day, the holy prophets having
|
||
foretold this and countless other marvels about Him.) The tribe of
|
||
Christians named after Him did not cease to this day." (see. 3.)
|
||
|
||
About this time, also "another sad calamity [?] put the Jews
|
||
into disorder," (sec. 4). continues Josephus. CE. devotes over
|
||
three long columns to the task of trying to prove that this section
|
||
3, or at least "the portions not in parentheses," -- is genuine,
|
||
and was written, sometime before his death in 94 A.D., by the
|
||
Jewish Pharisee, Josephus. "A testimony so important," well says
|
||
CE., "could not escape the critics," -- and it has not. We cannot
|
||
follow the lengthy and labored arguments; the simple reading or the
|
||
section, in its bizarre context, and a moment's reflection, condemn
|
||
it as a pious Christian forgery. If the Pharisee Josephus wrote
|
||
that paragraph, he must have believed that Jesus was the Prophesied
|
||
Messiah of his people -- "This was the Christ." Josephus is made to
|
||
aver, he must then needs have been of "the tribe of Christians
|
||
named after Him." But whatever Josephus may have said about Jesus
|
||
is, indeed, not "a testimony so important" -- when we remember what
|
||
he did aver that he saw with his own eyes; the pillar of salt into
|
||
which Mrs. Lot was turned; and Eleazar the magician drawing the
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
105
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
devil by a ring and Solomonic incantations, through the nose of one
|
||
possessed, before Vespasian and all his army. If Josephus had
|
||
written that he knew Jesus the Christ personally, and had
|
||
personally seen him ascend into heaven through the roof of the room
|
||
in Jerusalem (Mk. xvi, 19, 20), or from the open countryside by
|
||
Bethany (Lk. xxiv, 50, 51), or "on the mount called Olivet" (Acts
|
||
i, 9, 12), -- we should remember that pillar of salt and that
|
||
devil-doctor, and smile.
|
||
|
||
But, when and how did this famous passage get into The
|
||
Antiquities of the Jews? it, is pertinent to ask. The first mention
|
||
ever made of this passage, and its text, are in the Church History
|
||
of that "very dishonest writer," Bishop Eusebius, in the fourth
|
||
century, -- he who forged the Letters between Abgar and Jesus,
|
||
falsely declaring that he had found the original documents in the
|
||
official archives, whence he had copied and translated them into
|
||
his Ecclesiastical History. CE. admits, and I have the Contra
|
||
Celsum here before me, -- that "the above cited passage was not
|
||
known to Origen and the earlier patristic writers," -- though they
|
||
copied from Josephus the forged tale of the Letter of Aristeas
|
||
about the translating of the Septuagint; and "its very place in the
|
||
Josephan text is uncertain, since Eusebius (Hist. Eccl., II, vi)
|
||
must have found it before the notices concerning Pilate, while it
|
||
now stands after them" (HE. I, ii, p. 63); and it makes the curious
|
||
argument, which implies a confession: "But the spuriousness of the
|
||
disputed Josephan passage does not imply the historian's ignorance
|
||
of the facts connected with Jesus Christ"! For a wonder, that "a
|
||
writer so well informed as Josephus" should not, perhaps, know by
|
||
hearsay, sixty years after Jesus Christ, some of the remarkable
|
||
things circulated about him in current country-side gossip -- (if,
|
||
indeed, it were then current). But the fact is, that with the
|
||
exception of this one incongruous forged passage, section 3, the
|
||
wonder-mongering Josephus makes not the slightest mention of his
|
||
wonder-working fellow-countryman, Jesus the Christ, -- though some
|
||
score of other Joshuas, or Jesuses, are recorded by him, nor does
|
||
he mention any of his transcendent wonders, But, as CE. and I were
|
||
saying, none of the Fathers, before Eusebius (about 324), knew or
|
||
could find a word in the works of Josephus, of this momentous
|
||
"testimony to Jesus," over a century after Origen. That it did not
|
||
exist in the time of Origen is explicit by his own words; he cites
|
||
the supposed references by Josephus to John the Baptist and to
|
||
James, and expressly says that Josephus ought to have spoken of
|
||
Jesus instead of James; though Origen does not correctly describe
|
||
the reference to James; and the James passage, if not that also
|
||
about John, has a suspicious savor of interpolation.
|
||
|
||
For a clear understanding of this, I will quote the passage of
|
||
Origen in his work against Celsus; it completely refutes the claim
|
||
that Josephus wrote the disputed and forged section 3. Origen says:
|
||
|
||
"I would like to say to Celsus, who represents the Jew
|
||
accepting John somehow as a Baptist, who baptized Jesus, that the
|
||
existence of John the Baptist, baptizing for the remission of sins,
|
||
is related by one who lived no great time after John and Jesus. For
|
||
in the 18th book of his Antiquities of the Jews, Josephus bears
|
||
witness to John as having been a Baptist, and as promising
|
||
purification to those who underwent the rite. Now this writer,
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
106
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
although not believing in Jesus as the Christ, in seeking after the
|
||
cause of the fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the temple
|
||
[said that it was 'to avenge James the Just'], whereas he ought to
|
||
have said that the conspiracy against Jesus was the cause of these
|
||
calamities befalling the people, since they put to death Christ,
|
||
who was a prophet, says nevertheless -- being, although against his
|
||
will, not far from the truth -- that these disasters happened to
|
||
the Jews as a punishment for the death of James the Just, who was
|
||
a brother of Jesus (called Christ), -- the Jews having put him to
|
||
death, although he was a man most distinguished for his justice."
|
||
(Origen, Contra Celsum, I, xlvii; ANF. iv, 416.)
|
||
|
||
Josephus is thus quoted as bearing witness to John the
|
||
Baptist, not as the Heaven-sent "forerunner" of the Christ, but
|
||
simply as a Jewish religious teacher and baptizer on his own
|
||
account; and not a word by Josephus about the Christ, in whom it is
|
||
admitted that he did not believe as such, nor even mentions as the
|
||
most illustrious of those baptized by John, to the wondrous
|
||
accompaniment of a voice from Heaven and the Holy Ghost in dove-
|
||
like descent upon his head as he came up from the water. But
|
||
Origen, in his effort to get some Christian testimony from him,
|
||
misquotes Josephus and makes him say that John was baptizing "for
|
||
the remission of sins," whereas Josephus expressly says that the
|
||
efficacy of John's baptism was not for remission of sin but for the
|
||
purification of the body, as any washing would be. To vindicate
|
||
Josephus against Origen, the former's words are quoted. Josephus
|
||
recounts the defeat of Herod by Aretas, king of Arabia Petrea; and
|
||
goes on to say: --
|
||
|
||
"Now some of the Jews thought that the destruction of
|
||
Herod's army came from God, and that very justly, as a
|
||
punishment of what he did against John, that was called the
|
||
Baptist; for Herod slew him, who was a good man, and commanded
|
||
the Jews to exercise virtue, both as to righteousness toward
|
||
one another, and piety toward God, and so to come to baptism;
|
||
for that the washing would be acceptable to him, if they made
|
||
use of it, not in order to the putting away of some sins, but
|
||
for the purification of the body: supposing still that the
|
||
soul was thoroughly purified beforehand by righteousness. Now,
|
||
when many others came in crowds about him, for they were
|
||
greatly moved by hearing his words, Herod, who feared lest the
|
||
great influence John had over the people might put it into his
|
||
power and inclination to raise a rebellion, (for they seemed
|
||
ready to do anything he should advise,) thought it best, by
|
||
putting him to death, to prevent any mischief he might cause,
|
||
and not bring himself into difficulties, by sparing a man who
|
||
might make him repent of it when it should be too late.
|
||
Accordingly, he was sent a prisoner, out of Herod's suspicious
|
||
temper, to Macherus, the castle I before mentioned, and was
|
||
there put to death." (Josephus, Antiq. Jews, Bk. XVIII, v, 2.)
|
||
|
||
Beginning in section 4. of the same Book, and at length in
|
||
various chapters, Josephus goes into details regarding Salome; but
|
||
never a word of the famous dance-act and of the head of John the
|
||
Baptist being brought in on a charger to gratify her murderous
|
||
whim: the historical reason for the murder of John was political,
|
||
not amorous or jealous, as related by Gospel-truth.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
107
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Father Origen again falls into error in citing Josephus, this
|
||
time in the dubious passage where Josephus, who does not believe in
|
||
the Christ, yet gives him that title in speaking of the death of
|
||
James. With typical clerical bent Father Origen imputes the fall of
|
||
Jerusalem and the destruction of the temple to the sin of the Jews
|
||
in crucifying the Christ; and says that Josephus, in seeking the
|
||
cause of the disasters which befell the Holy City and people,
|
||
attributes them to the killing of the Christ's brother. The Holy
|
||
City and temple were destroyed in 70 A.D., which was well after the
|
||
time of the supposititious James, as his demise is recorded in the
|
||
suspected passage of Josephus. He related the death of Festus,
|
||
which was in 62 A.D., the appointment by Nero of Albinus as his
|
||
successor, and the murder of James at the instigation of the high
|
||
priest Ananus, before Albinus can arrive. this sentence is to be
|
||
read in the text of Josephus:
|
||
|
||
"Festus was now dead, and Albinus was but upon the road;
|
||
so he (Ananus) assembled the sanhedrin of judges, and brought
|
||
before them the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ, whose
|
||
name was James, and some others; and when he had formulated an
|
||
accusation against them all breakers of the law, he delivered
|
||
them to be stoned." (Jos., Antiq. Jews, Bk. XX, ix, i.)
|
||
|
||
Bishop Eusebius cannot pass over this chance to turn another
|
||
Jewish testimony for his Christ; he says that "The wiser part of
|
||
the Jews were of the opinion that this -- (the killing of James) --
|
||
was the cause of the immediate siege of Jerusalem ... Josephus also
|
||
has not hesitated to superadd his testimony in his works. "These
|
||
things,' he says, 'happened to the Jews to avenge James the Just,
|
||
who was the brother of him that is called Christ, and whom the Jews
|
||
had slain, notwithstanding his preeminent justice.'" (Euseb. Hist.
|
||
Eccles. Bk. II, ch. 23.)
|
||
|
||
The reader may judge of the integrity of these pretended
|
||
Jewish testimonies to the Baptist and to the brother of the Christ,
|
||
both suspicious per se, and both falsely cited by Father Origen,
|
||
who in all this could not find the famous section 3, first found a
|
||
century later by Bishop Eusebius; and which Origen makes it
|
||
positive Josephus had not written and could not have written. Is it
|
||
a violent suspicion, and uncharitable, to suggest that the holy
|
||
Bishop who forged the Letter of his Christ, and lied about finding
|
||
it in the Edessa archives, really "found," in the sense of
|
||
invented, or forged, the Josephus passages first heard of in his
|
||
Church History?
|
||
|
||
But Bishop Eusebius, with a sort of "stop thief" forethought,
|
||
himself imputes forgery to those who would question or discredit
|
||
his own pious inventions, while with unctuous fervor pretended
|
||
truth he appeals to the wonderful "testimonies of Josephus," which
|
||
he has just fabricated. After quoting and misquoting Josephus with
|
||
respect to John the Baptist and Jesus Christ, he thur solemnly
|
||
couches for their false witness: "When such testimony as this is
|
||
transmitted to us by an historian who sprung from the Hebrews
|
||
themselves, both respecting John the Baptist and our Savior, what
|
||
subterfuge can be left, to prevent those from being convicted
|
||
destitute of all shame, who have forged the acts against them?"
|
||
(Eusebius, HE. I, xi.) The Bishop justly pronounces his own
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
108
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
condemnation. This, says Gibbon, "is an example of no vulgar
|
||
forgery." (Chap. xvi.) In view of the convicting circumstances, and
|
||
of his notoriously bad record, it, is not uncharitable to impute
|
||
this Josephus forgery to Bishop Eusebius.
|
||
|
||
THE OWL-ANGEL FORGERY
|
||
|
||
Another story of Pagan superstition related by Josephus, and
|
||
twisted by the Christian invention of Bishop Eusebius and the
|
||
sacred writers of Acts into inspired "history" and truth of God, is
|
||
the celebrated angel-owl passage relating to the tragic death of
|
||
the King, Herod Agrippa. Josephus tells that Herod went to Caesarea
|
||
to attend a celebration in honor of Caesar; that as Herod entered
|
||
the stadium, clad in a robe of silver tissue, the rays of the sun
|
||
shone upon it resplendently, making him look like a supernatural
|
||
being; whereupon the crowd cried out hailing him as more than
|
||
mortal, as a god; but his mortality was quickly made evident by his
|
||
sudden illness and death. It may be explained that the word "angel"
|
||
(Greek, angelos) means simply "messenger" or herald. Thus proceeds
|
||
Josephus:
|
||
|
||
"But" he [Herod] presently afterward looked up, he saw an
|
||
owl sitting upon a certain rope over his head, and immediately
|
||
understood that this bird was a messenger [Gr. angelos] of
|
||
ill-tidings." Herod was shortly seized with "severe pains in
|
||
his belly," and died after five days of suffering." (Jos.
|
||
Antiq. Jews, XIX, viii, 2.)
|
||
|
||
This was too Paganish and prosaic for the pious Christian
|
||
fancy of Bishop Eusebius; so while he was forging the "Jesus
|
||
passage," he proceeded to give Christian embellishment for
|
||
edification to the "owl" story, with its use of the word "angelos."
|
||
So he quotes in full the narration of Josephus, under the chapter
|
||
heading "Herod Agrippa persecuting the Apostles, immediately
|
||
experienced divine Judgment." he first relates the "martyrdom of
|
||
James" by Herod, and the imprisonment of Peter, as recorded in
|
||
Acts, and proceeds: "The consequences, however, of the king's
|
||
attempts against the apostles, were not long deferred, but the
|
||
avenging minister of divine justice soon overtook him. ... As it is
|
||
also recorded in the book of Acts, he proceeded to Caesarea, and
|
||
there on a noted festival, being clad in a splendid and royal
|
||
dress, he harangued the people. ... The whole people applauding him
|
||
for his harangue, as it were the voice of a god, and not of a man,
|
||
the Scriptures relate, 'that the angel of the Lord immediately
|
||
smote him and being consumed by worms, he gave up the ghost.' It is
|
||
wonderful to observe, likewise, in this singular event, the
|
||
coincidence of the history given by Josephus, with that of the
|
||
sacred Scriptures. In this he [Josephus] plainly adds his testimony
|
||
to the truth, in the nineteenth book of his Antiquities, where he
|
||
relates the miracles in the following words: [here quoting Josephus
|
||
in full, until he reaches the owl-story, when he thus falsifies]:
|
||
-- 'After a little While, raising himself, he saw an angel
|
||
[angelos] hanging over his head upon a rope,, and this he knew
|
||
immediately to be an omen of evil'! Thus far Josephus: in which
|
||
statement, as in others, I can but admire his agreement with the
|
||
divine Scriptures"! (Eusebius, HE. II, x.) An angel hanging on a
|
||
rope over one's head might well have been taken by a superstitious
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
109
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
person as ominous of something -- maybe of a hung angel. This pious
|
||
story, with the owl piously metamorphosed into an angel, was
|
||
apparently cribbed from Josephus also by the writer of Acts, or
|
||
maybe "interpolated" into it by the fanciful Bishop. There we find
|
||
this Pagan-Jewish anecdote retold by divine inspiration thus
|
||
embellished over Josephus and Eusebius: "And immediately the angel
|
||
of the Lord [Gr. angelos Kurioul smote him, because he gave not God
|
||
the glory: and he was eaten of worms and gave up the ghost"! (Acts
|
||
xii, 20-23.) Note the almost identical words, except for the
|
||
progressive embellishments: Josephus' owl thus became first an
|
||
angel of evil omen, then the avenging minister of the wrath of God,
|
||
aided by devouring worms to give true Christian zest and spite to
|
||
the simple Pagan superstition. Herod probably died from acute
|
||
indigestion caused by the excesses of the festivities, or from an
|
||
attack of peritonitis or appendicitis. Profane history of the event
|
||
does not chronicle the devouring, avenging worms of God.
|
||
|
||
The forgery of pious documents of every imaginable character
|
||
was among the most constant and zealous activities of the holy
|
||
propagandists of the Christian Faith, from the beginning to the
|
||
critical era when forgeries were no longer possible or profitable.
|
||
A fitting close to this review is the following omnibus confession
|
||
-- the Churches cheating each other by forgeries:
|
||
|
||
"Indeed, in later times, we hear of recovered autographs
|
||
of Apostolic writings in the controversies about the Apostolic
|
||
origin of some Churches or about claims for metropolitan
|
||
dignity. So the autograph of the Gospel of St. Matthew was
|
||
said to have been found in Cyprus. ... Eusebius (Hist. Eccles.
|
||
vii, 19) relates that in his time the seat of St. James was as
|
||
yet extant in Jerusalem. Of old pictures of Apostles, see
|
||
Eusebius, ibid, vii, 18. Whether or not even the oldest of
|
||
these statements are historically true remains still a mooted
|
||
question. We regard it as useless to record what may be found
|
||
on these topirg in the vast amount of matter that makes up the
|
||
apocryphal Acts of the Apostles and other legendary
|
||
documents." (CE. 635.)
|
||
|
||
Among some of these not already mentioned are found "The
|
||
Gospel of Our Lord Jesus Christ, the Canons of Pseudo-Hippolytus,
|
||
The Egyptian Church Ordinance." (CE. i, 636.) Also: "In the last
|
||
years of the fifth century a famous document attributed to Popes
|
||
Gelasius and Hormisdas adds ... a list of books disapproved, the
|
||
works of heretics, and forged Scriptural documents." (CE. vi, 4.)
|
||
A glance at the Index-volume of CE. reveals the numerous forged
|
||
works attributed to many of the Fathers of the early Church, listed
|
||
under the word Pseudo, or false, which word is to be understood as
|
||
prefixed to each of the following names: Pseudo-Alquin, Ambrosius,
|
||
Antoninus, Areopagite, Athanasius, Augustine, Barnabas,
|
||
Callisthenes, Chrysostom, Clement, Epiphanius, Gelasius, Gregory,
|
||
Nazianzen, Hegesippus, Hippolytus, Ignatius, Isidore, Jonathan,
|
||
Justin, Matthew, Prochorus, Tertullian, Zaeharius. The pious
|
||
ignorant "Christians, who for the most part are untrained and
|
||
illiterate persons," as shown in the Octavius of Minucius Felix (V,
|
||
xi), and the whole Church, were gulled by these frauds for a
|
||
thousand years.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
110
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Before looking into the forgery of the New Testament Books, we
|
||
shall first draw, from their own words, cameo pen-sketches of those
|
||
great men of God and of Holy Church, who under the fond name of
|
||
Fathers, but with the minds and devious ways of little children,
|
||
forged the sacred documents of the Faith, and by their pious labors
|
||
of fraud and forgery founded what is credulously called the Church
|
||
of Christ and the Most Holy Christian Faith.
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
|
||
Abbreviations used for most often used sources:
|
||
|
||
The libraries of the Union Theological Seminary and of
|
||
Columbia University, in New York City, were the places of the finds
|
||
here recorded. Cited so often, space will be saved for more
|
||
valuable uses by citing by their initials, -- which will become
|
||
very familiar -- my chief ecclesiastical authorities, towit:
|
||
|
||
The Ante-Nicene Fathers, cited as ANF.; A Collection of the
|
||
extant Writings of all the Founders of Christianity down to the
|
||
Council of Nicaea, or Nice, in 325 A.D. American Reprint, eight
|
||
volumes. The Christian Literature Publishing Co., Buffalo, N.Y.,
|
||
1885. [xxx]
|
||
|
||
The Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, cited as N&PNF.; First and
|
||
Second Series; many volumes; same publishers.
|
||
|
||
The Catholic Encyclopedia, cited as CE.; fifteen volumes and
|
||
index, published under the Imprimatur of Archbishop Farley; New
|
||
York, Robert Appleton Co., 1907-9.
|
||
|
||
The Encyclopedia Biblica, cited as EB., four volumes; Adam &
|
||
Charles Black, London, 1899; American Reprint, The Macmillan Co.,
|
||
New York, 1914.
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
||
|
||
The UNITED STATES of America
|
||
must again become
|
||
The Free Market-Place of Ideas.
|
||
|
||
The Bank of Wisdom is always looking for more of these old,
|
||
hidden, suppressed and forgotten books that contain needed facts
|
||
and information for today. If you have such books please contact
|
||
us, we need to give them back to America.
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
You are reading
|
||
FORGERY IN CHRISTIANITY
|
||
by
|
||
Joseph Wheliss
|
||
1930
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
111
|
||
|