Awesome Linux Containers

Table of Contents

• Foundations
• Specifications
• Clouds
• Operating Systems
• Hypervisors
• Containers
• Sandboxes
• Partial Access
• Dashboard
• Best practices
• Security
  • Tools
  • Links
  • Levels of security problems
  • Technologies for security
• Another Information Sources

Foundations

• OPEN CONTAINER INITIATIVE
  The Open Container Initiative is a lightweight, open governance structure, to be formed under the auspices of the Linux Foundation, for the express purpose of creating open industry standards around container formats and runtime.
• Cloud Native Computing Foundation
  The Cloud Native Computing Foundation will create and drive the adoption of a new set of common container technologies informed by technical merit and end user value, and inspired by Internet-scale computing.
• Cloud Foundry Foundation
  The Cloud is our foundry.

Specifications

• Open Container Specifications
  This project is where the Open Container Initiative Specifications are written. This is a work in progress.
• App Container basics
  App Container (appc) is an open specification that defines several aspects of how to run applications in containers: an image format, runtime environment, and discovery protocol.
• Systemd Container Interface
  Systemd is a suite of basic building blocks for a Linux system. It provides a system and service manager that runs as PID 1 and starts the rest of the system. If you write a container solution, please consider supporting the following interfaces.
• Nulecule Specification
  Nulecule defines a pattern and model for packaging complex multi-container applications and services, referencing all their dependencies, including orchestration metadata in a container image for building, deploying, monitoring, and active management.
• Oracle microcontainer manifesto
  This is not a new container format, but simply a specific method for constructing a container that allows for better security and stability.

Clouds

• Amazon EC2 Container Service
  Container management service that supports Docker containers and allows you to easily run applications on a managed cluster of Amazon EC2 instances.
• Google Cloud Platform
  Run Docker containers on Google Cloud Platform, powered by Kubernetes. Google Container Engine actively schedules your containers, based on declared needs, on a managed cluster of virtual machines.
• Jelastic
  Unlimited PaaS and Container-Based IaaS in a Joint Cloud Solution for DevOps.
• Joyent
  High-Performance Container-Native Infrastructure for Today's Demanding Real-Time Web and Mobile Applications.
• Kubernetes
  Manage a cluster of Linux containers as a single system to accelerate Dev and simplify Ops.
• Mesosphere
  The Mesosphere Datacenter Operating System (DCOS) is a new kind of operating system that spans all of the machines in your datacenter or cloud. It provides a highly elastic, and highly scalable way of deploying applications, services and big data infrastructure on shared resources.
• OpenShift Origin
  OpenShift Origin is a distribution of Kubernetes optimized for continuous application development and multi-tenant deployment. Origin adds developer and operations-centric tools on top of Kubernetes to enable rapid application development, easy deployment and scaling, and long-term lifecycle maintenance for small and large teams.
• Warden
  Manages isolated, ephemeral, and resource controlled environments. Part of Cloud Foundry - the open platform as a service project.
• Virtuozzo DevOps
  A platform, built on Virtuozzo containers, that can be easily run on top of any bare-metal or virtual servers in any public or private cloud, to automate, optimize, and accelerate internal IT and development processes.
• Rancher
  Rancher is a complete, open source platform for deploying and managing containers in production. It includes commercially-supported distributions of Kubernetes, Mesos, and Docker Swarm, making it easy to run containerized applications on any infrastructure.
• Docker Swarm
  Docker Swarm is native clustering for Docker.
• Azure Container Service
  Azure Container Service optimizes the configuration of popular open source tools and technologies specifically for Azure.
• CIAO
  Cloud Integrated Advanced Orchestrator for Intel Clear Linux OS.
• Kontena
  Kontena is a developer friendly, open source platform for orchestrating applications that are run on Docker containers. It simplifies deploying and running containerized applications on any infrastructure.

Operating Systems

• CoreOs
  A lightweight Linux operating system designed for clustered deployments providing automation, security, and scalability for your most critical applications.
• RancherOS
  RancherOS is a tiny Linux distro that runs the entire OS as Docker containers.
• Project Atomic
  Project Atomic provides the best platform for your Linux Docker Kubernetes (LDK) application stack. Use immutable infrastructure to deploy and scale your containerized applications.
• Snappy Ubuntu Core
  Ubuntu Core is the perfect system for large-scale cloud container deployments, bringing transactional updates to the world’s favourite container platform.
• ResinOS
  A host OS tailored for containers, designed for reliability, proven in production.
• Photon
  Photon OS is a minimal Linux container host designed to have a small footprint and tuned for VMware platforms. Photon is intended to invite collaboration around running containerized and Linux applications in a virtualized environment.
• Clear Linux Project
  The Clear Linux Project for Intel Architecture is a distribution built for various Cloud use cases.
• CargOS
  CargOS is a new lightweight, open source, platform for Docker hosts that aims for speed, manageability and security. Releases are built for 64-bit Intel/AMD CPUs.
• OSv
  OSv is the open source operating system designed for the cloud. Built from the ground up for effortless deployment and management, with superior performance.
• HypriotOS - Minimal Debian-based operating systems that is optimized to run Docker. It made it dead easy use Docker on any Raspberry Pi.

Hypervisors

• Docker
  An open platform for distributed applications for developers and sysadmins. Standard de facto.
• LXD
  Daemon based on liblxc offering a REST API to manage LXC containers.
• OpenVZ
  OpenVZ is container-based virtualization for Linux. OpenVZ creates multiple secure, isolated Linux containers (otherwise known as VEs or VPSs) on a single physical server enabling better server utilization and ensuring that applications do not conflict.

Containers

• runc
  runc is a CLI tool for spawning and running containers according to the OCS specification.
• Bocker
  Docker implemented in around 100 lines of bash.
• Rocket
  rkt (pronounced "rock-it") is a CLI for running app containers on Linux. rkt is designed to be composable, secure, and fast. Based on AppC specification.
• LXC
  LXC is the well known set of tools, templates, library and language bindings. It's pretty low level, very flexible and covers just about every containment feature supported by the upstream kernel.
• Vagga
  Vagga is a fully-userspace container engine inspired by Vagrant and Docker, specialized for development environments.
• libct
  Libct is a containers management library which provides convenient API for frontend programs to rule a container during its whole lifetime.
• libvirt
  A big toolkit to interact with the virtualization capabilities of recent versions of Linux (and other OSes).
• systemd-nspawn
  Spawn a namespace container for debugging, testing and building. Part of systemd.
• porto
  The main goal of Porto is to create a convenient, reliable interface over several Linux kernel mechanism such as cgroups, namespaces, mounts, networking etc.
• udocker
  A basic user tool to execute simple containers in batch or interactive systems without root privileges.
• Let Me Contain That For You
  LMCTFY is the open source version of Google’s container stack, which provides Linux application containers.
• cc-oci-runtime
  Intel Clear Linux OCI (Open Containers Initiative) compatible runtime.
• railcar
  Railcar is a rust implementation of the opencontainers initiative's runtime spec. It is similar to the reference implementation runc, but it is implemented completely in rust for memory safety without needing the overhead of a garbage collector or multiple threads.

Sandboxes

• Firejail
  Firejail is a SUID sandbox program that reduces the risk of security breaches by restricting the running environment of untrusted applications using Linux namespaces, seccomp-bpf and Linux capabilities.
• NsJail
  NsJail is a process isolation tool for Linux. It makes use of the namespacing, resource control, and seccomp-bpf syscall filter subsystems of the Linux kernel.
• Subuser
  Securing the Linux desktop with Docker.
• Snappy
  Snappy Ubuntu Core is a new rendition of Ubuntu with transactional updates - a minimal server image with the same libraries as today’s Ubuntu, but applications are provided through a simpler mechanism.
• xdg-app
  xdg-app is a system for building, distributing and running sandboxed desktop applications on Linux.
• Bubblewrap
  Run applications in a sandbox using Linux namespaces without root privileges, with user namespacing provided via setuid binary.

Partial Access

• nsenter
  Run program with namespaces of other processes. Part of the util-linux.
• ip-netns
  Process network namespace management. Part of the iproute2.
• unshare
  Run program with some namespaces unshared from parent. Part of the util-linux.
• python-nsenter
  This Python package allows entering Linux kernel namespaces (mount, IPC, net, PID, user and UTS) by doing the "setns" syscall.
• butter
  Python library to interface to low level linux features (inotify, fanotify, timerfd, signalfd, eventfd, containers) with asyncio support.
• pyspaces
  Works with Linux namespaces through glibc with pure python.
• CRIU
  Checkpoint/Restore In Userspace is a software tool for Linux operating system. Using this tool, you can freeze a running application (or part of it) and checkpoint it to a hard drive as a collection of files. CRIU integrated with Docker and LXC to implement Live migration of containers.

Dashboard

• LXC-Web-Panel
  Web panel for LXC on Ubuntu.

Best practices

• The Twelve-Factor App
  The twelve-factor app is a methodology for building software-as-a-service apps.
• Container Best Practices
  A collaborative project to document container-based application architecture, creation and management from Project Atomic.

Security

Tools

• Docker bench security
  The Docker Bench for Security is a script that checks for dozens of common best-practices around deploying Docker containers in production.
• CoreOS Clair
  Open Source Vulnerability Analysis for your Containers.
• bane
  Custom AppArmor profile generator for docker containers.
• OpenSCAP
  The OpenSCAP ecosystem provides multiple tools to assist administrators and auditors with assessment, measurement and enforcement of security baselines.
• drydock
  Drydock provides a flexible way of assessing the security of your Docker daemon configuration and containers using editable audit templates.
• trireme
  Security by segmentation for Docker and Kubernetes.
• goss
  Quick and Easy server testing/validation.

Links

• CIS Security Benchmarks
• Are Docker containers really secure?
• Bringing new security features to Docker
• Docker, Linux Containers (LXC), and security
• For containers, security is problem #1
• Linux Container Security
• Ask HN: Best Linux sandbox?
• CIS Docker 1.6 Benchmark v1.0.0
• Understanding docker security and best practices
• Update on Ubuntu Phone security issue
• Don't expose the Docker socket (not even to a container)
• RedHat Blog
  • Introduction to Linux Containers
  • What’s Next for Containers? User Namespaces
  • Architecting Containers Part 1: Why Understanding User Space vs. Kernel Space Matters
  • Architecting Containers Part 2: Why the User Space Matters
  • Secure Your Containers with this One Weird Trick
• Why you shouldn't use ENV variables for secret data

Levels of security problems

1. regular application

• always untrusted -> know it
• suid bit -> mount with nosuid
• limit available syscall -> seccomp-bpf, grsec
• leak to another container (bug in namespaces, filesystem) -> user namespaces with different uid inside for each container: 1000 in container - 14293 and 15398 outside; security modules like selinux or apparmor

2. system services like cron, ssh

• run as root -> isolate via bastion host or vm
• using /dev -> "devices" control group
  The following device nodes are created in the container by default.
  The Docker images are also mounted with nodev, which means that even if a device node was pre-created in the image, it could not be used by processes within the container to talk to the kernel.
  /dev/console,/dev/null,/dev/zero,/dev/full,/dev/tty*,/dev/urandom,/dev/random,/dev/fuse
• root calls -> capabilities (cap_sys_admin warning!)
  Here is the current list of capabilities that Docker uses: chown, dac_override, fowner, kill, setgid, setuid, setpcap, net_bind_service, net_raw, sys_chroot, mknod, setfcap, and audit_write.
  Docker removes several of these capabilities including the following:
  CAP_SETPCAP Modify process capabilities
  CAP_SYS_MODULE Insert/Remove kernel modules
  CAP_SYS_RAWIO Modify Kernel Memory
  CAP_SYS_PACCT Configure process accounting
  CAP_SYS_NICE Modify Priority of processes
  CAP_SYS_RESOURCE Override Resource Limits
  CAP_SYS_TIME Modify the system clock
  CAP_SYS_TTY_CONFIG Configure tty devices
  CAP_AUDIT_WRITE Write the audit log
  CAP_AUDIT_CONTROL Configure Audit Subsystem
  CAP_MAC_OVERRIDE Ignore Kernel MAC Policy
  CAP_MAC_ADMIN Configure MAC Configuration
  CAP_SYSLOG Modify Kernel printk behavior
  CAP_NET_ADMIN Configure the network
  CAP_SYS_ADMIN Catch all
  uses /proc, /sys -> remount ro, drop cap_sys_admin; security modules like selinux or apparmor; some part of this fs are "namespace-aware"
  Docker mounts these file systems into the container as "read-only" mount points.
  . /sys
  . /proc/sys
  . /proc/sysrq-trigger
  . /proc/irq
  . /proc/bus
  Copy-on-write file systems
  Docker uses copy-on-write file systems. This means containers can use the same file system image as the base for the container. When a container writes content to the image, it gets written to a container specific file system. This prevents one container from seeing the changes of another container even if they wrote to the same file system image. Just as important, one container can not change the image content to effect the processes in another container.
• uid 0 -> user namespaces, uid 0 mappet to random uid outside

3. system services like devices, network, filesystems

• root -> more of services should work on host outside; isolate sensitive functions, run as non-privileged context
• full privileges -> isolate on kernel level

4. kernel drivers, network stack, security policies

• absolute privileges -> run it in separate vm

5. general like immutable infrastructure

• container is ro
• write to small separate rw nosuid part

src
src

Technologies for security

Things are better. For example, most modern container technologies can make use of Linux's built-in security tools such as:
AppArmor, SELinux and Seccomp policies;
Grsecurity;
Control groups (cgroups);
Kernel namespaces
src

Sure, you're deploying seccomp, but you can't use selinux inside your container, because the policy isn't per-namespace (?? lxc uses apparmore for each container...)
sVirt - selinux for kvm
src

Major kernel subsystems are not namespaced like:

• SELinux
• Cgroups
• file systems under /sys
• /proc/sys, /proc/sysrq-trigger, /proc/irq, /proc/bus

Devices are not namespaced:

• /dev/mem
• /dev/sd* file system devices
• kernel modules

If you can communicate or attack one of these as a privileged process, you can own the system.
src

Another Information Sources

• sysdig-container-ecosystem
  The ecosystem of awesome new technologies emerging around containers and microservices can be a little overwhelming, to say the least. We thought we might be able to help: welcome to the Container Ecosystem Project.
• doger.io
  This page is an attempt to document the ins and outs of containers on Linux. This is not just restricted to programmers looking to implement containers or use container like features in their own code but also Sysadmins and Users who want to get more of a handle on how containers work 'under the hood'.