removed debug info. Added explaination about the new method

This commit is contained in:
csoler 2017-11-01 20:31:49 +01:00
parent 69278e6e87
commit a9c43627ab

View File

@ -1036,10 +1036,10 @@ uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag(uint32_t withFlag)
unsigned long long sum = 0; unsigned long long sum = 0;
unsigned long long no_peers = 0; unsigned long long no_peers = 0;
uint32_t count = 0; uint32_t count = 0;
// bool doPrint = false;
// bool doAvg = false;
#ifdef BITDHT_DEBUG
std::cerr << "Estimating DHT network size. Flags=" << std::hex << withFlag << std::dec << std::endl; std::cerr << "Estimating DHT network size. Flags=" << std::hex << withFlag << std::dec << std::endl;
#endif
int i = 0; int i = 0;
for(it = buckets.begin(); it != buckets.end(); it++, i++) for(it = buckets.begin(); it != buckets.end(); it++, i++)
@ -1057,21 +1057,6 @@ uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag(uint32_t withFlag)
unsigned long long no_nets = ((unsigned long long) 1 << shift); unsigned long long no_nets = ((unsigned long long) 1 << shift);
// /* use doPrint so it acts as a single switch */
// if (size && !doAvg && !doPrint)
// doAvg = true;
//
// if (size && !doPrint)
// doPrint = true;
// if (size == 0)
// {
// /* reset counters - if empty slot - to discount outliers in average */
// sum = 0;
// no_peers = 0;
// count = 0;
// }
no_peers = no_nets * size; no_peers = no_nets * size;
if(size < mFns->bdNodesPerBucket() && size > 0) if(size < mFns->bdNodesPerBucket() && size > 0)
@ -1080,8 +1065,10 @@ uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag(uint32_t withFlag)
count++; count++;
} }
#ifdef BITDHT_DEBUG
if(size > 0) if(size > 0)
std::cerr << " Bucket " << shift << ": " << size << " / " << mFns->bdNodesPerBucket() << " peers. no_nets=" << no_nets << ". no_peers=" << no_peers << "." << std::endl; std::cerr << " Bucket " << shift << ": " << size << " / " << mFns->bdNodesPerBucket() << " peers. no_nets=" << no_nets << ". no_peers=" << no_peers << "." << std::endl;
#endif
} }
@ -1089,13 +1076,25 @@ uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag(uint32_t withFlag)
if (count != 0) if (count != 0)
NetSize = sum / count; NetSize = sum / count;
#ifdef BITDHT_DEBUG
std::cerr << "Estimated net size: " << NetSize << ". Old style estimate: " << calcNetworkSizeWithFlag_old(withFlag) << std::endl; std::cerr << "Estimated net size: " << NetSize << ". Old style estimate: " << calcNetworkSizeWithFlag_old(withFlag) << std::endl;
#endif
//std::cerr << "bdSpace::calcNetworkSize() : " << NetSize;
//std::cerr << std::endl;
return NetSize; return NetSize;
} }
/* (csoler) This is the old method for computing the DHT size estimate. The method is based on averaging the
* estimate given by each bucket: n 2^b where n is the bucket size and b is the number of similar bits
* in this bucket. The idea is that buckets that are not empty nor full give a estimate of the network
* size.
*
* The existing implementation of this method was not using all non empty/full buckets, in order to avoid
* outliers, but this method is also biased, and tends to give a lower value (because it skips the largest buckets)
* especially when the network is very sparse.
*
* The new implementation respects the original estimate without bias, but it still notoriously wrong. Only averaging
* the estimate over a large period of time would produce a reliable value.
*/
uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag_old(uint32_t withFlag) uint32_t bdSpace::calcNetworkSizeWithFlag_old(uint32_t withFlag)
{ {
std::vector<bdBucket>::iterator it; std::vector<bdBucket>::iterator it;