mirror of
https://github.com/nhammer514/textfiles-politics.git
synced 2024-12-11 00:34:28 -05:00
636 lines
41 KiB
XML
636 lines
41 KiB
XML
<xml><p> From: NLNS
|
|
Subject: Project Censored</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>By <ent type='PERSON'>Carl Jensen</ent>,Ph.D.
|
|
Director of "Project Censored"
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University
|
|
Rohnert Park, <ent type='GPE'>California</ent></p>
|
|
|
|
<p>What is Project Censored?</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The basic premise of Project Censored is that the mass media have failed
|
|
to provide the public with all the information it needs to succeed and
|
|
prosper as a society.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>While <ent type='GPE'>the United</ent> States may have a free press and the most sophisti-cated communications system in the world, unfortunately a free press and
|
|
high technology do not guarantee a well-informed society.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The problem is not the quantity of information, which sometimes reaches
|
|
an overload level, but the quality of information. For example, when
|
|
something starts to go wrong in your personal life, there generally are
|
|
some warning signals that alert you to the problem. If you are a
|
|
rational person, you normally would act upon that information in an
|
|
effort to solve the problem.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>So too, it is with a society. When a problem arises, there should be a
|
|
warning signal -- information-- that alerts the citizens that something
|
|
is wrong which needs attention and resolution. An aware and informed
|
|
populace could then influence its leaders to act upon that information
|
|
in an effort to solve the problem. This, unfortunately, is not the case
|
|
in <ent type='GPE'>the United</ent> States as we are becoming abundantly aware during these
|
|
difficult times.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>I would suggest that a systematic omission of news about significant
|
|
issues in our major news media has led to a dangerously distorted
|
|
picture of <ent type='GPE'>America</ent> in the late 20th Century. This false picture of
|
|
society, while perhaps reassuring to, or even desired by, an elite group
|
|
in our society, represents a festering sore that must be treated if we
|
|
are to survive as a nation.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>To understand how this situation has come about in a society with a free
|
|
press that mass produces information, we must understand how the flow
|
|
of information is controlled.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>In totalitarian societies, we find outright, overt censorship. The
|
|
state, through its bureaucracy, determines what can or cannot be said or
|
|
printed and maintains its control of the information flow through a
|
|
monopoly on the means of production of the information industry. The
|
|
massive coverup of the <ent type='GPE'>Chernobyl</ent> disaster by <ent type='NORP'>Communist</ent> leaders is a
|
|
classic example of this form of censorship. In late 1991, a
|
|
parliamentary commission, chaired by <ent type='PERSON'>Volodymyr Yavorivsky</ent>, revealed
|
|
that in April 1986 <ent type='NORP'>Soviet</ent> authorities reacted to the <ent type='GPE'>Chernobyl</ent> nuclear
|
|
power accident with "a total lie, falsehoods, coverup and concealment"
|
|
which led to thousands of deaths.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>In societies perceived as free, we find the information output deter-mined by economic pressures to produce corporate profits, by a system-atic distribution of "punishment and reward" to workers in the media,
|
|
and by a less obvious, but nonetheless effective, control of the means
|
|
of production of the information industry. The latter is
|
|
well-documented in <ent type='PERSON'>Ben</ent> Bagdikian's book "The Media Monopoly."</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>In both cases, the efforts to manipulate and control the flow of
|
|
information are successful -- whether by overt censorship or by covert
|
|
censorship. The crucial difference is that the citizens in a
|
|
totalitarian society are aware that their information is controlled
|
|
and manipulated and they conduct their lives with that knowledge.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>However, the citizens of a free society, such as <ent type='GPE'>the United</ent> States, want
|
|
to believe the mass media provide them with a fair, objective, and
|
|
uncensored report of what is happening in the world around them and thus
|
|
are lulled into a false sense of being well-informed.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Project Censored Launched</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>In 1976, concerned about increasing social problems and public apa-thy, I launched a national research effort, called Project Censored, to
|
|
explore whether there really is a systematic omission of certain issues
|
|
in our national news media. My quest was specifically stimulated by
|
|
personal bewilderment over how the <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n people could elect Richard
|
|
Nixon by a landslide after <ent type='EVENT'>Watergate</ent>, one of the most sensational
|
|
political crimes of the century.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Project Censored is now an international media research project in its
|
|
16th year. By exploring and publicizing stories on important issues
|
|
that have been overlooked or underreported by the news media, the
|
|
project seeks to stimulate journalists and editors to provide more mass
|
|
media coverage of those issues. It also hopes to encourage the general
|
|
public to seek out and demand more information on those issues.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Since its start, the research project has generated queries for more
|
|
information about the project as well as about individual stories from
|
|
journalists, scholars, and concerned people throughout the world. It
|
|
has been described variously as a tip sheet for investigative television
|
|
programs like "60 Minutes" and " 20/20,' ' as a distant early warning
|
|
system for society's problems, and even as a "moral force" in <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n
|
|
media. In 1988, <ent type='ORG'>the national</ent> Association for Education in Journalism
|
|
and Mass Communication cited the project for "providing a new model for
|
|
media criticism for journalism education." Project Censored was the
|
|
model for <ent type='LOC'>Bay Area</ent> Censored, a regional research effort that calls
|
|
attention to the most important <ent type='GPE'>San Francisco</ent> <ent type='LOC'>Bay Area</ent> stories that the
|
|
local media under-report or ignore. <ent type='LOC'>Bay Area</ent> Censored, now in its third
|
|
year, is sponsored by the Media Alliance, a <ent type='GPE'>San Francisco</ent>-based
|
|
organization of journalists.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The Project director has been cited by <ent type='ORG'>the Giraffe</ent> Project for "sticking
|
|
his neck out for the common good; " been honored with the Media Alli-ance Meritorious Achievement Award in the "<ent type='ORG'>Unimpeachable</ent> of the annual
|
|
Freedom of Information Award from <ent type='ORG'>the Society</ent> of Professional
|
|
Journalists, in <ent type='GPE'>Los Angeles</ent>; and was named the "Outstanding Journalism
|
|
Teacher of 1991" at the four-year college level by <ent type='ORG'>the California</ent>
|
|
Newspaper Publishers Association.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Despite its growing impact and recognition, the Project has largely been
|
|
ignored by the major news media in <ent type='GPE'>the United</ent> States, which,
|
|
incidentally, are not known for their inclination to accept and evaluate
|
|
criticism. Supporters of Project Censored regularly nominate the pro-ject itself as a top "censored' ' story of the year. This may be
|
|
changing, however. The Project's first major national media recognition
|
|
occurred in February, 1991,when it was the subject of an hour-long
|
|
documentary on <ent type='ORG'>PBS</ent>-TV, hosted by Bill <ent type='ORG'>Moyers</ent>.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Information about securing a copy of the videotape, titled "<ent type='ORG'>Moyers</ent>:
|
|
Project Censored," is available from <ent type='ORG'>Public Affairs Television</ent>, 356 West
|
|
58th St., <ent type='GPE'>New York</ent>, NY 10019, (212/560-6961).</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The Censored Research Process</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Researchers in the censorship seminar I teach at <ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University
|
|
have reviewed thousands of stories over the past 16 years that many
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>America</ent>ns have not seen or heard about. The stories are nominated
|
|
annually by journalists, scholars, librarians, and the general public
|
|
from throughout <ent type='GPE'>the United</ent> States and abroad.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>We then select the top 25 stories according to a number of criteria in-cluding the amount of coverage the story received, the importance of the
|
|
issue, the reliability of the source, and the potential impact the story
|
|
may have. Next, the top 25 "censored" stories are submitted in synopsis
|
|
form to a panel of judges who select the top ten stories of the year.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>A review of the project to date reveals that the major news media do
|
|
systematically overlook, ignore, or distort certain subjects. The most
|
|
under-reported category of ignored subjects deals with political or gov-ernmental issues ranging from regulatory agencies to foreign
|
|
political/ military involvement to the presidency. The second leading
|
|
category of stories deals with business and economic issues or what some
|
|
call "corporate crime. " The third-ranked subject area concerns dangers
|
|
to an individual's health, whether from poisonous pesticides or
|
|
pharmaceutical malfeasance or low-level radiation. Other leading
|
|
subjects often under covered by the mainstream press include civil and
|
|
human rights, the military, and the environment.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Why Are Some Issues Overlooked?</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>One of the questions often asked is why doesn't the press cover the
|
|
issues raised by Project Censored. The failure of the news media to
|
|
cover critical and sometimes controversial issues consistently and in
|
|
depth is not, as some say, a conspiracy on the part of the media elite.
|
|
News is too diverse, fast-breaking, and unpredictable to be controlled
|
|
by some sinister conservative eastern establishment media cabal.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>However, there are a variety of factors operating that, when combined,
|
|
lead to the systematic failure of the news media to fully inform the
|
|
public. While it is not an overt form of censorship, such as the kind
|
|
we observe in some other societies, it is nonetheless real and often
|
|
equally dangerous.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The media's explanations for censorship are plentiful. Sometimes a
|
|
source for a story isn't considered to be reliable; other times the
|
|
story doesn't have an easily identifiable "beginning, middle, and end;"
|
|
some stories are considered to be "too complex" for the general public;
|
|
on occasion stories are ignored because they haven't been "blessed" by
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>The New York</ent> Times or <ent type='ORG'>The Washington Post</ent>. Reporters and editors at
|
|
most of the other 1650 daily newspapers know their news judgment isn't
|
|
going to be challenged when they produce the-leader" stories, a practice
|
|
which leads to the "pack" or "herd" phenomenon in journalism.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Another major factor contributing to media self-censorship is that the
|
|
story is considered potentially libelous. There is no question that
|
|
long and costly jury trials, and sometimes large judgments against the
|
|
media, have produced a massive chilling effect on the press and replaced
|
|
copy editors with copy attorneys.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Nonetheless, the bottom line explanation for much of the censorship
|
|
found in the mainstream media is the media's own bottom line. Corpo-rate media perceive their primary responsibility is to maximize profits,
|
|
not, as some would have it, to inform the public. Many of the stories
|
|
cited by Project Censored are not in the best financial interests of
|
|
publishers, owners, stockholders, or advertisers. Equally important,
|
|
investigative journalism is more expensive than the traditional public
|
|
stenographers school of journalism. And, of course, there is always the
|
|
"don't rock the boat" mentality which pervades corporate media
|
|
boardrooms.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Jonathan Alter</ent>, media columnist for Newsweek, suggests an additional
|
|
reason for the lack of coverage given some issues. According to <ent type='ORG'>Alter</ent>,
|
|
some stories are not covered because they do not fit conventional
|
|
definitions of news. This, of course, is why I suggest it is time for
|
|
journalism to rethink its traditional definitions of news. In a time of
|
|
pending economic doom, nuclear terrorism, and environmental disaster,
|
|
it is not news when a man bites a dog.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Real news is not repetitive, sensationalistic coverage of
|
|
non-important events such as the <ent type='PERSON'>William Kennedy</ent> Smith Palm <ent type='PERSON'>Beach</ent> trial
|
|
which attracted so much media attention in 1991.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>By contrast, real news is objective and reliable information about
|
|
important events happening in a society. And I suggest that the
|
|
widespread dissemination of such information will help people become
|
|
better informed and that a better informed public will elect
|
|
politicians who are more responsive to people's needs.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>A Smoking Gun! <ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent> Censors <ent type='GPE'>Bohemian Grove</ent> Story</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Critics of Project Censored, who deny there is such a thing as media
|
|
self-censorship, often ask for "smoking gun" examples. Then, when
|
|
provided with such examples, they too often merely ignore them. None-theless, here's another example, excerpted from an article I wrote for
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>Fine Line</ent>, The Newsletter On Journalism Ethics, "Project Censored,
|
|
Sins of Omission and The Hardest 'W' of all -- Why," November/ December
|
|
1991 .</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Perhaps the most blatant recent example of media self-censorship, and
|
|
media denial, is an incident which occurred during the summer of 1991.
|
|
The <ent type='GPE'>Bohemian Grove</ent> encampment, which draws the cream of America's male
|
|
power elite -- including press moguls -- to northern <ent type='GPE'>California</ent> each
|
|
year, is one of the media's best known, best kept secrets.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Dirk Mathison</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>San Francisco</ent> bureau chief for <ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent> at the
|
|
time, managed to surreptitiously infiltrate the encampment in search of
|
|
a good story. And he got it. He recorded a variety of newsworthy
|
|
items, including a previously unpublicized <ent type='EVENT'>Gulf War</ent> <ent type='NORP'>Iraqi</ent> casualty
|
|
count of 200000 as reported to the <ent type='ORG'>Bohemian Club</ent> members by former
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>Navy</ent> Secretary <ent type='PERSON'>John Lehman</ent>. Unfortunately, <ent type='PERSON'>Mathison</ent> was spotted by a
|
|
Time Inc. executive and quietly ordered to leave.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The article, which <ent type='PERSON'>Mathison</ent> said was scheduled to run for four pages,
|
|
was suddenly killed. When I asked <ent type='PERSON'>Lanny Jones</ent>, managing editor of
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent>, whether the fact that Time Inc. owns People had
|
|
anything to do with killing the story, he said no. Since his magazine
|
|
had obtained the story by illegal trespass, he said, running it would
|
|
have been unethical.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Think about it. <ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent> -- pleading ethics to explain why it
|
|
spiked a story the <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n people should hear!</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>When I took exception to <ent type='PERSON'>Jones</ent>' response, he asked me what I would have
|
|
done without violating the publication's guidelines. I said, at the
|
|
very least, I'd have <ent type='PERSON'>Mathison</ent> write a straight news article describing
|
|
exactly what happened -- how he gained access to the <ent type='GPE'>Bohemian Grove</ent>,
|
|
what he heard there, and why he was told to leave. <ent type='PERSON'>Jones</ent> said it was a
|
|
good idea and he'd think about it. That was August 6, 1991.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The <ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent>/<ent type='GPE'>Bohemian Grove</ent> story of self-censorship is a classic
|
|
example of the dangers <ent type='PERSON'>Ben</ent> Bagdikian warns about in Media Monopoly. If
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>People Magazine</ent> were not part of the Time Inc. media empire, it is
|
|
doubtful that the story would have been spiked.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Would It Make Any Difference?</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Finally, there is yet another question that is often asked about the
|
|
project. Would it really make any difference if the press were to
|
|
provide more coverage for the kinds of stories cited by Project
|
|
Censored?</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The answer is very simple: yes.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>First, there is the issue of a lack of public interest. Critics of
|
|
Project Censored say that the media give the public what it wants, i.e.
|
|
"junk food news," because the people are not interested in reading about
|
|
the issues raised by Project Censored. We counter that by saying,
|
|
Unfortunately, unaware of alternatives, the people will read or watch
|
|
what the mass media produce. However, we suggest that it is the media's
|
|
responsibility, as watchdogs of society, to explore, compile, and
|
|
present information people should know about in a way that will attract
|
|
their attention and be relevant to their everyday lives. And, when the
|
|
media do this, the people will read and respond to the issues raised.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>An example of what the press can do when it takes its responsibilities
|
|
seriously is provided by one of 1991's top 25 stories -- "Voodoo
|
|
Economics: The Untold Story" (#3). Authors <ent type='PERSON'>Donald Barlett</ent> and James
|
|
Steele, and their newspaper, <ent type='ORG'>The Philadelphia Inquirer</ent>, invested the
|
|
time, energy, and money to produce an extraordinarily informative series
|
|
of articles on a very complex and normally uninteresting subject -- the
|
|
economy. Within hours of the first installment of the series, the
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>Inquirer</ent> started to receive requests for reprints. Altogether the
|
|
newspaper distributed more than 225000 free reprints. One reader
|
|
wanted 535 copies -- one to distribute to each member of <ent type='ORG'>Congress</ent>.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>There is, indeed, a genuine desire on the part of people to know more
|
|
about issues that affect them. But then, the next question is, would it
|
|
make any difference if the people were better informed?</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Hunger in <ent type='LOC'>Africa</ent> was consistently nominated as a "censored" subject
|
|
during the early 1980s. When I would ask journalists why they did not
|
|
cover the tragedy unfolding there, they would say: " It is not news, "
|
|
or, "Everyone already knows about starving <ent type='LOC'>Africa</ent>ns," or "Nothing can be
|
|
done about it anyway.''</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Early in 1984, an <ent type='ORG'>ABC</ent>-TV News correspondent in <ent type='GPE'>Rome</ent> came upon
|
|
information that led him to believe that millions of lives were being
|
|
threatened by drought and famine in <ent type='LOC'>Africa</ent>. He asked the home office in
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>New York</ent> for permission to take his crew to <ent type='LOC'>Africa</ent> to get the story.
|
|
The answer was no.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>(There's an ironic twist to this story. I subsequently discovered who
|
|
it was at <ent type='ORG'>ABC</ent> that refused to let the network's TV crew go to <ent type='LOC'>Africa</ent> in
|
|
1984. It was <ent type='PERSON'>Rick Kaplan</ent>, who later became executive producer of Ted
|
|
Koppel's "Nightline." And, in mid-1986, it was the same <ent type='PERSON'>Rick Kaplan</ent>
|
|
who killed a two-part "Nightline" series on Project Censored which was
|
|
going to explore whether the news media ever overlook, undercover, or
|
|
censor important stories.)</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='ORG'>ABC</ent>-TV News was not the only, nor even the first, television network to
|
|
reject the tragic story of starving children in <ent type='GPE'>Ethiopia</ent>. In October,
|
|
1983, <ent type='PERSON'>David Kline</ent>, a free-lance journalist and news producer in San
|
|
Francisco, shot film on assignment for <ent type='ORG'>CBS</ent> showing emaciated adults and
|
|
some children near death. According to a <ent type='GPE'>Columbia</ent> Journalism Review
|
|
article, one of the children in Kline's footage was so thin that its
|
|
heart could be seen beating through the chest wall. Nonetheless, <ent type='ORG'>Kline</ent>
|
|
was told the footage was not strong enough. After being rejected by
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>CBS</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>Kline</ent> offered to do the story for <ent type='ORG'>NBC</ent> and <ent type='ORG'>PBS</ent> and they both turned
|
|
him down. Nor were the television networks the only media not
|
|
interested in a story about millions of people facing death. <ent type='ORG'>Kline</ent> also
|
|
offered the story to a number of magazines including Life, Playboy, The
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>New York</ent>er, Esquire, Harper's, and Mother <ent type='PERSON'>Jones</ent>, all of whom rejected
|
|
it. Only the Christian Science Monitor ran Kline's piece.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Later, as we all now know, a <ent type='ORG'>BBC</ent> television crew, traveling through
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>Ethiopia</ent>, captured the stark reality of children starving to death.
|
|
People throughout the world saw the coverage and responded.
|
|
Overnight, it sparked a world-wide reaction that reportedly saved the
|
|
lives of seven million <ent type='GPE'>Ethiopia</ent>ns.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Indeed, the media can make a difference.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The press has the power to stimulate people to clean up the environ-ment; to prevent nuclear proliferation; to force crooked politicians
|
|
out of office; to reduce poverty; to provide quality health care for
|
|
all people; to create a truly equitable society; and, as we have seen,
|
|
to literally save the lives of millions of human beings.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Project Censored Judges Of 1991</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>One of the most difficult challenges of Project Censored is to select
|
|
the top ten "censored" stories from among the 25 top nominations. This
|
|
responsibility falls to our distinguished national panel of judges who
|
|
volunteer their efforts. Perhaps one of the greatest tributes to the
|
|
project is that some of our judges, identified with asterisks below,
|
|
have participated in Project Censored every year since selecting the
|
|
first group of "best censored stories" of 1976. We are indebted to the
|
|
following judges who selected the top ten "censored" stories of 1991.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Dr. <ent type='PERSON'>Donna Allen</ent>, founding editor of Media Report to Women;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Ben</ent> Bagdikian,* Professor <ent type='PERSON'>Emeritus</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>Graduate School</ent> of Journalism, UC-Berkeley;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Richard Barnet</ent>, Senior Fellow, Institute for Policy Studies;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Noam Chomsky</ent>,* professor, <ent type='ORG'>Linguistics and Philosophy</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>MIT</ent>;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Dr. <ent type='PERSON'>George Gerbner</ent>, professor, <ent type='ORG'>Annenberg School</ent> of Communications,
|
|
University of <ent type='GPE'>Pennsylvania</ent>;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Nicholas Johnson</ent>, * professor, College of Law, University of Iowa;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Rhoda H. <ent type='PERSON'>Karpatkin</ent>, executive director, <ent type='ORG'>Consumers Union</ent>;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Charles L. <ent type='ORG'>Klotzer</ent>, editor and publisher, St. Louis Journalism
|
|
Review;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Judith Krug, director, <ent type='ORG'>Office for Intellectual Freedom</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n
|
|
Library Association;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Frances Moore Lappe</ent>, co-founder and co-director, <ent type='ORG'>Institute for the Arts</ent>
|
|
of Democracy;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>William Lutz</ent>, professor, <ent type='NORP'>English</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>Rutgers University</ent>, and editor of The
|
|
Quarterly Review of Doublespeak;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Robert C. <ent type='GPE'>Maynard</ent>, editor and publisher, <ent type='ORG'>Oakland Tribune</ent>;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Jack L. <ent type='PERSON'>Nelson</ent>, * professor, <ent type='ORG'>Graduate School</ent> of Education, Rutgers
|
|
University;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Tom Peters</ent>, nationally syndicated columnist on excellence;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Herbert 1. Schiller, Professor <ent type='PERSON'>Emeritus</ent> of Communication, UC-<ent type='GPE'>San Diego</ent>;</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Sheila <ent type='PERSON'>Rabb Weidenfeld</ent>,* president, D.C. Productions.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>The following pages provide a brief one page synopsis of each of the top
|
|
25 censored stories of 1991 and some additional background information
|
|
about the issue supplied by the author when available. If you are
|
|
interested in any of these issues, you are encouraged to go to the
|
|
original articles, or other sources, for more information. The synopsis
|
|
is merely a brief overview of the issue.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>From: <ent type='ORG'>New Liberation</ent> News Service <special>nlns@igc.apc.org</special></p>
|
|
|
|
<p>/* Written 11:38 am Mar 19, 1993 by newsdesk@igc.apc.org in igc:media.issues */
|
|
/* ---------- "Project Censored" ---------- */
|
|
From: News Desk <special>newsdesk</special>
|
|
Subject: Project Censored</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Events conspired against me but here at long last is the 1992 list
|
|
from Project Censored. Hopefully, it has not already been uploaded
|
|
by someone else...</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>Brian Wilson</ent>
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>NEWS FROM: PROJECT CENSORED
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University
|
|
Rohnert Park, CA 94928</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>For Immediate Release: # 106
|
|
Contact: <ent type='PERSON'>Mark Lowenthal</ent>
|
|
Project Censored: 707/664-2500</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>(EDITOR'S NOTE: A NATIONAL PANEL OF MEDIA EXPERTS ANNUALLY SELECTS
|
|
THE TOP TEN UNDER-REPORTED NEWS STORIES OF THE YEAR.)</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>NEWS MEDIA SELL-OUT TOPS CENSORED NEWS LIST</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>ROHNERT <ent type='GPE'>PARK</ent> -- The top censored story of 1992 revealed how
|
|
the nation's major news media traded their traditional adversarial
|
|
watchdog role for profits and deregulation during the Reagan/<ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> era
|
|
according to a national panel of media experts.
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Carl Jensen</ent>, professor of communication studies at <ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State
|
|
University, <ent type='GPE'>California</ent>, and founder/director of Project Censored, said the
|
|
media sell-out story, written by nationally acclaimed media critic <ent type='PERSON'>Ben</ent>
|
|
Bagdikian, also explained why a number of other critical issues were
|
|
overlooked, under-reported, or censored in 1992.
|
|
Project Censored, a national media research effort now in its
|
|
17th year, locates stories about significant issues that are not
|
|
widely publicized by <ent type='ORG'>the national</ent> news media. Following are the top
|
|
ten under-reported stories of 1992:
|
|
1.THE GREAT MEDIA SELL-OUT. In the past decade, the Reagan/<ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent>
|
|
administrations gave print and electronic media owners in <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>
|
|
"permission" to create giant, monopolistic media empires. In return, the
|
|
media looked the other way while the administrations committed high crimes
|
|
and misdemeanors and then lied about it.
|
|
2.CORPORATE CRIME DWARFS STREET CRIME. While the press
|
|
continues to alarm the public with stories of street crime and
|
|
violence, corporate crime and violence grows at an accelerated pace safely
|
|
away from the media's spotlight.
|
|
3.CENSORED ELECTION YEAR I<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>ES. While the candidates and the
|
|
media focused on alleged infidelities and family values, there were far more
|
|
important issues that were under-reported during the election year including:
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> and <ent type='GPE'>Iran</ent>-contra; Bush's Team 100; Homelessness; <ent type='PERSON'>Dan Quayle</ent>'s Council on
|
|
Competitiveness; The Death Rate of <ent type='NORP'>Iraqi</ent> Children After the <ent type='EVENT'>Gulf War</ent>; and
|
|
What Happened in <ent type='ORG'>Mena</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>Arkansas</ent>, while <ent type='PERSON'>Bill Clinton</ent> was Governor.
|
|
4.WORLD'S LEADING MERCHANT OF DEATH. With the end of the cold
|
|
war, the hope was that U.S. arms production and sales would be reduced and
|
|
replaced with non-military production, but this has not happened. Instead,
|
|
the U.S. has now become the world's unchallenged weapons producer and
|
|
supplier.
|
|
5.<ent type='GPE'>IRAQGATE</ent> AND THE WATERGATE LAW. While some of the disturbing
|
|
facts behind the <ent type='LOC'>Iraqgate</ent> scandal have started to appear in the press, the
|
|
mainstream media all but ignored that story, as well as the quiet demise of
|
|
the <ent type='EVENT'>Watergate</ent> Law, for more than a year.
|
|
6."WE ARE WINNING THE WAR ON DRUGS" WAS A LIE. When President
|
|
George <ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> told the <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n people "We are winning the war on drugs" in
|
|
1992, he was lying; in fact, <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>ns are in greater danger from drugs today
|
|
than ever before in our history.
|
|
7.TRASHING FEDERAL REGULATIONS FOR PROFIT. While polls show
|
|
the general public firmly opposes deregulation when the purity of air,
|
|
water, food, drugs, and other necessities are involved, President <ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent>
|
|
proposed a total 210-day moratorium on new federal regulations during 1992
|
|
and big business reciprocated with campaign contributions.
|
|
8.GOVERNMENT SECRECY MAKES A MOCKERY OF DEMOCRACY. America's
|
|
information control policy is out of control; in 1991, some 6500 U.S.
|
|
government employees classified 7107017 documents, an average of more than
|
|
19000 documents per day.
|
|
9.ADVERTISING PRE<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>RE CORRUPTS A FREE PRESS. The Center for
|
|
the Study of Commercialism invited 200 media outlets to a press conference to
|
|
reveal how advertisers suppress the news; not a single radio or television
|
|
station or network sent a reporter and only two newspapers bothered to
|
|
attend.
|
|
10.POST COLD WAR BLACK BUDGET IS PROSPERING. The end of the
|
|
cold war did not end the secretive cold war mentality of the <ent type='ORG'>Pentagon</ent>; today,
|
|
close to $100 million is being spent to fuel <ent type='ORG'>the national</ent> security machinery
|
|
of the <ent type='ORG'>Pentagon</ent>.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>15 OTHER "CENSORED" STORIES
|
|
Another 15 under-reported issues round out the list of the top 25
|
|
"censored" stories of 1992: <ent type='ORG'>Solar Power Eclipsed</ent> by Oil, Gas, and Nuclear
|
|
Interests; What Happened to the <ent type='ORG'>EPA</ent>?; The <ent type='PERSON'>Specter</ent> of Sterility; News Media
|
|
Lose the War with the <ent type='ORG'>Pentagon</ent>; Plutonium is Forever; America's Killing
|
|
Ground: Dumping on Native <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n Lands; Norplant: Birth Control or Social
|
|
Control?; The Censored News about <ent type='ORG'>Electric Automobiles</ent>; Poison in the
|
|
Pacific; Black Gold Conquistadors Invade <ent type='GPE'>Ecuador</ent>; How To Sell Pollution for
|
|
Profit; Clear-cutting the World's Rainforests; Censorship Through Bribery;
|
|
The No-Pest Shell Game; University of Arizona Desecrates Sacred Native
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n Site.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>PROJECT CENSORED JUDGES
|
|
The panel of judges who selected the top ten under-reported
|
|
news stories were Dr. <ent type='PERSON'>Donna Allen</ent>, founding editor of Media Report to
|
|
Women; <ent type='PERSON'>Richard Barnet</ent>, Senior Fellow, Institute for Policy Studies;
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Noam Chomsky</ent>, professor, <ent type='ORG'>Linguistics and Philosophy</ent>, Massachusetts
|
|
Institute of Technology; <ent type='PERSON'>Hugh Downs</ent>, host, ABC's "20/20;" Susan
|
|
Faludi, journalist/author; <ent type='PERSON'>George Gerbner</ent>, professor of communication
|
|
and Dean <ent type='PERSON'>Emeritus</ent>, University of <ent type='GPE'>Pennsylvania</ent>; <ent type='PERSON'>Nicholas Johnson</ent>,
|
|
professor, College of Law, University of Iowa;
|
|
Rhoda H. <ent type='PERSON'>Karpatkin</ent>, president, <ent type='ORG'>Consumers Union</ent>; Charles L.
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>Klotzer</ent>, editor and publisher, St. Louis Journalism Review; Judith
|
|
Krug, director, <ent type='ORG'>Office for Intellectual Freedom</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n Library
|
|
Association; <ent type='PERSON'>William Lutz</ent>, professor, <ent type='NORP'>English</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>Rutgers University</ent>, and
|
|
editor of <ent type='ORG'>The Quarterly Review</ent> of Doublespeak; Jack L. <ent type='PERSON'>Nelson</ent>,
|
|
professor, <ent type='ORG'>Graduate School</ent> of Education, <ent type='ORG'>Rutgers University</ent>; Herbert
|
|
I. Schiller, Scholar in Residence, The <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>n University; and Sheila
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Rabb Weidenfeld</ent>, president, D.C. Productions.
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>The SSU PROJECT CENSORED</ent> researchers, who reviewed and
|
|
evaluated more than 700 "censored" nominations from throughout the
|
|
country, were <ent type='PERSON'>Diane Albracht</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Beverly Alexander</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Peter Anderson</ent>, Judy
|
|
Bailey, <ent type='PERSON'>Jeannie Blake</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Serge Chasson</ent>, Amy S. Cohen, <ent type='PERSON'>Amy Doyle</ent>, G. John
|
|
Faiola, <ent type='PERSON'>Eric Fedel</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Kimberly Kaido</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Blake Kehler</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Kenneth Lang</ent>,
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Therese Lipsey</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Jennifer Makowsky</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Stephanie Niebel</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Nicole Novak</ent>,
|
|
Valerie Quigley, Kimberly S. Anderson, Damon S. <ent type='PERSON'>Van Hoesen</ent>, and Mark
|
|
Lowenthal, assistant director of Project Censored.
|
|
"CENSORED: The News That Didn't Make the News and Why," the
|
|
1993 Project Censored yearbook (ISBN 1-882680-00-6), published by
|
|
<ent type='ORG'>Shelburne Press</ent>, <ent type='ORG'>Chapel Hill</ent>, NC, will be available in bookstores
|
|
across the country in April or call 919/942-0220 for more information.
|
|
The book features the top 25 "censored" stories of 1992, a chronology
|
|
of censorship from 605 B.C. to 1993, and a "censored" resource guide
|
|
to alternative publications and groups. It includes an introduction by
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Hugh Downs</ent>, host of ABC's "20/20," and cartoons by <ent type='PERSON'>Tom Tomorrow</ent>, whose
|
|
series "This <ent type='ORG'>Modern World</ent>" is syndicated to over 60 newspapers.
|
|
"America's CENSORED Newsletter" (<ent type='ORG'>ISSN</ent>1061-4230), the first and only
|
|
publication to monitor news media censorship and self-censorship on a regular
|
|
basis in <ent type='GPE'>America</ent>, is published by <ent type='ORG'>Censored Publications</ent>. Based on Project
|
|
Censored, the Newsletter reports monthly on the issues the mainstream media
|
|
ignore, overlook, or censor. For an annual subscription, send $30 to
|
|
CENSORED Newsletter, PO Box 310, Cotati, CA 94931.
|
|
To receive a free pamphlet listing the top 25 stories, please send a
|
|
self-addressed, stamped envelope to PROJECT CENSORED, <ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State
|
|
University, Rohnert Park, CA 94928.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>--<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>--</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>(EDITOR'S NOTE: SIDEBAR STORY #1 FOLLOWS)</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>INVESTIGATIVE <ent type='GPE'>JOURNALISTS</ent> AND MEDIA
|
|
CITED FOR EXPOSING "CENSORED" STORIES</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Following are the investigative journalists and media cited by Project
|
|
Censored for exposing the top ten issues overlooked or under-reported by the
|
|
national news media in 1992:</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>1.THE GREAT MEDIA SELL-OUT. MOTHER JONES, May/June 1992,
|
|
"Journalism of Joy," by <ent type='PERSON'>Ben</ent> Bagdikian.
|
|
2.CORPORATE CRIME. <ent type='ORG'>MULTINATIONAL MONITOR</ent>, December 1991,
|
|
"Corporate Crime & Violence in Review," by <ent type='PERSON'>Russell Mokhiber</ent>.
|
|
3.CENSORED ELECTION YEAR I<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>ES. COMMON CAUSE MAGAZINE,
|
|
April/May/June 1992, "George Bush's Ruling Class;" <ent type='GPE'>WASHINGTON</ent> POST, 1/9/92,
|
|
"A Profound Silence on Homelessness," by Mary McGrory; THE PROGRESSIVE, May
|
|
1992, "<ent type='PERSON'>Deregulatory Creep</ent>," by Arthur E. <ent type='ORG'>Rowse</ent>; THIS WORLD, <ent type='GPE'>San Francisco</ent>
|
|
Examiner, 10/11/92, "46900 Unspectacular Deaths," by <ent type='PERSON'>Mike Royko</ent>;
|
|
UNCLASSIFIED, February/March 1992, "The <ent type='ORG'>Mena</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>Arkansas</ent>, Story."
|
|
4.WORLD'S LEADING MERCHANT OF DEATH. <ent type='ORG'>WORLD PRESS REVIEW</ent>,
|
|
September 1992, "The World's Top Arms Merchant," by <ent type='PERSON'>Frederick Clairmonte</ent>; THE
|
|
HUMAN QUEST, July/August 1992, "War 'Dividends' -- Military Spending Out of
|
|
Balance With Needy," by Tristram Coffin.
|
|
5. <ent type='GPE'>IRAQGATE</ent> & THE WATERGATE LAW. COVERT/ACTION INFORMATION
|
|
BULLETIN, Fall 1992, "<ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> Administration Uses <ent type='ORG'>CIA</ent> to Stonewall <ent type='LOC'>Iraqgate</ent>
|
|
Investigation," by <ent type='PERSON'>Jack Calhoun</ent>; WAR AND PEACE DIGEST (NY),
|
|
August 1992, "BNL-<ent type='LOC'>Iraqgate</ent> Scandal;" THE PAPER of <ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> County (CA),
|
|
10/22/92, "Is <ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> a Felon?," by Stephen P. Pizzo; THE NEW YORK TIMES,
|
|
10/20/92, "The <ent type='PERSON'>Patsy</ent> Prosecutor," by <ent type='PERSON'>William Safire</ent>.
|
|
6.WINNING THE WAR ON DRUGS. IN THESE TIMES, 5/20/92, "Drug
|
|
Deaths Rise As the War Continues," by <ent type='PERSON'>Mike Males</ent>; EXTRA!, September 1992,
|
|
"Don't Forget the <ent type='ORG'>Hype</ent>: Media, Drugs and Public Opinion," by <ent type='PERSON'>Micah Fink</ent>.
|
|
7.TRASHING FEDERAL REGULATIONS FOR PROFIT. THE NATION,
|
|
3/23/92, "Bush's <ent type='ORG'>Regulatory Chill</ent>: Immoral, Illegal, and Deadly," by
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Christine Triano</ent> and <ent type='PERSON'>Nancy Watzman</ent>; THE PROGRESSIVE, May 1992, "Deregulatory
|
|
Creep," by Arthur E. <ent type='ORG'>Rowse</ent>.
|
|
8.GOVERNMENT SECRECY. I<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>ES IN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, Summer
|
|
1992, "The Perils of Government Secrecy," by <ent type='PERSON'>Steven Aftergood</ent>.
|
|
9.HOW ADVERTISING PRE<ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent>RE CAN CORRUPT A FREE PRESS. THE
|
|
CENTER FOR THE STUDY OF COMMER<ent type='ORG'>CIA</ent>LISM, 1992, "Dictating Content: How
|
|
Advertising Pressure Can Corrupt a Free Press," by Ronald K. L. Collins.
|
|
10.PENTAGON'S POST COLD WAR BLACK BUDGET. MOTHER JONES,
|
|
March/April 1992, "The Pentagon's Secret Stash," by <ent type='PERSON'>Tim Weiner</ent>.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>-- <ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent> --</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>(EDITOR'S NOTE: SIDEBAR STORY #2 FOLLOWS)</p>
|
|
|
|
<p><ent type='PERSON'>DAN QUAYLE</ent> IS JUNK FOOD NEWS OF 1992</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>ROHNERT <ent type='GPE'>PARK</ent> -- Vice President-reject <ent type='PERSON'>Dan Quayle</ent> set a new
|
|
record in the annual <ent type='ORG'>Junk Food</ent> News competition by being cited in two
|
|
of the top three over-covered unimportant news stories of 1992
|
|
according to Dr. <ent type='PERSON'>Carl Jensen</ent>, professor of Communication Studies at
|
|
<ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University.
|
|
The annual list of news stories that receive more media coverage than
|
|
they deserve is based on a national survey by <ent type='PERSON'>Jensen</ent> of members of the
|
|
Organization of News Ombudsmen.
|
|
The top ten <ent type='ORG'>Junk Food</ent> News stories of 1992 were:
|
|
1. <ent type='PERSON'>Dan Quayle</ent> Misspells Potato -- the Vice President's final tutoring
|
|
assignment
|
|
2. Madonna's Best Selling "Sex" -- from pop queen to porn queen
|
|
3. <ent type='PERSON'>Murphy</ent> Brown/<ent type='PERSON'>Dan Quayle</ent> -- Dan's "family values" get low ratings
|
|
4. <ent type='PERSON'>Johnny Carson</ent>: The Final Days -- Where's Johnny?
|
|
5. Royal Scandal: Fergie & <ent type='PERSON'>Diana</ent> -- the naughty wives of Windsor
|
|
6. Woody Allen vs <ent type='PERSON'>Mia Farrow</ent> -- we liked him better when he was funny
|
|
7. <ent type='PERSON'>Geniffer Flowers</ent> -- no shrinking violet
|
|
8. The Barbara/Hillary Cookie Bake-off -- let the chips fall where
|
|
they may
|
|
9. The Elvis Stamp Election -- the youngest candidate won this
|
|
election too
|
|
10. U.S. Olympic Dream Team -- first single sport <ent type='EVENT'>Olympics</ent> in history</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>Other nominations cited by the news ombudsmen included <ent type='PERSON'>Bush</ent> Tosses
|
|
Cookies in <ent type='GPE'>Japan</ent>, the Jay Leno/Arsenio Hall Late Night War, Clinton's <ent type='GPE'>Vietnam</ent>
|
|
Record, <ent type='PERSON'>Jerry Brown</ent>'s 800 Number, Batman Returns/Superman Dies, Polls-Polls-Polls, and <ent type='PERSON'>Sinead</ent> O'Connor Rips the Pope.
|
|
Ombudsmen comments on the <ent type='ORG'>Junk Food</ent> News stories included:
|
|
"Too many wire editors feel pressured to duplicate in the next day's
|
|
paper whatever was on last night's 'Entertainment Tonight' or any number of
|
|
other pseudo-news programs." -- <ent type='PERSON'>William Flynn</ent>, <ent type='PERSON'>Patriot Ledger</ent>, Quincy, MA.
|
|
"The media helped <ent type='PERSON'>Madonna</ent> sell her book ... but even the media
|
|
couldn't rescue Batman." -- <ent type='PERSON'>Gina Lubrano</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>San Diego</ent> Union-Tribune.
|
|
"Many of the junk food stories this year centered on the presidential
|
|
campaign ... but if the candidates talk about it, and they do, how can you
|
|
ignore it?" -- <ent type='PERSON'>Frank Ritter</ent>, The <ent type='NORP'>Tennessean</ent>, <ent type='GPE'>Nashville</ent>, TN.
|
|
"Truly significant news is often oppressively dull or mentally
|
|
taxing; the media welcome stories like these to leaven the loaf." --
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Kerry</ent> W. <ent type='PERSON'>Sipe</ent>, The Virginian-Pilot, <ent type='GPE'>Norfolk</ent>, VA.
|
|
Noting the extensive coverage given <ent type='ORG'>British Royalty</ent> in the
|
|
United States media, <ent type='PERSON'>Takeshi Maezawa</ent>, columnist for The Daily Yomiuri
|
|
in <ent type='GPE'>Tokyo</ent>, points out that the press in <ent type='GPE'>Japan</ent> mutually agreed not to
|
|
cover the <ent type='GPE'>Japan</ent>ese Prince's search for a bride.
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Jensen</ent>, who also is director of Project Censored which cites
|
|
the most important news stories overlooked by the press each year,
|
|
notes that the coverage given <ent type='PERSON'>Dan Quayle</ent>'s spelling and fight with
|
|
<ent type='PERSON'>Murphy</ent> Brown filled media time and space that could have been devoted
|
|
to more relevant political issues during an election year.
|
|
For more information about <ent type='ORG'>Junk Food</ent> News stories, contact
|
|
Project Censored at <ent type='GPE'>Sonoma</ent> State University, Rohnert Park, <ent type='GPE'>California</ent>
|
|
94928, 707/664-2500.</p>
|
|
|
|
<p>-- <ent type='ORG'>SSU</ent> --
|
|
|
|
</p></xml> |