mirror of
https://github.com/nhammer514/textfiles-politics.git
synced 2024-12-25 07:19:31 -05:00
651 lines
40 KiB
Plaintext
651 lines
40 KiB
Plaintext
|
||
From TIME Magazine, May 6, 1991:
|
||
|
||
THE THRIVING CULT OF GREED AND POWER
|
||
|
||
Ruined lives. Lost fortunes. Federal crimes.
|
||
Scientology poses as a religion but is really a ruthless
|
||
global scam - and aiming for the mainstream.
|
||
|
||
By Richard Behar
|
||
|
||
By all appearances, Noah Lottick of Kingston, Pa. had been a
|
||
normal, happy 24-year-old who was looking for his place in the world.
|
||
On the day last June when his parents drove to New York to claim his
|
||
body, they were nearly catatonic with grief. The young
|
||
Russian-studies scholar had jumped from a 10th-floor window of the
|
||
Milford Plaza Hotel and bounced off the hood of a stretch limosine.
|
||
When the police arrived, his fingers were still clutching $171 in
|
||
cash, virtually the only money he hadn't yet turned over to the Church
|
||
of Scientology, the self-help "philosophy" group he had discovered
|
||
just seven months earlier.
|
||
His death inspired his father Edward, a physician, to start his
|
||
own investigation of the church. "We thought Scientology was
|
||
something like Dale Carnegie," Lottick says. "I now believe it's a
|
||
school for psychopaths. Their so-called therapies are manipulations.
|
||
They take the best and brightest people and destroy them." The
|
||
Lotticks want to sue the church for contributing to their son's death,
|
||
but the prospect has them frightened. For nearly 40 years, the big
|
||
business of Scientology has shielded itself exquisitely behind the
|
||
First Amendment as well as a battery of high-priced criminal lawyers
|
||
and shady private detectives.
|
||
The Church of Scientology, started by science-fiction writer L.
|
||
Ron Hubbard to "clear" people of unhappiness, portrays itself as a
|
||
religion. In reality the church is a hugely profitable global racket
|
||
that survives by intimidating members and critics in a Mafia-like
|
||
manner. At times during the past decade, prosecutions against
|
||
Scientology seemed to be curbing its menace. Eleven top
|
||
Scientologists, including Hubbard's wife, were sent to prison in the
|
||
early 1980's for infiltrating, burglarizing, and wiretapping more than
|
||
100 private and government agencies in attempts to block their
|
||
investigations. In recent years hundreds of longtime Scientology
|
||
adherents - many charging that they were mentally or physically abused
|
||
- have quit the church and criticized it at their own risk. Some have
|
||
sued the church and won; others have settled for amounts in excess of
|
||
$500,000. In various cases judges have labeled the church
|
||
"schizophrenic and paranoid" and "corrupt, sinister and dangerous."
|
||
Yet the outrage and litigation have failed to squelch
|
||
Scientology. The group, which boasts 700 centers in 65 countries,
|
||
threatens to become more insidious and persuasive than ever.
|
||
Scientology is trying to go mainstream, a strategy that has sparked a
|
||
renewed law-enforcement campaign against the church. Many of the
|
||
group's followers have been accused of committing financial scams,
|
||
while the church is busy attracting the unwary through a wide array of
|
||
front groups in such businesses as publishing, consulting, health care
|
||
and even remedial education.
|
||
In Hollywood, Scientology has assembled a star-studded roster of
|
||
followers by aggressively recruiting and regally pampering them at the
|
||
church's "Celebrity Centers," a chain of clubhouses that offers
|
||
expensive counseling and career guidance. Adherents include screen
|
||
idols Tom Cruise and John Travolta, actresses Kirstie Alley, Mimi
|
||
Rogers and Anne Archer, Palm Springs mayor and performer Sonny Bono,
|
||
jazzman Chick Corea and even Nancy Cartwright, the voice of cartoon
|
||
star Bart Simpson. Rank-and-file members, however, are dealt a less
|
||
glamorous Scientology.
|
||
According to the Cult Awareness Network, whose 23 chapters
|
||
monitor more than 200 "mind control" cults, no group prompts more
|
||
telephone please for help than does Scientology. Says Cynthia Kisser,
|
||
the network's Chicago-based executive director: "Scientology is quite
|
||
likely most ruthless, the most classically terroristic, the most
|
||
litigous and the most lucrative cult the country has ever seen. No
|
||
cult extracts more money from its members." Agrees Vicki Aznaran, who
|
||
was one of Scientology's six key leaders until she bolted from the
|
||
church in 1987: "This is a criminal organization, day in and day out.
|
||
It makes Jim and Tammy [Bakker] look like kindergarten."
|
||
To explore Scientology's reach, TIME conducted more than 150
|
||
interviews and reviewed hundreds of court records and internal
|
||
Scientology documents. Church officials refused to be interviewed.
|
||
The investigation paints a picture of a depraved yet thriving
|
||
enterprise. Most cults fail to outlast their founder, but Scientology
|
||
has prospered since Hubbard's death in 1986. In a court filing, one
|
||
of the cult's many entities - the Church of Spiritual Technology -
|
||
listed $503 million in income just for 1987. High-level defectors say
|
||
the parent organization has squirreled away an estimated $400 million
|
||
in bank accounts in Leichtenstein, Switzerland and Cyprus.
|
||
Scientology probably has about 50,000 members, far fewer than the 8
|
||
million the group claims. But in one sense, that inflated figure
|
||
rings true: Millions of people have been affected in one way or
|
||
another by Hubbard's bizarre creation.
|
||
Scientology is now run by David Miscavige, 31, a high school
|
||
dropout and second-generation church member. Defectors describe him
|
||
as cunning, ruthless and so paranoid about perceived enemies that he
|
||
kept plastic wrap over his glass of water. His obsession is to attain
|
||
credibility for Scientology in the 1990s. Among other tactics, the
|
||
group:
|
||
* Retains public relations powerhouse Hill and Knowlton to help
|
||
shed the church's fringe-group image.
|
||
* Joined such household names as Sony and Pepsi as a main sponsor
|
||
of Ted Turner's Goodwill Games.
|
||
* Buys massive quantities of its own books from retail stores to
|
||
propel the titles onto best-seller lists.
|
||
* Runs full-page ads in such publications as NEWSWEEK and
|
||
BUSINESS WEEK that call Scientology a "philosophy," along with a
|
||
plethora a TV ads touting the group's books.
|
||
* Recruits wealthy and respectable professionals through a web of
|
||
consulting groups that typically hide their ties to Scientology.
|
||
The founder of this enterprise was part storyteller, part
|
||
flimflam man. Born in Nebraska in 1911, Hubbard was a moderately
|
||
successful writer of pulp science fiction. Years later, church
|
||
brochures described him falsely as an "extensively decorated" World
|
||
War II hero who was crippled and blinded in action, twice pronounced
|
||
dead and miraculously cured through Scientology. Hubbard's
|
||
"doctorate" from "Sequoia University" was a fake mail-order degree.
|
||
In a 1984 case in which the church sued a Hubbard biographical
|
||
researcher, a California judge concluded that its founder was a
|
||
"pathological liar."
|
||
Hubbard wrote one of Scientology's sacred texts, "Dianetics: The
|
||
Modern Science of Mental Health," in 1950. In it he introduced a
|
||
crude psychotherapeutic technique he called "auditing." He also
|
||
created a simplified lie detector (called an "E-meter") that was
|
||
designed to measure electrical charges in the skin while subjects
|
||
discussed intimate details of their past. Hubbard argued that
|
||
unhappiness sprang from mental aberrations (or "engrams") caused by
|
||
early traumas. Counseling sessions with the E-meter, he claimed,
|
||
could knock out the engrams, cure blindness and even improve a
|
||
person's intelligence and appearance.
|
||
Hubbard kept adding steps, each more costly, for his followers to
|
||
climb. In the 1960s the guru decreed that humans are made of clusters
|
||
of spirits (or "thetans") who were banished to earth some 75 million
|
||
years ago by a cruel galactic ruler named Xenu. Naturally, those
|
||
thetans had to be audited.
|
||
An Internal Revenue Service ruling in 1967 stripped Scientology's
|
||
mother church of its tax-exempt status. A federal court ruled in 1971
|
||
that Hubbard's medical claims were bogus and that E-meter auditing
|
||
could no longer be called a scientific treatment. Hubbard responded
|
||
by going fully religious, seeking First Amendment protection for
|
||
Scientology's strange rites. His counselors started sporting clerical
|
||
collars. Chapels were built, franchises became "missions" fees became
|
||
"fixed donations," and Hubbard's comic-book cosmology became "sacred
|
||
scriptures."
|
||
During the early 1970's, the IRS conducted its own auditing
|
||
session and proved that Hubbard was skimming millions of dollars from
|
||
the church, laundering the money through dummy corporations in Panama
|
||
and stashing it in Swiss bank accounts. Moreover, church members
|
||
stole IRS documents, filed false tax returns and harassed the agency's
|
||
employees. By late 1985, with high-level defectors accusing Hubbard
|
||
of having stolen as much as $200 million from the church, the IRS was
|
||
seeking an indictment of Hubbard for tax fraud. Scientology members
|
||
"worked day and night" shredding documents the IRS sought, according
|
||
to defector Aznaran, who took part in the scheme. Hubbard, who had
|
||
been in hiding for five years, died before the criminal case could be
|
||
prosecuted.
|
||
Today the church invents costly new services with all the zeal of
|
||
its founder. Scientology doctrine warns that even adherents who are
|
||
"cleared" of engrams face grave spiritual dangers unless they are
|
||
pushed to higher and more expensive sessions that cost as much as
|
||
$1,000 an hour, or $12,500 for a 12 1/2-hour "intensive."
|
||
Psychiatrists say these sessions can produce a drugged-like,
|
||
mind-controlled euphoria that keeps customers coming back for more.
|
||
To pay their fees, newcomers can earn commissions by recruiting new
|
||
members, become auditors themselves (Miscavige did so at age 12), or
|
||
join the church staff and receive free counseling in exchange for what
|
||
their written contracts describe as a "billion years" of labor. "Make
|
||
sure that lots of bodies move through the shop," implored Hubbard in
|
||
one of his bulletins to officials. "Make money. Make more money.
|
||
Make others produce so as to make money...however you get them in or
|
||
why, just do it."
|
||
Harriet Baker learned the hard way about Scientology's business
|
||
of selling religion. When Baker, 73, lost her husband to cancer, a
|
||
Scientologist turned up at her Los Angeles home peddling a $1,300
|
||
auditing package to cure her grief. Some $15,000 later, the
|
||
Scientologists discovered that her home was debt free. They arranged
|
||
a $45,000 mortgage, which they pressured her to tape for more auditing
|
||
until Baker's children helped their mother snap out of her daze. Last
|
||
June, Baker demanded a $27,000 refund for unused services, prompting
|
||
two cult members to show up at her door unannounced with an E-meter to
|
||
interrogate her. Baker never got the money and, financially strapped,
|
||
was forced to sell her house in September.
|
||
Before Noah Lattick killed himself, he had paid more than $5,000
|
||
for church counseling. His behavior had also become strange. He once
|
||
remarked to his parents that his Scientology mentors could actually
|
||
read minds. When his father suffered a major heart attack, Noah
|
||
insisted that it was purely psychosomatic. Five days before he
|
||
jumped, Noah burst into his parents' home and demanded to know why
|
||
they were spreading "false rumors" about him - a delusion that finally
|
||
prompted his father to call a psychiatrist.
|
||
It was too late. "From Noah's friends at Dianetics" read the
|
||
card that accompanied a bouquet of flowers at Lottick's funeral. Yet
|
||
no Scientology staff member bothered to show up. A week earlier,
|
||
local church officials had given Lottick's parents a red-carpet tour
|
||
of their center. A cult leader told Noah's parents that their son had
|
||
been at the church just hours before he disappeared - but the church
|
||
denied this story as soon as the body was identified. True to form,
|
||
the cult even haggled with the Lotticks over $3,000 their son had paid
|
||
for services he never used, insisting that Noah had intended it as a
|
||
"donation."
|
||
The church has invented hundreds of goods and services for which
|
||
members are urged to give "donations." Are you having trouble "moving
|
||
swiftly up the Bridge" - that is advancing up the stepladder of
|
||
enlightenment? Then you can have your case reviewed for a mere $1,250
|
||
"donation." Want to know "why a thetan hangs on to the physical
|
||
universe?" Try 52 of Hubbard's tape-recorded speeches from 1952,
|
||
titled "Ron's Philadelphia Doctorate Course Lectures," for $2,525.
|
||
Next: Nine other series of the same sort. For the collector,
|
||
gold-and-leather-bound editions of 22 of Hubbard's books (and
|
||
bookends) on subjects ranging from Scientology ethics to radiation can
|
||
be had for just $1,900.
|
||
To gain influence and lure richer, more sophisticated followers,
|
||
Scientology has lately resorted to a wide array of front groups and
|
||
financial scams. Among them:
|
||
|
||
CONSULTING. Sterling Management Systems, formed in 1983, has been
|
||
ranked in recent years by INC. magazine as one of America's
|
||
fastest-growing private companies (estimated 1988 revenues: $20
|
||
million). Sterling regularly mails a free newsletter to more than
|
||
300,000 health-care professionals, mostly dentists, promising to
|
||
increase their incomes dramatically. The firm offers seminars and
|
||
courses that typically cost $10,000. But Sterling's true aim is to
|
||
hook customers for Scientology. "The church has a rotten product, so
|
||
they package it as something else," says Peter Georgiades, a
|
||
Pittsburgh attorney who represents Sterling victims. "It's a kind of
|
||
bait and switch." Sterling's founder, dentist Gregory Hughes, is now
|
||
under investigation by California's Board of Dental Examiners for
|
||
incompetence. Nine lawsuits are pending against him for malpractice
|
||
(seven others have been settled), mostly for orthodontic work on
|
||
children.
|
||
Many dentists who have unwittingly been drawn into the cult are
|
||
filing or threatening lawsuits as well. Dentist Robert Geary of
|
||
Medina, Ohio, who entered a Sterling seminar in 1988, endured "the
|
||
most extreme high-pressure sales tactics I have ever faced." Sterling
|
||
officials told Geary, 45, that their firm was not linked to
|
||
Scientology, he says. But Geary claims they eventually convinced him
|
||
that he and his wife had personal problems that required auditing.
|
||
Over five months, the Gearys say, they spent $130,000 for services,
|
||
plus $50,000 for "gold-embossed, investment-grade" books signed by
|
||
Hubbard. Geary contends that Scientologists not only called his bank
|
||
to increase his credit-card limit but also forged his signature on a
|
||
$20,000 loan application. "It was insane," he recalls. "I couldn't
|
||
even get an accounting from them of what I was paying for." At one
|
||
point, the Gearys claim, Scientologists held Dorothy hostage for two
|
||
weeks in a mountain cabin, after which she was hospitalized for a
|
||
nervous breakdown.
|
||
Last October, Sterling broke some bad news to another dentist,
|
||
Glover Rowe of Gadsden, Ala., and his wife Dee. Tests showed that
|
||
unless they signed up for auditing, Glover's practice would fail, and
|
||
Dee would someday abuse their child. The next month the Rowes flew to
|
||
Glendale, Calif., where they shuttled daily from a local hotel to a
|
||
Dianetics center. "We thought they were brilliant people because they
|
||
seemed to know so much about us," recalls Dee. "Then we realize our
|
||
hotel room must have been bugged." After bolting from the center,
|
||
$23,000 poorer, the Rowes say, they were chased repeatedly by
|
||
Scientologists on foot and in cars. Dentists aren't the only ones at
|
||
risk. Scientology also makes pitches to chiropractors, podiatrists
|
||
and veterinarians.
|
||
|
||
PUBLIC INFLUENCE. One front, the Way to Happiness Foundation, has
|
||
distributed to children in thousands of the nation's public schools
|
||
more than 3.5 million copies of a booklet Hubbard wrote on morality.
|
||
The church calls the scheme "the largest dissemination project in
|
||
Scientology history." Applied Scholastics is the name of still
|
||
another front, which is attempting to install a Hubbard tutorial
|
||
program in public schools, primarily those populated by minorities.
|
||
The group also plans a 1,000-acre campus, where it will train
|
||
educators to teach various Hubbard methods. The disingenuously named
|
||
Citizens Commission on Human Rights is a Scientology group at war with
|
||
psychiatry, its primary competitor. The commission typically issues
|
||
reports aimed at discrediting particular psychiatrics and the field in
|
||
general. The CCHR is also behind an all-out war against Eli Lilly,
|
||
the maker of Prozac, the nation's top-selling antidepression drug.
|
||
Despite scant evidence, the group's members - who are calling
|
||
themselves "psychbusters" - claim that Prozac drives people to murder
|
||
or suicide. Through mass mailings, appearances on talk shows and
|
||
heavy lobbying, CCHR has hurt drug sales and helped spark dozens of
|
||
lawsuits against Lilly.
|
||
Another Scientology-linked group, the Concerned Businessmen's
|
||
Association of America, holds antidrug contests and awards $5,000
|
||
grants to schools as a way to recruit students and curry favor with
|
||
education officials. West Virginia Senator John D. Rockefeller IV
|
||
unwittingly commended the CBAA in 1987 on the Senate floor. Last
|
||
August author Alex Haley was the keynote speaker at its annual awards
|
||
banquet in Los Angeles. Says Haley: "I didn't know much about that
|
||
group going in. I'm a Methodist." Ignorance about Scientology can be
|
||
embarassing: two months ago, Illinois Governor Jim Edgar, noting that
|
||
Scientology's founder "has solved the aberrations of the human mind,"
|
||
proclaimed March 13 "L. Ron Hubbard Day." He rescinded the
|
||
proclamation in late March, once he learned who Hubbard really was.
|
||
|
||
HEALTH CARE. HealthMed, a chain of clinics run by Scientologists,
|
||
promotes a grueling and excessive system of saunas, exercise and
|
||
vitamins designed by Hubbard to purify the body. Experts denounce the
|
||
regime as quackery and potentially harmful, yet HealthMed solicits
|
||
unions and public agencies for contracts. The chain is plugged
|
||
heavily in a new book, "Diet for a Poisoned Planet," by journalist
|
||
David Steinman, who concludes that scores of common foods (among them:
|
||
peanuts, bluefish, peaches and cottage cheese) are dangerous.
|
||
Former Surgeon General C. Everett Koop labeled the book "Trash,"
|
||
and the Food and Drug Administration issued a paper in October that
|
||
claims Steinman distorts his facts. "HealthMed is a gateway to
|
||
Scientology, and Steinman's book i a sorting mechanism," says
|
||
physician William Jarvis, who is head of the National Council Against
|
||
Health Fraud. Steinman, who describes Hubbard favorably as a
|
||
"researcher," denies any ties to the church and contends, "HealthMed
|
||
has no affiliation that I know of with Scientology."
|
||
|
||
DRUG TREATMENT. Hubbard's purification treatments are the mainstay of
|
||
Narconon, a Scientology-run chain of 33 alcohol and drug
|
||
rehabilitation centers - some in prisons under the name "Criminon" -
|
||
in 12 countries. Narconon, a classic vehicle for drawing addicts into
|
||
the cult, now plans to open what it calls the world's largest
|
||
treatment center, a 1,400-bed facility on an Indian reservation near
|
||
Newkirk, Okla. (Pop. 2,400). At a 1989 ceremony in Newkirk, the
|
||
Association for Better Living and Education presented Narconon with a
|
||
check for $200,000 and a study praising its work. The association
|
||
turned out to be part of Scientology itself. Today the town is
|
||
battling to keep out the cult, which has fought back through such
|
||
tactics as sending private detectives to snoop on the mayor and the
|
||
local newspaper publisher.
|
||
|
||
FINANCIAL SCAMS. Three Florida Scientologists, including Robert
|
||
Bernstein, a big contributor to the church's international "war
|
||
chest," pleaded guilty in March to using their rare-coin dealership as
|
||
a money laundry. Other notorious activities by Scientologists include
|
||
making the shady Vancouver stock exchange even shadier (see
|
||
accompanying article) and plotting to plant operatives in the World
|
||
Bank, International Monetary Fund and Export-Import Bank of the U.S.
|
||
The alleged purpose of this scheme: to gain inside information on
|
||
which countries are going to be denied credit so that
|
||
Scientology-linked traders can make illicit profits by taking "short"
|
||
positions in those countries' currencies.
|
||
In the stock market the practice of "shorting" involved borrowing
|
||
shares of publicly traded companies in the hope that the price will go
|
||
down before the stocks must be brought on the market and returned to
|
||
the lender. The Feshbach brothers of Palo Alto, Calif. - Kurt, Joseph
|
||
and Matthew - have become the leading short sellers in the U.S., with
|
||
more than $500 million under management. The Feshbachs command a
|
||
staff of about 60 employees and claim to have earned better returns
|
||
than the Dow Jones industrial average for most of the 1980's. And,
|
||
they say, they owe it all to the teachings of Scientology, whose "war
|
||
chest" has received more than $1 million from the family.
|
||
The Feshbachs also embrace the church's tactics; the brothers are
|
||
the terrors of the stock exchanges. In congressional hearings in
|
||
1989, the heads of several companies claimed that Feshbach operatives
|
||
have spread false information to to government agencies and posed in
|
||
various guises - such as a Securities and Exchange Commission official
|
||
- in an effort to discredit the companies and drive the stocks down.
|
||
Michael Russell, who ran a chain of business journals, testified that
|
||
a Feshbach employee called his bankers and interfered with his loans.
|
||
Sometimes the Feshbachs send private detectives to dig up dirt on
|
||
firms, which is then shared with business reporters, brokers and fund
|
||
managers.
|
||
The Feshbachs, who wear jackets bearing the slogan "stock
|
||
busters," insist they run a clean shop. but as part of a possible
|
||
probe into insider stock trading, federal officials are reportedly
|
||
investigating whether the Feshbachs received confidential information
|
||
from FDA employees. The brothers seem aligned with Scientology's war
|
||
on psychiatry and medicine: many of their targets are health and
|
||
biotechnology firms. "Legitimate short selling performs a public
|
||
service by deflating hyped stocks," says Robert Flaherty, the editor
|
||
of EQUITIES magazine and a harsh critic of the brothers. "But the
|
||
Feshbachs have damaged scores of good start-ups."
|
||
Occasionally a Scientologist's business antics land him in jail.
|
||
Last August a former devotee named Steven Fishman began serving a
|
||
five-year prison term in Florida. His crime: stealing blank
|
||
stock-confirmation slips from his employer, a major brokerage house,
|
||
to use as proof that he owned stock entitling him to join dozens of
|
||
successful class-action lawsuits. Fishman made roughly $1 million
|
||
this way from 1983 to 1986 and spent as much as 30% of the loot on
|
||
Scientology books and tapes.
|
||
Scientology denies any tie to the Fishman scam, a claim strongly
|
||
disputed by both Fishman and his longtime psychiatrist, Uwe Geertz, a
|
||
prominent Florida hypnotist. Both men claim that when arrested,
|
||
Fishman was ordered by the church to kill Geertz and then do an "EOC,"
|
||
or end of cycle, which is church jargon for suicide.
|
||
|
||
BOOK PUBLISHING. Scientology mischiefmaking has even moved to the
|
||
book industry. Since 1985 at least a dozen Hubbard books, printed by
|
||
a church company, have made best-seller lists. They range from a
|
||
5,000-page sci-fi decalogy ("Black Genesis," "The Enemy Within," "An
|
||
Alien Affair") to the 40-year-old "Dianetics." In 1988 the trade
|
||
publication PUBLISHERS WEEKLY awarded the dead author a plaque
|
||
commemorating the appearance of "Dianetics" on its best-seller list
|
||
for 100 consecutive weeks.
|
||
Critics pan most of Hubbard's books as unreadable, while
|
||
defectors claim that church insiders are sometimes the real authors.
|
||
Even so, Scientology has sent out armies of its followers to buy the
|
||
group's books at such major chains as B. Dalton's and Waldenbooks to
|
||
sustain the illusion of a best-selling author. A former Dalton's
|
||
manager says some books arrived in his store with the chain's price
|
||
stickers already on them, suggesting that copies are being recycled.
|
||
Scientology claims that sales of Hubbard's books now top 90 million
|
||
worldwide. The sceme, set up to gain converts and credibility, is
|
||
coupled with a radio and TV advertising campaign virtually
|
||
unparalleled in the book industry.
|
||
Scientology devotes vast resources to squelching its critics.
|
||
Since 1986 Hubbard and his church have been the subject of four
|
||
unfriendly books, all published by small yet courageous publishers.
|
||
In each case, the writers have been badgered and heavily sued. One of
|
||
Hubbard's policies was that all perceived enemies are "fair game" and
|
||
subject to being "tricked, lied to or destroyed." those who criticize
|
||
the church - journalists, doctors, lawyers and even judges - often
|
||
find themselves engulfed in litigation, stalked by private eyes,
|
||
framed for fictional crimes, beaten up or threatened with death.
|
||
Psychologist Margaret Singer, 69, an outspoken Scientology critic and
|
||
professor at the University of California, Berkeley, now travels
|
||
regularly under an assumed name to avoid harassment.
|
||
After the Los Angeles TIMES published a negative series on the
|
||
church last summer, Scientologists spent an estimated $1 million to
|
||
plaster the reporters' names on hundreds of billboards and bus
|
||
placards across the city. Above their names were quotations taken out
|
||
of context to portray the church in a positive light.
|
||
The church's most fearsome advocates are its lawyers. Hubbard
|
||
warned his followers in writing to "beware of attorneys tell you not
|
||
to sue...the purpose of the suit is to harass and discourage rather
|
||
than to win." Result: Scientology has brought hundreds of suits
|
||
against its perceived enemies and today pays an estimated $20 million
|
||
annually to more than 100 lawyers.
|
||
One legal goal of Scientology is to bankrupt the opposition or
|
||
bury it under paper. The church has 71 active lawsuits against the
|
||
IRS alone. One of them, "Miscavige vs. IRS," has required the U.S. to
|
||
produce an index of 52,000 pages of documents. Boston attorney
|
||
Michael Flynn, who helped Scientology victims from 1979 to 1987,
|
||
p\personally endured 14 frivolous lawsuits, all of them dismissed.
|
||
Another laywer, Joseph Yanny, believes the church "has so subverted
|
||
justice and the judicial system that it should be barred from seeking
|
||
equity in any court." He should know: Yanny represented the cult
|
||
until 1987, when, he says, he was asked to help church officials steal
|
||
medical records to blackmail an opposing attorney (who was allegedly
|
||
beaten up instead). Since Yanny quit representing the church, he has
|
||
been the target of death threats, burglaries, lawsuits and other
|
||
harassment.
|
||
|
||
Scientology's critics contend that the U.S. needs to crack down
|
||
on the church in a major, organized way. "I want to know, Where is
|
||
our government?" demands Toby Plevin, a Los Angeles attorney who
|
||
handles victims. "It shouldn't be left to private litigators, because
|
||
God knows most of us are afraid to get involved." But law-enforcement
|
||
agents are also wary. "Every investigator is very cautious, walking
|
||
on eggshells when it comes to the church," says a Florida police
|
||
detective who has tracked the cult since 1988. "It will take a
|
||
federal effort with lots of money and manpower."
|
||
So far the agency giving Scientology the most grief is the IRS,
|
||
whose officials have implied that Hubbard's successors may be looting
|
||
the church's coffers. Since 1988, when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld
|
||
the revocation of the cult's tax-exempt status, a massive IRS probe of
|
||
church centers across the country has been under way. An IRS agent,
|
||
Marcus Owens, has estimated that thousands of IRS employees have been
|
||
involved. Another agent, in an internal memorandum, spoke hopefully
|
||
of the "ultimate disintegration" of the church. A small but helpful
|
||
beacon shone last June when a federal appeals court ruled that two
|
||
cassette tapes featuring conversations between church officials and
|
||
their lawyers are evidence of a plan to commit "future frauds" against
|
||
the IRS.
|
||
Foreign governments have been moving even more vigorously against
|
||
the organization. In Canada the church and nine of its members will
|
||
be tried in June on charges of stealing government documents (many of
|
||
them retrieved in an enormous police raid of the church's Toronto
|
||
headquarters). Scientology proposed to give $1 million to the needy
|
||
if the case was dropped, but Canada spurned the offer. Since 1986
|
||
authorities in France, Spain and Italy have raided more than 50
|
||
Scientology centers. Pending charges against more than 100 of its
|
||
overseas church members include fraud, extortion, capital flight,
|
||
coercion, illegally practicing medicine and taking advantage of
|
||
medically incapacitated people. In Germany last month, leading
|
||
politicians accused the cult of trying to infiltrate a major party as
|
||
well as launching an immense recruitment drive in the east.
|
||
Sometimes even the church's biggest zealots can use a little
|
||
protection. Screen star Travolta, 37, has long served as an
|
||
unofficial Scientology spokesman, even though he told a magazine in
|
||
1983 that he was opposed to the church's management. High-level
|
||
defectors claim that Travolta has long feared that if he defected,
|
||
details of his sexual life would be made public. "He felt pretty
|
||
intimidated about this getting out and he told me so," recalls William
|
||
Franks, the church's former chairman of the board. "There were no
|
||
outright threats made, but it was implicit. If you leave, they
|
||
immediately start digging up everything." Franks was driven out in
|
||
1981 after attempting to reform the church.
|
||
|
||
The church's former head of security, Richard Aznaran, recalls
|
||
Scientology leader Miscavige repeatedly joking to staffers about
|
||
Travolta's allegedly promiscuous homosexual behavior. At this point
|
||
any threat to expose Travolta seems superfluous: last May a male porn
|
||
star collected $100,000 from a tabloid for an account of his alleged
|
||
two-year liaison with the celebrity. Travolta refuses to comment, and
|
||
in December his lawyer dismissed questions about the subject as
|
||
"bizarre." Two weeks later, Travolta announced that he was getting
|
||
married to actress Kelly Preston, a fellow Scientologist.
|
||
Shortly after Hubbard's death the church retained Trout & Reis, a
|
||
respected, Connecticut-based firm of marketing consultants, to help
|
||
boost its public image. "We were brutally honest," says Jack Trout.
|
||
"We advised them to clean up their act, stop with the controversy and
|
||
even to stop being a church. They didn't want to hear that."
|
||
Instead, Scientology hired one of the country's largest p.r. outfits,
|
||
Hill and Knowlton, whose executives refuse to discuss the lucrative
|
||
relationship. "Hill and Knowlton must feel that these guys are not
|
||
totally off the wall," says Trout. "Unless it's just for the money."
|
||
One of Scientology's main strategies it to keep advancing the
|
||
tired argument that the church is being "persecuted" by
|
||
anti-religionists. It is supported in that position by the American
|
||
Civil Liberties Union and the National Council of Churches. But in
|
||
the end, money is what Scientology is all about. As long as the
|
||
organization's opponents and victims are successfully squelched,
|
||
Scientology's managers and lawyers will keep pocketing millions of
|
||
dollars by helping it achieve its ends.
|
||
|
||
|
||
MINING MONEY IN VANCOUVER
|
||
|
||
One source of funds for the Los Angeles-based church is the
|
||
notorious, self-regulated stock exchange in Vancouver, British
|
||
Columbia, often called the scam capital of the world. The exchange's
|
||
2,300 penny-stock listings account for $4 billion in annual trading.
|
||
Local journalists and insiders claim the vast majority range from
|
||
total washouts to outright frauds.
|
||
Two Scientologists who operate there are Kenneth Gerbino and
|
||
Michael Baybak, 20-year church veterans from Beverly Hills who are
|
||
major donators to the cult. Gerbino, 45, is a money manager,
|
||
marketer, and publisher of a national financial newsletter. He has
|
||
boasted in Scientology journals that he owes all his stock-picking
|
||
success to L. Ron Hubbard. That's not saying much: Gerbino's
|
||
newsletter picks since 1985 have cumulatively returned 24%, while the
|
||
Dow Jones industrial average has more than doubled. Nevertheless
|
||
Gerbino's short-term gains can be stupendous. A survey last October
|
||
found Gerbino to be the only manager who made money in the third
|
||
quarter of 1990, thanks to gold and other resource stocks. For the
|
||
first quarter of 1991, Gerbino was dead last. Baybak, 49, who runs a
|
||
public relations company staffed with Scientologists, apparently has
|
||
no ethics problem with engineering a hostile takeover of a firm he is
|
||
hired to promote.
|
||
Neither man agreed to be interviewed for this story, yet both
|
||
threatened legal action through attorneys. "What these guys do is
|
||
take over companies, hype the stock, sell their shares, and then
|
||
there's nothing left," says John Campbell, a former securities lawyer
|
||
who was director of mining company Athena Gold until Baybak and
|
||
Gerbino took it over.
|
||
The pattern has become familiar. The pair promoted a mining
|
||
venture called Skylark Resources, whose stock traded at nearly $4 a
|
||
share in 1987. The outfit soon crashed, and the stock is around 2
|
||
cents. NETI Technologies, a software company, was trumpeted in the
|
||
press as "the next Xerox" and in 1984 rose to a market value of $120
|
||
million with Baybak's help. The company, which later collapsed, was
|
||
delisted two months ago by the Vancouver exchange.
|
||
Baybak appeared in 1989 at the helm of Wall Street Ventures, a
|
||
start-up that announced it owned 35 tons of rare Middle Eastern
|
||
postage stamps - worth $100 million - and was buying the world's
|
||
largest collection of southern Arabian stamps (worth $350 million).
|
||
Steven C. Rockefeller Jr. of the oil family and former hockey star
|
||
Dennis Potvin joined the company in top posts, but both say they quit
|
||
when they realized the stamps were virtually worthless. "The stamps
|
||
were created by sand-dune nations to exploit collectors," says Michael
|
||
Laurence, editor of LINN'S STAMP NEWS, America's largest stamp
|
||
journal. After the stock topped $6, it began a steady descent, with
|
||
Baybak unloading his shares along the way. Today it trades at 18
|
||
cents.
|
||
Athena Gold, the current object of Baybak and Gerbino's
|
||
attentions, was founded by entrepreneur William Jordan. He turned to
|
||
an established Vancouver broker in 1987 to help finance the company, a
|
||
4,500-acre mining property near Reno. The broker promised to raise
|
||
more than $3 million and soon brought Baybak and Gerbino into the
|
||
deal. Jordan never got most of the money, but the cult members ended
|
||
up with a good deal of cheap stock and options. Next time they
|
||
elected directors who were friendly to them and set in motion a series
|
||
of complex maneuvers to block Jordan from voting stock he controlled
|
||
and to run him out of the company. "I've been an honest policeman all
|
||
my life and I've seen the worst kinds of crimes, and this ranks high,"
|
||
says former Athena shareholder Thomas Clark, a 20-year veteran of
|
||
Reno's police force who has teamed up with Jordan to try to get the
|
||
gold mine back. "They stole this man's property."
|
||
With Baybak as chairman, the two Scientologists and their staffs
|
||
are promoting Athena, not always accurately. A letter to shareholders
|
||
with the 1990 annual report claims Placer Dome, one of America's
|
||
largest gold-mining firms, has committed at least $25.5 million to
|
||
develop the mine. That's news to Placer Dome. "There is no
|
||
pre-commitment," says Placer executive Cole McFarland. "We're not
|
||
going to spend that money unless survey results justify the
|
||
expenditure."
|
||
Baybak's firm represented Western Resource Technologies, a
|
||
Houston oil-and-gas company, but got the boot in October. Laughs
|
||
Steven McGuire, president of Western Resource: "His is a p.r. firm in
|
||
need of a p.r. firm." But McGuire cannot laugh too freely. Baybak
|
||
and other Scientologists, including the estate of L. Ron Hubbard,
|
||
still control huge blocks of his company's stock.
|
||
|
||
THE SCIENTOLOGISTS AND ME
|
||
|
||
Strange things seem to happen to people who write about
|
||
Scientology, Journalist Paulette Cooper wrote a critical book about
|
||
the cult in 1971. This led to a Scientology plot (called Operation
|
||
Freak-Out) whose goal, according to church documents, was "to get P.C.
|
||
incarcerated in a mental institution or jail." It almost worked: By
|
||
impersonating Cooper, Scientologists got her indicted in 1973 for
|
||
threatening to bomb the church. Cooper, who also endured 19 lawsuits
|
||
by the church, was finally exonerated in 1977 after FBI raids on the
|
||
church offices in Los Angeles and Washington uncovered documents from
|
||
the bomb scheme. No Scientologists were ever tried in the matter.
|
||
For the TIME story, at least 10 attorneys and six private
|
||
detectives were unleashed by Scientology and its followers in an
|
||
effort to threaten, harass, and discredit me. Last Oct. 12, not long
|
||
after I began this assignment, I planned to lunch with Eugene Ingram,
|
||
the church's leading private eye and a former cop. Ingram, who was
|
||
tossed off the Los Angeles police force in 1981 for alleged ties to
|
||
prostitutes and drug dealers, has told me that he might be able to
|
||
arrange a meeting with church boss David Miscavige. Just hours before
|
||
the lunch, the church's "national trial counsel," Earle Cooley, called
|
||
to inform me that I would be eating alone.
|
||
Alone, perhaps, but not forgotten. By day's end, I later
|
||
learned, a copy of my personal credit report - with detailed
|
||
information about my bank accounts, home mortgage, credit-card
|
||
payments, home address and Social Security number - had been illegally
|
||
retrieved from a national credit bureau called Trans Union. The sham
|
||
company that received it, "Educational Funding Services" of Los
|
||
Angeles, gave as its address a mail drop a few blocks from
|
||
Scientology's headquarters.
|
||
The owner of the mail drop is a private eye named Fred Wolfson,
|
||
who admits that an Ingram associate retained him to retrieve credit
|
||
reports on several individuals. Wolfson says he was told that
|
||
Scientology's attorneys "had judgments against these people and were
|
||
trying to collect on them." He says now, "They are vicious people.
|
||
They are vipers." Ingram, though a lawyer, denies any involvement in
|
||
the scam.
|
||
During the past five months, private investigators have been
|
||
contacting acquaintances of mine, ranging from neighbors to a former
|
||
colleague, to inquire about subjects such as my health (like my credit
|
||
rating, it's excellent) and whether I've ever had trouble with the IRS
|
||
(unlike Scientology, I haven't). One neighbor was greeted at dawn
|
||
outside my Manhattan apartment building by two men who wanted to know
|
||
whether I lived there. I finally called Cooley to demand that
|
||
Scientology stop the nonsense. He promised to look into it.
|
||
After that, however, an attorney subpoenaed me, while another
|
||
falsely suggested that I might own shares in a company I was reporting
|
||
about that had been taken over by Scientologists (he also threatened
|
||
to call the Securities and Exchange Commission). A close friend in
|
||
Los Angeles received a disturbing telephone call from a Scientology
|
||
staff member seeking data about me - an indication that the cult may
|
||
have illegally obtained my personal phone records. Two detectives
|
||
contacted me, posing as a friend and a relative of a so-called cult
|
||
victim, to elicit negative statements from me about Scientology. Some
|
||
of my conversations with them were taped, transcribed and presented by
|
||
the church in affidavits to TIME's lawyers as "proof" of my bias
|
||
against Scientology.
|
||
Among the comments I made to one of the detectives, who
|
||
represented himself as "Harry Baxter," a friend of the victim's
|
||
family, was that "the church trains people to lie." Baxter and his
|
||
colleagues are hardly in a position to dispute that observation. His
|
||
real name is Barry Silvers, and he is a former investigator for the
|
||
Justice Department's Organized Crime Strike Force.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|